{"success":true,"data":{"result":[{"indicators":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.149107789196032,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.4976002068704504,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.610519366901214,"federation_revenue_performance":1.4700517749654232,"igr_performance":2.1835794859464963,"aids_grant_performance":1.0906323680859367,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":1.4114516575506666,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.0681020838368251,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.3152786815142339,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.9814554889156639,"total_expenditure_performance":1.149107789196032},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7959819379939153,"satutory_allocation":0.5835246859404489,"derivation":0.17604527303939296,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.19186854097875095,"igr":0.21561087192230494,"tax_revenue":0.21245725205346633,"personal_taxes":0.10798208532674479,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.1002407133768911,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.04369570794791764,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.03157800984017693,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.013950489334273447,"other_taxes":0.011016506254523073,"sales_taxes":0.007741371949853712,"lottery_tax":0.00018752502923782323,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0.0012001278037657213,"withholding_tax":0.000016156287446882055,"other_taxes_nec":0.006337562829403284,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.10447516672672155,"fees_general":0.0018181179507486625,"fines_general":0.07776608994215381,"sales_general":0.003204393889164718,"earnings_general":0.0011880273991570916,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.017190989389493115,"rent_on_land_others_general":0,"repayments":0.00032780357148630033,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.002979744584517846,"domestic_aids":0.1389136129673237,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.1389136129673237,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.06510444903876103,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.009582474699901202,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.05552197433885983,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.9917107631966516,"derivation":0.7270111091924208,"vat":0.21933411268484576,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.23904825992285225,"tax_revenue":0.2686287365847227,"personal_taxes":0.2646996540042308,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.1345344550415799,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.12488951020284758,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.05444031052596404,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.03934291815434716,"other_taxes":0.017380859746047188,"sales_taxes":0.013725421776489203,"lottery_tax":0.009644944838732336,"property_tax":0.0002336366957428847,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.0014952345064582647,"other_taxes_nec":0.00002012905493151324,"non_tax_revenue":0.007895944581599673,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.13016519896265094,"fines_general":0.002265185997891665,"sales_general":0.09688846533593375,"earnings_general":0.00399234173254635,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.001480158659989115,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.02141818600875097,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0.0004084091793295844,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.0037124520482095056,"foreign_aids":0.1730719235682983,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.1730719235682983,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.08111337677642225,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.011938767507591699,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0.06917460926883055,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.19936655946716117,"ovetimes_payments":0.14229947153926478,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.14229947153926478,"allowances":0.13404943618737303,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.00825003535189175,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.0013253153789275784,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0.0013253153789275784,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.0557417725489688,"gratuity_arrears":0.007380140715749479,"pension_arrears":0.04658326987362314,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.001778361959596186,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.39766760379787836,"materials_supplies_general":0.21363340255496138,"maintainance_services_general":0.026226118933496082,"training_general":0.0008902270859312511,"other_servies_general":0.004249690460185561,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.010525485426409159,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0031917532483540065,"financial_general":0.1304473331876063,"miscellaneous_general":0.003522338994881513,"loans_advances":0.004465612989274652,"staff_loans_advances":0.000001481870754549864,"grants_contribution_general":0.03011336035806832,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.07785561030622469,"public_debt_charges":0.07785561030622469,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.08002019010704205,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.001961797429860161,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.033500471576237846,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.033500471576237846,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.011027846149099702,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.011027846149099702,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.03549187238170448,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.03549187238170448,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.026158400829650284,"construction_provision":0.026158400829650284,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.20560100772793244,"preservation_of_environment":0.018159851212752057,"other_capital_projects":0.17771771190255548},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.003739308196683315,"personal_cost":0.005984136415941594,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.248390011641923,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.17729035143478752,"allowances":0.17729035143478752,"social_contribution":0.16701166486578845,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.01027868656899909,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.0016512052135567122,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0.0016512052135567122,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.06944845499357875,"pension_arrears":0.009194888266133681,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.05803791256243247,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.002215654165012609,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.4954525021697067,"maintainance_services_general":0.26616501528417574,"training_general":0.03267501834121062,"other_servies_general":0.0011091304220196526,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.005294672615614513,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.013113660859625254,"financial_general":0.0039765928079196445,"miscellaneous_general":0.16252381891790849,"loans_advances":0.00438846828818115,"staff_loans_advances":0.005563689644636508,"grants_contribution_general":0.0000018462569397707587,"grants_to_other_states":0.03751811713012013,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0.09699999840513643,"foreign_debt_interest":0.09699999840513643,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.09969683985819594,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.0024441956953283554,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.04173810566361436,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.04173810566361436,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0137395501065032,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.0137395501065032,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.04421918408807836,"capital_expenditure":0.04421918408807836,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0.032590648622198654,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.032590648622198654,"preservation_of_environment":0.25615748618837025,"other_capital_projects":0.0226252871404648},"expenditure":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.22141779768097353,"recurrent_expenditure":0.004658789362615729,"capital_expenditure":0.0074556120043162075,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":130507295495.95001,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":97076874752.48001,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":33430420743.47},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.7438425138117475,"governors_office":0.25615748618825246,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.5970341632654086,"state_assembly":0.20560100772793244,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":18544546634.379997,"office_head_of_service":12198793895.98,"office_auditor_general_state":2265444250.07,"office_auditor_general_lga":2004119371.24,"civil_service_commission":409453282.8,"lga_service_commission":0,"state_inec":283550321.31,"economic_sector":190496386.67,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":52856588.23,"ministry_finance":1040318733.45,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0,"ministry_labour_productivity":99513804.63,"ministry_science_tech":77925585395.16,"ministry_transport":862660039.9999999,"ministry_energy":45211535232.93,"ministry_works":8942854178.71,"ministry_culture_tourism":32100901.43,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":60269084.18,"ministry_water_resources":1440247877.6200001,"ministry_housing_urban_development":17224733275.39,"ministry_land_survey":117837803.64,"law_justuce_sector":1942652928.23,"judiciary":24702880.79,"ministry_justice":692646098.99,"regional_sector":1219886691.9,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":153458401.35000002,"state_capital_dev_agency":1098534312.76,"social_sector":578006000,"ministry_youth_development":520528312.76,"ministry_women_affairs":20324828.509999998,"ministry_education":20324828.509999998,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":32918304325.140003,"ministry_sports":45754568.440000005,"minsitry_lga":243290369.9},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","admin_sector":17343383315.100002,"governors_office":14535715372.75,"secretary_to_state_gov":543778501.14,"state_assembly":101911422.52,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":104470775.28999999,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.1420958618743579,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.09347212237927473,"civil_service_commission":0.017358755627123884,"lga_service_commission":0.015356378075454907,"state_inec":0.00313739765462303,"economic_sector":0,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.002172677935226462,"ministry_finance":0.0014596608254440395,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00040500868575323886,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.007971345429365381,"ministry_science_tech":0,"ministry_transport":0.0007625152620922555,"ministry_energy":0.5970975423179624,"ministry_works":0.00661005223288201,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.34642917900596465,"state_planning_commission":0.06852378746130428,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.00024597016824251744,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0004618062457810876,"ministry_land_survey":0.011035765258543398,"law_justuce_sector":0.13198291490097155,"judiciary":0.000902921198330334,"ministry_justice":0.014885397179126887,"regional_sector":0.0001892835239297251,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.00530733624015535,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.009347268191136621,"social_sector":0.0011758607115939569,"ministry_youth_development":0.008417416885285127,"ministry_women_affairs":0.004428917155962387,"ministry_education":0.003988499729322739,"ministry_health":0.00015573710598148192,"ministry_environment":0.00015573710598148192,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.25223344181687285},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0003505901203924721,"governors_office":0.0018641898062140274,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.13289205978255975,"state_assembly":0.11137856560063163,"ministry_of_info":0.0041666521329232886,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0007808867859284498,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0008004975882232579,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.11405113639291899,"lga_service_commission":0.07502401292896517,"state_inec":0.013932747791001794,"economic_sector":0.012325569142425474,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.002518185702991305,"ministry_finance":0,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0017438677260531484,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0011715751162220194,"ministry_science_tech":0.0003250742157431897,"ministry_transport":0.006398082201742729,"ministry_energy":0,"ministry_works":0.0006120215677741683,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.4792514879778611,"state_planning_commission":0.005305460404211728,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.27805624332840734,"ministry_water_resources":0.05499960186609003,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.00019742430804650307,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.00037066193504812567,"judiciary":0.00885769333532928,"ministry_justice":0.10593412946969218,"regional_sector":0.0007247163104150468,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.011947543310166812,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0001519256135954872,"social_sector":0.004259854730634286,"ministry_youth_development":0.007502446202910109,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0009437871633141333,"ministry_education":0.006756114841039957,"ministry_health":0.003554804678789578,"ministry_environment":0.003201310162250379,"ministry_sports":0.00012500007868939734,"minsitry_lga":0.00012500007868939734},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.20245143170283159,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.00028139596122965846,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0014962643038739514,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.10666384112718309},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.0893963540458149,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.0033443015471771153,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0006267671989498336,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0006425075186030362},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":18544546634.379997,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":77925585395.16,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":1098534312.76,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":20324828.509999998},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":32918304325.140003,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.1420958618743579,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5970975423179624,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.008417416885285127,"health_total_expenditure":0.00015573710598148192,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.25223344181687285,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.11405113639291899},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.4792514879778611,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.006756114841039957,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.00012500007868939734,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.20245143170283159,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ekiti","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.6331202512318,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.6750665803922794,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.1282366904945629,"federation_revenue_performance":1.2842495378349337,"igr_performance":0.5378483661034992,"aids_grant_performance":0.2557157419488078,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.04195608337679248,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.4117163389522395,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.1258413312869773,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.5330969708510837,"total_expenditure_performance":0.6331202512318},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.8980208881022563,"satutory_allocation":0.8085392092331742,"derivation":0.5328719348658398,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.27566727436733446,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.08948167886908204,"personal_taxes":0.0586107881794137,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.0586107881794137,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.0586107881794137,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.030870890689668345,"fees_general":0.0008329533711716798,"fines_general":0.026163280449867973,"sales_general":0.0009388913792447274,"earnings_general":0.002298875913885004,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0004323419462191963,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0002045476292797637,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.08759505481903945,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.08759505481903945,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.014384057078704146,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.014384057078704146,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.9542013935052384,"derivation":0.8591217090554666,"vat":0.5662085921891369,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.2929131168663297,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.09507968444977175,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.06227749988468936,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.06227749988468936,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.06227749988468936,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.032802184565082396,"fines_general":0.0008850632296276826,"sales_general":0.02780006455828636,"earnings_general":0.000997628757075593,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0024426944067640864,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0004593894117818654,"repayments":0.00021734420154681145,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.09307503252973072,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.09307503252973072,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.015283928793419674,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.015283928793419674,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.1329067325412201,"ovetimes_payments":0.08087559813203313,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.08087559813203313,"allowances":0.0738826291942454,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.006992968937787737,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.052031134409186976,"gratuity_arrears":0,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.052031134409186976,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.35682727331212793,"materials_supplies_general":0.14944664201146912,"maintainance_services_general":0.01765210218497541,"training_general":0.0027425255570983475,"other_servies_general":0.012555787652618732,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.019935183228143024,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0030782823573405923,"financial_general":0.024379016515478514,"miscellaneous_general":0.01550118858674623,"loans_advances":0.017387290677730618,"staff_loans_advances":0.0009406062021916604,"grants_contribution_general":0.03527465904914602,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.03792758329407329,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.007973201404681378,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.007973201404681378,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.029954381889391906,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.029954381889391906,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.16945304800658553,"construction_provision":0.16945304800658553,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.45138900467108206,"preservation_of_environment":0.07385782453194485,"other_capital_projects":0.2348678268891478},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.055455561311404396,"personal_cost":0.004823411480461011,"salaries_wages":0.08238438045812399,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.1412214248880806,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.0859352042481313,"allowances":0.0859352042481313,"social_contribution":0.07850475269229167,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.0074304515558396384,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.0552862206399493,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0.0552862206399493,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.3791505141429811,"maintainance_services_general":0.15879607696361783,"training_general":0.018756423961134448,"other_servies_general":0.0029140989290763445,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.013341282183316462,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.021182335364464597,"financial_general":0.0032708607938777886,"miscellaneous_general":0.025904176439054,"loans_advances":0.016470948444994846,"staff_loans_advances":0.01847504575203378,"grants_contribution_general":0.000999450859954554,"grants_to_other_states":0.03748145423571103,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.04030034636273378,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.008472007713676453,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.008472007713676453,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.031828338649057326,"capital_expenditure":0.031828338649057326,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0.18005409081662954,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.18005409081662954,"preservation_of_environment":0.47962806096893823,"other_capital_projects":0.0784783962415162},"expenditure":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.24956124147710548,"recurrent_expenditure":0.058924880904253324,"capital_expenditure":0.005125165814161976,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.08753837653190122,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":109678293878.31999,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":57073506455.08,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":52604787423.23999},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.5203719390310617,"governors_office":0.4796280609689383,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.489734005853348,"state_assembly":0.45138900467108206,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":37276252915.96,"office_head_of_service":12575168642.630005,"office_auditor_general_state":6948039165.209999,"office_auditor_general_lga":4510171945.43,"civil_service_commission":989134662.45,"lga_service_commission":8811070502.43,"state_inec":2043098727.46,"economic_sector":117866126.61,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":54579466.76,"ministry_finance":150108257.36,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":7119445.07,"ministry_labour_productivity":1069895974.55,"ministry_science_tech":51198941646.740005,"ministry_transport":5491989637.27,"ministry_energy":24743294543.09,"ministry_works":87362861.49000001,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":49451381.72,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":1856375883.88,"ministry_water_resources":67376847.33,"ministry_housing_urban_development":10022890545.41,"ministry_land_survey":182571231.22,"law_justuce_sector":3110017931.0899997,"judiciary":10812250.46,"ministry_justice":1697295575.82,"regional_sector":3394027264.41,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":485475693.5500017,"state_capital_dev_agency":3542852214.9300003,"social_sector":1561938237.8199997,"ministry_youth_development":1980913977.1100001,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":17660157100.690002,"ministry_sports":282409343.54,"minsitry_lga":40748042.45},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","admin_sector":10653683280.01,"governors_office":5931939522.73,"secretary_to_state_gov":482118190.69000113,"state_assembly":215521921.48000002,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":53736799.79,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.33986900778485174,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.11465503517570422,"civil_service_commission":0.06334926373780338,"lga_service_commission":0.04112182808417593,"state_inec":0.009018508835917635,"economic_sector":0.08033559048798876,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.018628104570323347,"ministry_finance":0.00107465317376986,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0004976323466569592,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0013686231983744575,"ministry_science_tech":0.00006491206982029189,"ministry_transport":0.009754856104316966,"ministry_energy":0.4668101575644627,"ministry_works":0.050073623896474524,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.22559882788239635,"state_planning_commission":0.0007965373858470362,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.00045087664998566323,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.016925645159465305,"ministry_land_survey":0.0006143134156039084,"law_justuce_sector":0.09138444983954308,"judiciary":0.001664606776456145,"ministry_justice":0.028355819744427604,"regional_sector":0.00009858149755680368,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.015475218621681192,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.030945295959612786,"social_sector":0.004426360735412253,"ministry_youth_development":0.03230221851244818,"ministry_women_affairs":0.014241088027434628,"ministry_education":0.01806113048501355,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.1610177955565451},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.002574888189392446,"governors_office":0.00037152330702013795,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.09713574950235347,"state_assembly":0.05408489969137421,"ministry_of_info":0.004395748453425759,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0019650371450809193,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0004899492678981406,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.31985854379043066,"lga_service_commission":0.1079044918763432,"state_inec":0.05961944980342763,"economic_sector":0.03870069864484771,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.00848752618609998,"ministry_finance":0.07560567277231375,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.017531337853586605,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0010113808301679243,"ministry_science_tech":0.0004683332522201344,"ministry_transport":0.0012880427847277438,"ministry_energy":0.0000610902425686451,"ministry_works":0.009180519544127397,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.4393257808304507,"state_planning_commission":0.047125439669318155,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.2123162480674636,"ministry_water_resources":0.0007496396625636223,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.0004243303902096772,"law_justuce_sector":0.015929114127544237,"judiciary":0.0005781444910986957,"ministry_justice":0.08600400854810956,"regional_sector":0.0015665997407977744,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.026686314443763785,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.00009277731576266585,"social_sector":0.014564084337760325,"ministry_youth_development":0.02912333009508027,"ministry_women_affairs":0.00416574994097831,"ministry_education":0.03040036113305321,"ministry_health":0.013402615637522696,"ministry_environment":0.01699774549553051,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.15153755250218293,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.002423286524564818,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0003496491331827844,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.09141668900120181},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.05090054362145792,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.004136940017996159,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0018493416737708863,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0004611025300085386},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":37276252915.96,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":51198941646.740005,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":3542852214.9300003,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":17660157100.690002,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.33986900778485174,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.4668101575644627,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.03230221851244818,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.1610177955565451,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.31985854379043066},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.4393257808304507,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.03040036113305321,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.15153755250218293,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"taraba","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.109778179943509,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.2077040548378495,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.0687722949914786,"federation_revenue_performance":1.4500246682529239,"igr_performance":0.5674048112948977,"aids_grant_performance":2.374037329565704,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":1.1002775897651698,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.010299957358854,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.0655011130720773,"capital_expenditure_performance":1.286470471221622,"total_expenditure_performance":1.109778179943509},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7239030125370551,"satutory_allocation":0.5578957559327956,"derivation":0.1701375916597048,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.2070806081144324,"igr":0.18067755615865844,"tax_revenue":0.16600725660425947,"personal_taxes":0.0682340063593879,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.05808393636198958,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.05808393636198958,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.010150069997398306,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.010150069997398306,"licances_general":0.09777325024487157,"fees_general":0.0036752301779676647,"fines_general":0.056981800225640464,"sales_general":0.00029318467632796465,"earnings_general":0.0036020128910772557,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.016610129857018614,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00004554174072212375,"repayments":0.0011544434905480495,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.0003002579534648797,"reimbursement":0.00010819182709632724,"miscellaneous_income":0.0000019762325751635603,"aids_grants":0.015000481172433088,"domestic_aids":0.20555924236174675,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.17875767010968907,"capital_development_fund":0.026801572252057676,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.07053774510119812,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.05883852875201538,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0.011699216349182745,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.7877795935714277,"derivation":0.607123999005965,"vat":0.185150386844181,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.2253532233899374,"tax_revenue":0.19662038877184662,"personal_taxes":0.1806555945654626,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.07425491656563216,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.06320921309598031,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.06320921309598031,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.011045703469651853,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.011045703469651853,"fees_general":0.10640067799983044,"fines_general":0.003999529337132866,"sales_general":0.06200982541211008,"earnings_general":0.00031905504074303313,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.003919851419635628,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.018075793471381576,"repayments":0.00004956030486856624,"investment_income":0.0012563105941468505,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0003267524577887341,"miscellaneous_income":0.00011773858113808032,"aids_grants":0.0000021506136428535364,"domestic_aids":0.016324110767242175,"foreign_aids":0.22369761362790058,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.194531093624338,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.029166520003562603,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.07676193523842034,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.06403039007139202,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0.012731545167028319,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.2749885400983937,"ovetimes_payments":0.18082131230783988,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.18082131230783988,"allowances":0.18082131230783988,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.06351813116476131,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0.035258989723825275,"social_benefit":0.0021022562789362,"gratuity":0.01863113390948917,"pension":0.007525751252510676,"death_benefit":0.03064909662579251,"gratuity_arrears":0.007867471956191134,"pension_arrears":0.022781624669601378,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.34300783531047685,"materials_supplies_general":0.21995890557171877,"maintainance_services_general":0.0262191943090296,"training_general":0.007343816744817236,"other_servies_general":0.0310677780691082,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.03207046986350279,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.011488244903673369,"financial_general":0.019721477184801012,"miscellaneous_general":0.015028584292987613,"loans_advances":0.0056474151001638245,"staff_loans_advances":0.001419651784212537,"grants_contribution_general":0.06995227331942261,"grants_to_other_states":8.982875341652547e-7,"grants_to_lga":8.982875341652547e-7,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.011420445519471325,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.0023982924341185846,"subsidies_general":0.002089764265440204,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.006840823916235811,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0.00009156490367672447,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.011455255478429524,"public_debt_charges":0.000010629735820955513,"foreign_debt_interest":0.0032534395148265875,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.008191186227781982,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.10017233045332308,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.009423173214816638,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.009423173214816638,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.09074915723850643,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.09074915723850643,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.3009192939539449,"preservation_of_environment":0.05445016779275358,"other_capital_projects":0.2045827795874502},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.009147051146693121,"personal_cost":0.014693529608028132,"salaries_wages":0.01804576581901989,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.29925329305688436,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.19677682984035197,"allowances":0.19677682984035197,"social_contribution":0.19677682984035197,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.06912291658798828,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0.038370212740277,"gratuity":0.0022877575701739025,"pension":0.02027512918830535,"death_benefit":0.00818981708923203,"gratuity_arrears":0.03335354662854413,"pension_arrears":0.008561690934758476,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.02479185569378566,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.3732745525477018,"maintainance_services_general":0.23936789077091294,"training_general":0.028532753530267067,"other_servies_general":0.007991828836599886,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0338091721633726,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.034900340621833933,"financial_general":0.012501957782088343,"miscellaneous_general":0.021461683419193477,"loans_advances":0.016354693683054256,"staff_loans_advances":0.006145738165592272,"grants_contribution_general":0.001544920640211671,"grants_to_other_states":0.07612480192869946,"grants_to_lga":9.775516558425164e-7,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":9.775516558425164e-7,"grants_to_private_companies":0.0124281758383665,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.0026099157018201493,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.0022741632721196997,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0.0074444523521720995,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.00009964451225455367,"public_debt_charges":0.012466057398251467,"foreign_debt_interest":0.000011567694594136446,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.00354052022758797,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.00891396947606936,"domestic_debt_interest":0.10901145098851507,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.01025466593833442,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.01025466593833442,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.09875678505018065,"capital_expenditure":0.09875678505018065,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.3274721543954138,"other_capital_projects":0.059254803904377665},"expenditure":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.2226349886157777,"recurrent_expenditure":0.009954179095711547,"capital_expenditure":0.0159900740600242,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.019638108719522637,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":153444576666.09998,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":103195750564.95998,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":50248826101.14},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6725278456045862,"governors_office":0.3274721543954138,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.6179963754088705,"state_assembly":0.3009192939539449,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":40917737954.50999,"office_head_of_service":19298781779.41,"office_auditor_general_state":379099875.5100055,"office_auditor_general_lga":2645503094.03,"civil_service_commission":1557824789.17,"lga_service_commission":478285715.26,"state_inec":16070557148.419998,"economic_sector":174043816.86,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":129040534.52,"ministry_finance":116221824.24,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":26888857.24,"ministry_labour_productivity":41490519.85,"ministry_science_tech":65366005125.05,"ministry_transport":1777648251.44,"ministry_energy":28484373302.14,"ministry_works":337369181.02,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":253371918.67,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":402563970.46,"ministry_water_resources":20410196.82,"ministry_housing_urban_development":27821567355.25,"ministry_land_survey":359870711.20000005,"law_justuce_sector":1195639140.57,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":2030736163.46,"regional_sector":2132198616.5,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":550256317.52,"state_capital_dev_agency":1810170592.11,"social_sector":1538051442.8899999,"ministry_youth_development":272119149.22,"ministry_women_affairs":48294467.730000004,"ministry_education":20410196.82,"ministry_health":27884270.91,"ministry_environment":45302368526.7,"ministry_sports":303734062.76,"minsitry_lga":311216957.53},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","admin_sector":27824160470.329998,"governors_office":14196394422.25,"secretary_to_state_gov":2311627444.56,"state_assembly":278306487.02,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":76928682.25,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.26666134993840945,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.12577037389470422,"civil_service_commission":0.0024705980735633183,"lga_service_commission":0.01724077286737018,"state_inec":0.010152361347771019,"economic_sector":0.003116993286121569,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.10473199833833173,"ministry_finance":0.0011342454757376315,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0008409585879388627,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0007574189115389994,"ministry_science_tech":0.00017523497945783357,"ministry_transport":0.0002703941758742287,"ministry_energy":0.4259909769720203,"ministry_works":0.011584953278004842,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.18563297524762218,"state_planning_commission":0.0021986386769088976,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.0016512275909323594,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0026235138393714058,"ministry_land_survey":0.00013301347798308442,"law_justuce_sector":0.18131346157505826,"judiciary":0.0023452813974852273,"ministry_justice":0.007791993477695512,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.013234329994464016,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.013895561920964652,"social_sector":0.0035860264955298767,"ministry_youth_development":0.011796901731163725,"ministry_women_affairs":0.010023498231787274,"ministry_education":0.0017734034993764523,"ministry_health":0.0003147355793166299,"ministry_environment":0.00013301347798308442,"ministry_sports":0.00018172210133354542,"minsitry_lga":0.2952360357790899},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0019794382399120855,"governors_office":0.0020282043477314773,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.18133036093465987,"state_assembly":0.09251805916309302,"ministry_of_info":0.015064901574137552,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0018137264481207654,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0005013450714351354,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.24503929287184553,"lga_service_commission":0.1155723673134637,"state_inec":0.002270271282494919,"economic_sector":0.01584281633975174,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.00932916392350018,"ministry_finance":0.0028642539719158032,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.09623987435677338,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0010422759405591907,"ministry_science_tech":0.0007727700237422482,"ministry_transport":0.0006960041060849148,"ministry_energy":0.00016102616844427436,"ministry_works":0.0002484694451152737,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.39144978374676376,"state_planning_commission":0.010645595095994762,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.1705810497054797,"ministry_water_resources":0.0020203635314787146,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.0015173389069919583,"law_justuce_sector":0.0024107879757885855,"judiciary":0.00012222816915510214,"ministry_justice":0.1666117809077338,"regional_sector":0.002155115825214297,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.007160184902227263,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.012161233205431287,"ministry_youth_development":0.012768849583775683,"ministry_women_affairs":0.003295255937492628,"ministry_education":0.010840357850699672,"ministry_health":0.0092107495870198,"ministry_environment":0.001629608263679872,"ministry_sports":0.00028921545554003446,"minsitry_lga":0.00012222816915510214},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.0001669872863849323,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.2712970194379665,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0018189368151911673,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.001863748755800243,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.1666273099940739},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.08501629426400219,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.013843374113883542,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0016666616531159349,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.000460693841899566},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":40917737954.50999,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":65366005125.05,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":1810170592.11,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":48294467.730000004},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":45302368526.7,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.26666134993840945,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.4259909769720203,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.011796901731163725,"health_total_expenditure":0.0003147355793166299,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.2952360357790899,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.24503929287184553},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.39144978374676376,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.010840357850699672,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.00028921545554003446,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.2712970194379665,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"osun","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.8476197533597745,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.8500305976400586,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.8849479514108599,"federation_revenue_performance":0.850618802248795,"igr_performance":0.990408957722209,"aids_grant_performance":1.5790211432874999,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.6771597114810596,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.9161266101165316,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.194888433711558,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.6811129741040902,"total_expenditure_performance":0.8476197533597745},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.8089980195696335,"satutory_allocation":0.5866512921772227,"derivation":0.10289395996487218,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.1450530492842591,"igr":0.3387042829280914,"tax_revenue":0.22234672739241074,"personal_taxes":0.15483769475358455,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.15483769475358455,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.15483769475358455,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.06750903263882617,"fees_general":0.05995313899494606,"fines_general":0,"sales_general":0,"earnings_general":0.001200363133932863,"rent_on_government_building_general":0,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.001980361643873979,"repayments":0.0020981109117900504,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.0020727072927993113,"reimbursement":0.00005767759690376444,"miscellaneous_income":0.00014667306458015055,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.023487972496513028,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.023350893600853403,"capital_development_fund":0.00013707889565962804,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.16751400793385354,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.002709251894423941,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.0805275733034482,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.08427718273598142,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.7986757215915404,"derivation":0.5791659964155494,"vat":0.10158109875976266,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.1432022650287678,"tax_revenue":0.334382632627019,"personal_taxes":0.21950972517599093,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.15286206467189686,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.15286206467189686,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.15286206467189686,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.06664766050409403,"fines_general":0.059188175236744175,"sales_general":0,"earnings_general":0,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.00118504726708196,"rent_on_land_others_general":0,"repayments":0.001955093494264258,"investment_income":0.002071340356734666,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0020462608716955576,"miscellaneous_income":0.00005694166760913191,"aids_grants":0.0001448016099642767,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.02318828097051988,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.02305295111400902,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.00013532985651085565,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.1653766361930454,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.002674683570799572,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.0795000929054948,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0.08320185971675105,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.198223583858797,"ovetimes_payments":0.1368050881501723,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.1368050881501723,"allowances":0.1368050881501723,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.0033337150112566685,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0.0033337150112566685,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.058084780697368006,"gratuity_arrears":0.04625448536284999,"pension_arrears":0.011830295334518017,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.34450395503337583,"materials_supplies_general":0.181059329524415,"maintainance_services_general":0.013315842963487106,"training_general":0.008034668805621958,"other_servies_general":0.005839845308974544,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.010990132087103876,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0022455094348950836,"financial_general":0.03178854926823192,"miscellaneous_general":0.010005765837109545,"loans_advances":0.0044667351997499565,"staff_loans_advances":0.0006973430247680117,"grants_contribution_general":0.09367493759447301,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.026893573246770185,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.026893573246770185,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.13655105226219066,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.05511853911508895,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.05511853911508895,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.08143251314710172,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.08143251314710172,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.47019672773950033,"preservation_of_environment":0.416786514199349,"other_capital_projects":0.0020970002069631054},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0.05131321333318825,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.195694377545085,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.13505954261032466,"allowances":0.13505954261032466,"social_contribution":0.13505954261032466,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.0032911789371405176,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0.0032911789371405176,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.05734365599761982,"pension_arrears":0.045664307674908707,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.011679348322711114,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.34010830462081015,"maintainance_services_general":0.17874912813225463,"training_general":0.01314594131283569,"other_servies_general":0.007932151563847944,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.005765332613063036,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.010849905021675413,"financial_general":0.0022168581688364387,"miscellaneous_general":0.031382947684667435,"loans_advances":0.009878098656262041,"staff_loans_advances":0.004409742511751061,"grants_contribution_general":0.0006884453732033893,"grants_to_other_states":0.0924797052261122,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.02655042843054862,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.02655042843054862,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.1348087480580069,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.054415261763228695,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.054415261763228695,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.08039348629477824,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.08039348629477824,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.46419731783410484,"other_capital_projects":0.4114685845026792},"expenditure":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.002070243823791845,"recurrent_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.050658489507633776,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":272382613492.56,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":145943334884.66998,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":126439278607.89},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.5358026821658951,"governors_office":0.46419731783410484,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.5427275388921728,"state_assembly":0.47019672773950033,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":41264857367.15894,"office_head_of_service":33994239596.922623,"office_auditor_general_state":914972258.9296347,"office_auditor_general_lga":4073919736.8331237,"civil_service_commission":832982059.7346956,"lga_service_commission":161901312.63358513,"state_inec":631842260.4875126,"economic_sector":190172838.41548276,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":120668417.18797658,"ministry_finance":114262139.82771389,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":12230872.29378347,"ministry_labour_productivity":217665873.892806,"ministry_science_tech":176253363724.7185,"ministry_transport":3270031371.420245,"ministry_energy":75376124231.10489,"ministry_works":384103609.45843035,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":8463318137.468278,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":1783909195.5711157,"ministry_water_resources":11978984930.945152,"ministry_housing_urban_development":45316939321.83434,"ministry_land_survey":2298641516.968061,"law_justuce_sector":3538087671.2750773,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":1048658997.0677567,"regional_sector":20292012210.504578,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":2502552531.1005917,"state_capital_dev_agency":4467379507.795698,"social_sector":3730572600.4645014,"ministry_youth_development":736806907.331197,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":50397012892.886826,"ministry_sports":215744076.86376503,"minsitry_lga":208107076.73106077},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","admin_sector":23638118313.766422,"governors_office":13481982656.893261,"secretary_to_state_gov":10441072029.84333,"state_assembly":2256355032.436577,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":155633706.3524143,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.15149593007442846,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.12480326538114797,"civil_service_commission":0.0033591434019874648,"lga_service_commission":0.014956607121858022,"state_inec":0.0030581322686275203,"economic_sector":0.000594389306122167,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0023196864601079652,"ministry_finance":0.0006981827363246048,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00044301071805110856,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00041949131173467835,"ministry_science_tech":0.0000449032782854826,"ministry_transport":0.0007991180901814477,"ministry_energy":0.6470800814514278,"ministry_works":0.012005286715958338,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.27672883839615464,"state_planning_commission":0.0014101619943114392,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.03107143304394298,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.006549277036068392,"ministry_land_survey":0.04397852262795897,"law_justuce_sector":0.1663723640094677,"judiciary":0.00843901704111833,"ministry_justice":0.012989403493522608,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.003849948363522844,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0744981919011466,"social_sector":0.009187636828255,"ministry_youth_development":0.016401118450674247,"ministry_women_affairs":0.013696074623229944,"ministry_education":0.002705043827444304,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.18502287002346937},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0007920625846761617,"governors_office":0.0007640248181139693,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.0867827722580101,"state_assembly":0.04949648762093809,"ministry_of_info":0.03833237333310382,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.008283770404817736,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0005713790038095268,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.1534539038683237,"lga_service_commission":0.1264162560594374,"state_inec":0.0034025578669687763,"economic_sector":0.015149910300206097,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0030976563854621863,"ministry_finance":0.0006020713519975051,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0023496667064202828,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0007072062361664952,"ministry_science_tech":0.0004487363066918901,"ministry_transport":0.00042491292929720765,"ministry_energy":0.0000454836202266804,"ministry_works":0.0008094461054491463,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.6554431169561509,"state_planning_commission":0.012160446242465069,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.28030535568825976,"ministry_water_resources":0.0014283873039197723,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.03147300852923108,"law_justuce_sector":0.006633921638727234,"judiciary":0.04454691278046979,"ministry_justice":0.16852260480206785,"regional_sector":0.008548085147466975,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.013157282007659282,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.003899706122691187,"ministry_youth_development":0.07546102639685458,"ministry_women_affairs":0.00930638029633835,"ministry_education":0.016613090878588418,"ministry_health":0.013873086343467862,"ministry_environment":0.002740004535120556,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.1874141549286101,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0008022994127094887,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.00077389927857649,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0879043759457084},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.05013619342428241,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.03882779114668569,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.008390832062245165,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.000578763658402501},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":41264857367.15894,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":176253363724.7185,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":4467379507.795698,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":50397012892.886826,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.15149593007442846,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.6470800814514278,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.016401118450674247,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.18502287002346937,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.1534539038683237},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.6554431169561509,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.016613090878588418,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.1874141549286101,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"edo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.9254111209908912,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.9194581925378964,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.7676325252543469,"federation_revenue_performance":0.7689056210407448,"igr_performance":0.7612792810913434,"aids_grant_performance":1.9159097308140458,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":1.1450925816894735,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.923986594245641,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.1560871893953002,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.7259456300404191,"total_expenditure_performance":0.9254111209908912},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.6405952203819189,"satutory_allocation":0.5345431242732033,"derivation":0.19283329258431312,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.21800660147739814,"igr":0.12370323021149211,"tax_revenue":0.10605209610871559,"personal_taxes":0.08183838036264954,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.05739891273087139,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.05739891273087139,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.02443946763177815,"lottery_tax":0.02443946763177815,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.024213715746066056,"fees_general":0.0006100893313699408,"fines_general":0.014957272480123683,"sales_general":0.00014684363712482899,"earnings_general":0.0009412243522936139,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.005935756940601418,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0011498628964643944,"repayments":0.0002736344277729218,"investment_income":0.00019900334372935155,"interest_earned":2.8336585901150462e-8,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.17297987237367018,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.1327542640625287,"capital_development_fund":0.04022560831114149,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.18642490724441094,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.18642490724441094,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.6364744383556766,"derivation":0.5311045477295895,"vat":0.19159284629177162,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.21660422185234468,"tax_revenue":0.1229074795854732,"personal_taxes":0.10536989062608716,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.08131193540001912,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.057029680491258034,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.057029680491258034,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.02428225490876108,"property_tax":0.02428225490876108,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.02405795522606804,"fines_general":0.0006061647857737178,"sales_general":0.01486105624616403,"earnings_general":0.00014589903029468238,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0009351697014467333,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.005897573763870267,"repayments":0.0011424661282625206,"investment_income":0.00027187420884550693,"interest_earned":0.00019772320710655076,"reimbursement":2.8154304032427005e-8,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.17186713795683495,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.1319002904956798,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.03996684746115515,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.18522568442386186,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.18522568442386186,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.25380438969442914,"ovetimes_payments":0.20480150403882097,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.20480150403882097,"allowances":0.20480150403882097,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.04900288565560818,"gratuity_arrears":0.0024275759994126203,"pension_arrears":0.04453415112666073,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.0020411585295348265,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.4368554729645225,"materials_supplies_general":0.15599298264957395,"maintainance_services_general":0.013841496231622171,"training_general":0.00268629000524593,"other_servies_general":0.005484941344169702,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0036126992119821515,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0020809662885170523,"financial_general":0.05698413669118382,"miscellaneous_general":0.0077770428010892085,"loans_advances":0.0050962043956055796,"staff_loans_advances":0.0034888929243950375,"grants_contribution_general":0.0549403127557633,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.1695550694228523,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.1695550694228523,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.1113074208920963,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.0033765079197253054,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.0033765079197253054,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.107930912972371,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.107930912972371,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.31581452465012605,"preservation_of_environment":0.05405580555048409,"other_capital_projects":0.20828971488667936},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.020154132290890667,"personal_cost":0.00037460755466184277,"salaries_wages":0.03294026436741008,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.25217173223156103,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.20348406936254065,"allowances":0.20348406936254065,"social_contribution":0.20348406936254065,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.04868766286902034,"pension_arrears":0.002411960035965761,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.04424767454413598,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.0020280282889186016,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.4340452956110535,"maintainance_services_general":0.15498952046523382,"training_general":0.013752457495345677,"other_servies_general":0.0026690098020556966,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.005449658146626373,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.003589459659913561,"financial_general":0.0020675799749666256,"miscellaneous_general":0.056617572597686586,"loans_advances":0.007727015112507737,"staff_loans_advances":0.005063421841494501,"grants_contribution_general":0.0034664497858936925,"grants_to_other_states":0.05458689604874337,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.16846436587042898,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.16846436587042898,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.1105914092753907,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0033547877246561425,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.0033547877246561425,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.10723662155073456,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.10723662155073456,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.31378297215738565,"other_capital_projects":0.053708078647692524},"expenditure":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.20694984145951822,"recurrent_expenditure":0.02002448601277873,"capital_expenditure":0.0003721978019365184,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.032728368235459604,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":161964579012.43,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":111142852025.68999,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":50821726986.740005},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6862170278426144,"governors_office":0.31378297215738565,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.6906598626589515,"state_assembly":0.31581452465012605,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":31714689945.22522,"office_head_of_service":18619488997.77853,"office_auditor_general_state":4807647892.193485,"office_auditor_general_lga":4566327639.116162,"civil_service_commission":1042364106.0816594,"lga_service_commission":37194120.57187935,"state_inec":1410373288.402998,"economic_sector":505695150.75210595,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":137694068.6136446,"ministry_finance":94376555.2893351,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":55440239.39776882,"ministry_labour_productivity":438087887.0276507,"ministry_science_tech":67989651172.84468,"ministry_transport":1971469082.3280427,"ministry_energy":36836007515.76106,"ministry_works":285642969.7608329,"ministry_culture_tourism":197340256.7307248,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":118506929.16029882,"ministry_water_resources":46571502.00901939,"ministry_housing_urban_development":22972752883.857204,"ministry_land_survey":283261284.27815604,"law_justuce_sector":1230735793.780532,"judiciary":123547226.21954584,"ministry_justice":1120498001.8095598,"regional_sector":2357933207.328072,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":445384519.82163405,"state_capital_dev_agency":5468588708.33902,"social_sector":4673084044.56689,"ministry_youth_development":795504663.7721295,"ministry_women_affairs":37316328.46483053,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":37316328.46483053,"ministry_environment":56754332857.55623,"ministry_sports":70415920.21724525,"minsitry_lga":236669301.62724257},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","admin_sector":34391695586.968666,"governors_office":11352986622.416927,"secretary_to_state_gov":720502541.7076374,"state_assembly":405869280.09566593,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":9576193604.52285,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.19581250504649705,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.11496025310786981,"civil_service_commission":0.029683329043349173,"lga_service_commission":0.028193372075296284,"state_inec":0.0064357534989280775,"economic_sector":0.00022964354798233312,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0087079119212526,"ministry_finance":0.0031222576802628944,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.000850149270002284,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0005826987349011178,"ministry_science_tech":0.00034229854290248273,"ministry_transport":0.002704837623750003,"ministry_energy":0.419780989074326,"ministry_works":0.012172223669823153,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.2274324901183121,"state_planning_commission":0.0017636138191604919,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.001218416137244304,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0007316842354228822,"ministry_land_survey":0.00028754127780892917,"law_justuce_sector":0.14183812920042324,"judiciary":0.0017489088417067852,"ministry_justice":0.007598795991598131,"regional_sector":0.000762803984506169,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.006918166976024845,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.014558326405103132,"social_sector":0.0027498884171918416,"ministry_youth_development":0.033764102877823256,"ministry_women_affairs":0.028852506350837692,"ministry_education":0.00491159652698556,"ministry_health":0.0002303980826694625,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0.0002303980826694625,"minsitry_lga":0.3504120049186842},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.00043476123388584345,"governors_office":0.0014612411125341136,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.21234084511977938,"state_assembly":0.07009549057973745,"ministry_of_info":0.004448519213897641,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0025059138397446608,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.05912523381910512,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.1970802710441288,"lga_service_commission":0.11570455031163976,"state_inec":0.02987551041219861,"economic_sector":0.028375906885660687,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.006477421059705889,"ministry_finance":0.00023113034925500148,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.008764290315684124,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0031424723857636588,"ministry_science_tech":0.0008556534656468084,"ministry_transport":0.0005864713521953772,"ministry_energy":0.0003445147162445663,"ministry_works":0.0027223497901343254,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.42249881378258086,"state_planning_commission":0.012251031360274311,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.22890497614600602,"ministry_water_resources":0.0017750321380893784,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0012263046352204538,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.0007364214425509562,"judiciary":0.00028940293140881126,"ministry_justice":0.14275644418406178,"regional_sector":0.0017602319549162653,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.007647993539930405,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0007677426729427696,"social_sector":0.0069629578684965,"ministry_youth_development":0.014652582648821742,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0027676922598614878,"ministry_education":0.03398270475699783,"ministry_health":0.02903930865179064,"ministry_environment":0.004943396105207185,"ministry_sports":0.00023188976909193347,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.00023188976909193347,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.35268070795627815,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0004375760465009929,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0014707017534486071,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.2137156219926217},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.07054931593437047,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.004477320650240288,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0025221380965063456,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.05950803348258979},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":31714689945.22522,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":67989651172.84468,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":5468588708.33902,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":37316328.46483053},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":56754332857.55623,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.19581250504649705,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.419780989074326,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.033764102877823256,"health_total_expenditure":0.0002303980826694625,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.3504120049186842,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.1970802710441288},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.42249881378258086,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.03398270475699783,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.00023188976909193347,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.35268070795627815,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"adamawa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.4156736838434482,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.538989684003296,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.447411153498778,"federation_revenue_performance":1.7921147990493074,"igr_performance":0.814926708433127,"aids_grant_performance":0.4924450551286652,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.04357380537875757,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.5988156494020743,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.6199654693209422,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.2895554720818112,"total_expenditure_performance":0.4156736838434482},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.888845253829124,"satutory_allocation":0.7123144472433391,"derivation":0.18415734647449997,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.18468525646832767,"igr":0.34347184430051153,"tax_revenue":0.1765308065857849,"personal_taxes":0.09581840894003207,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.09581840894003207,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.09581840894003207,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.08071239764575283,"fees_general":0.0012397333935355943,"fines_general":0.04731095524052944,"sales_general":0.0010143621681313574,"earnings_general":0.007143969637984812,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.023346615251183634,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00038184288606891124,"repayments":0.0002749190683190864,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.06260962174131224,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.06260962174131224,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.048545124429563706,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.048545124429563706,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":1.1388148107703278,"derivation":0.9126383236584642,"vat":0.2359478354346269,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.23662420932213407,"tax_revenue":0.44006627890170325,"personal_taxes":0.22617648711186353,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.12276537763493998,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.12276537763493998,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.12276537763493998,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.10341110947692356,"fines_general":0.0015883830665492991,"sales_general":0.06061619422222265,"earnings_general":0.0012996307912728831,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.009153065054217726,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.029912373514811658,"repayments":0.0004892283917467599,"investment_income":0.00035223443610257895,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.08021729792511387,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.08021729792511387,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.06219744826550387,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.06219744826550387,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.1931891652714852,"ovetimes_payments":0.12870021667307857,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.12870021667307857,"allowances":0.12870021667307857,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.06448894859840662,"gratuity_arrears":0.06412937781922695,"pension_arrears":0.00035957077917965637,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.25712764471228955,"materials_supplies_general":0.09429631668010018,"maintainance_services_general":0.017150198971974815,"training_general":0.001728223197781709,"other_servies_general":0.005333201931531652,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.010816609190597359,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.006185151067094905,"financial_general":0.018474540213621226,"miscellaneous_general":0.002274875136580223,"loans_advances":0.0030730756199579606,"staff_loans_advances":0.0003754599409614121,"grants_contribution_general":0.028884981409998917,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.024793924416980116,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.024793924416980116,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.13803740361520925,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.03249795924354305,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.03249795924354305,"transfers_payment":0.1055394443716662,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.1055394443716662,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.33018344819945267,"preservation_of_environment":0.03850057890486002,"other_capital_projects":0.14416291307360235},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.06135541101267238,"personal_cost":0.004004107677028861,"salaries_wages":0.08216043753128913,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.24751966863043984,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.16489452158882614,"allowances":0.16489452158882614,"social_contribution":0.16489452158882614,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.0826251470416137,"pension_arrears":0.08216445433150923,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.00046069271010445306,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.3294395383171381,"maintainance_services_general":0.12081522804309376,"training_general":0.021973341830655354,"other_servies_general":0.0022142506420234874,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.006833055947919557,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.013858559401088743,"financial_general":0.007924598361430524,"miscellaneous_general":0.02367012697295509,"loans_advances":0.002914637263382149,"staff_loans_advances":0.003937315315066221,"grants_contribution_general":0.0004810503738145728,"grants_to_other_states":0.037008291934758054,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.0317667087960906,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.0317667087960906,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.17685760147795376,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.04163734592373952,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.04163734592373952,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.13522025555421424,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.13522025555421424,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.42304079305242204,"other_capital_projects":0.04932807965301372},"expenditure":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.18470578524749082,"recurrent_expenditure":0.07861036606892295,"capital_expenditure":0.005130181105063607,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.105266380977931,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":136438749520.8,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":78719592720.44,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":57719156800.36},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.576959206947578,"governors_office":0.42304079305242204,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.4503168099837747,"state_assembly":0.33018344819945267,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":41543366558.35093,"office_head_of_service":40135528676.15607,"office_auditor_general_state":26482079.248762287,"office_auditor_general_lga":476765327.82010496,"civil_service_commission":276023942.1220719,"lga_service_commission":357244626.72823524,"state_inec":35658798.990304604,"economic_sector":230300303.23002347,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0,"ministry_finance":0,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":5362804.055340918,"ministry_labour_productivity":0,"ministry_science_tech":69896855755.85112,"ministry_transport":933447475.4237883,"ministry_energy":25245032597.773495,"ministry_works":33300687.957349576,"ministry_culture_tourism":579647.8678621063,"state_planning_commission":16691075.173948979,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":76864005.8704577,"ministry_water_resources":346604262.9322811,"ministry_housing_urban_development":41652552387.25753,"ministry_land_survey":346885535.3284545,"law_justuce_sector":202245151.88314545,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":224422670.89670354,"regional_sector":7135336.471451687,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":811094921.0146472,"state_capital_dev_agency":2055952746.3991706,"social_sector":87293177.33511056,"ministry_youth_development":1968659569.06406,"ministry_women_affairs":3176077838.305137,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":3176077838.305137,"ministry_environment":19766496621.89366,"ministry_sports":161098652.79530075,"minsitry_lga":590013343.192481},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","admin_sector":16501332016.208897,"governors_office":1537272440.6204154,"secretary_to_state_gov":815434920.3917481,"state_assembly":55057309.34623251,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":106287939.33859015,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.30448363609502055,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.29416517534146286,"civil_service_commission":0.00019409500117651776,"lga_service_commission":0.003494354276146619,"state_inec":0.0020230612131196075,"economic_sector":0.0026183516631671675,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0002613538977419933,"ministry_finance":0.0016879391231514793,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0,"ministry_labour_productivity":0,"ministry_science_tech":0.00003930557905416277,"ministry_transport":0,"ministry_energy":0.5122947549823108,"ministry_works":0.006841512977084892,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.18502831993432264,"state_planning_commission":0.00024407060365408073,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.000004248410879592086,"ministry_water_resources":0.00012233383281927862,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0005633590614134133,"ministry_land_survey":0.0025403652858856014,"law_justuce_sector":0.305283891369201,"judiciary":0.0025424268145727326,"ministry_justice":0.0014823146107207125,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0016448602151875515,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.00005229699404687016,"social_sector":0.00594475487252246,"ministry_youth_development":0.015068686525053075,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0006397975475566989,"ministry_education":0.014428888977496375,"ministry_health":0.023278415035758927,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0.023278415035758927,"minsitry_lga":0.1448745073618567},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.001180739733844756,"governors_office":0.004324382517904372,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.1209431490259538,"state_assembly":0.011267124962810212,"ministry_of_info":0.005976564013197992,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0004035313247856985,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0007790157833598923,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.23764955658473141,"lga_service_commission":0.22959599530252614,"state_inec":0.00015149119853034593,"economic_sector":0.002727344414716101,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0015789997991603269,"ministry_finance":0.002043624149116457,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0002039867846648186,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0013174369214173,"ministry_science_tech":0,"ministry_transport":0,"ministry_energy":0.0000306780145998153,"ministry_works":0,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.39984618852960685,"state_planning_commission":0.005339802644978659,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.14441465147994764,"ministry_water_resources":0.0001904971691669462,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0000033158857883900557,"ministry_land_survey":0.00009548158809999075,"law_justuce_sector":0.0004397018928830298,"judiciary":0.00198275576151342,"ministry_justice":0.23827415603284172,"regional_sector":0.001984364785185978,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0011569469363762862,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.001283813822629203,"ministry_youth_development":0.000040817817355788865,"ministry_women_affairs":0.004639882712839779,"ministry_education":0.011761113723286044,"ministry_health":0.0004993621510529991,"ministry_environment":0.011261751572233044,"ministry_sports":0.018168808945506168,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.018168808945506168,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.11307459040009703,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0009215676671130275,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0033751816717073973,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.09439615904024949},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.008793993942456056,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.004664709755349618,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.00031495630318025745,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0006080220200412051},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":41543366558.35093,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":69896855755.85112,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":2055952746.3991706,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":3176077838.305137},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":19766496621.89366,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.30448363609502055,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5122947549823108,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.015068686525053075,"health_total_expenditure":0.023278415035758927,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.1448745073618567,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.23764955658473141},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.39984618852960685,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.011761113723286044,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.018168808945506168,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.11307459040009703,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"cross_river","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.0137606176263239,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.4265116500995225,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.4898577163108166,"federation_revenue_performance":1.5437500290212798,"igr_performance":1.2706076363767367,"aids_grant_performance":0.37045725203399316,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":1.420623094678143,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.2398625020938907,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.5714935614730814,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.7258905758042371,"total_expenditure_performance":1.0137606176263239},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.8953641950426199,"satutory_allocation":0.7447020655580939,"derivation":0.06667703891324184,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.030513774234208188,"igr":0.6475112524106439,"tax_revenue":0.15066212948452584,"personal_taxes":0.10974102017323026,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.09209248582039198,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.09142914281250317,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.0006633217892286799,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":2.1218660127723278e-8,"sales_taxes":0.017648534352838276,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.0005620386213066561,"other_taxes_nec":0.01708649573153162,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.04092110931129559,"fees_general":0.0009774536334833483,"fines_general":0.018243512638810466,"sales_general":0.0015086502703595339,"earnings_general":0.000013566671457989485,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0002707527910847984,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.000012301681480396472,"repayments":0.000003146602481293552,"investment_income":0.010607273593959085,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":1.801089797900276e-8,"miscellaneous_income":0.009284433417280703,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.013221540171281687,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.005324218152054165,"capital_development_fund":0.007897322019227522,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.09141426478609846,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.0012724039376175618,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.09014186084848089,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":1.2378699166269287,"derivation":1.0295746567802158,"vat":0.09218315972143194,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.042186278361817056,"tax_revenue":0.8952052186969666,"personal_taxes":0.20829525984671304,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.15172050462205977,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.12732083589631238,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.1264037427643592,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.0009170637964702688,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":2.9335482911498017e-8,"lottery_tax":0.0243996687257474,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.0007770365457431176,"non_tax_revenue":0.02362263218000428,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.05657475522465326,"fines_general":0.0013513612164591038,"sales_general":0.02522224542172101,"earnings_general":0.0020857577226440858,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.000018756361444414232,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00037432447799712825,"repayments":0.000017007471945853896,"investment_income":0.0000043502795541109705,"interest_earned":0.01466489831969229,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":2.4900648141936258e-8,"aids_grants":0.012836029052547122,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.01827920629406562,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.007360903547939114,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.010918302746126502,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.12638317341234898,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.0017591395377379957,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0.12462403387461099,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.1614100483819474,"ovetimes_payments":0.13305881763713615,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.13305881763713615,"allowances":0.13305881763713615,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.015285820160782075,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.004906883644751246,"housing_fund_contribution":0.005901643139250244,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0.004426172631906987,"pension":0.000051120744873597785,"death_benefit":0.013065410584029158,"gratuity_arrears":0.0009537520018691273,"pension_arrears":0.007392028504872695,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.00007694141887108007,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.004642688658416256,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.2573594633960615,"materials_supplies_general":0.08992471786504687,"maintainance_services_general":0.004685595988281974,"training_general":0.0003515314705255636,"other_servies_general":0.0010912842182606477,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0011261423494341738,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0009379413974906777,"financial_general":0.028780241116760894,"miscellaneous_general":0.021094481598179626,"loans_advances":0.0002511155015667975,"staff_loans_advances":0.0035511244581878042,"grants_contribution_general":0.02805525976635872,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.04735036228158175,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.04735036228158175,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.043636483946015235,"public_debt_charges":0.043636483946015235,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.03217329271220594,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.0003325822942421927,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0003325822942421927,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.03184071041796375,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.03184071041796375,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.044274606591211775,"construction_provision":0.044274606591211775,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.3045408967036815,"preservation_of_environment":0.04227838488976145,"other_capital_projects":0.20334991196382288},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.03302224113540572,"personal_cost":0.0009726105771408095,"salaries_wages":0.02491774813755062,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.22315460484076977,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.1839581126952694,"allowances":0.1839581126952694,"social_contribution":0.1839581126952694,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.021133140048224558,"housing_fund_contribution":0.006783925113218466,"social_benefit":0.00815921224144756,"gratuity":0,"pension":0.006119326612758164,"death_benefit":0.00007067608080036614,"gratuity_arrears":0.0180633520972758,"pension_arrears":0.001318592945276648,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.010219718143403177,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.00010637399651497997,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0.006418667012080995,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.355807769912074,"maintainance_services_general":0.12432382668709127,"training_general":0.006477987781369779,"other_servies_general":0.00048600361117914445,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0015087356762242307,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0015569281683614545,"financial_general":0.001296734274098892,"miscellaneous_general":0.039789612840182745,"loans_advances":0.029163802083892736,"staff_loans_advances":0.00034717529102604384,"grants_contribution_general":0.0049095442517438845,"grants_to_other_states":0.03878730270901238,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.06546340509737095,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.06546340509737095,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0.060328848353797516,"foreign_debt_interest":0.060328848353797516,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.0444806162540109,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0004598057629784704,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.0004598057629784704,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.04402081049103243,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.04402081049103243,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0.06121107351980339,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.06121107351980339,"preservation_of_environment":0.4210376252471563,"other_capital_projects":0.058451232546906824},"expenditure":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.28113782074652727,"recurrent_expenditure":0.045654314867005864,"capital_expenditure":0.0013446655346525816,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.03444959155206375,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":579502987944.23,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":335510426076.55994,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":243992561867.67004},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.5789623747528437,"governors_office":0.4210376252471563,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.41876951177800886,"state_assembly":0.3045408967036815,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":50406782565.6829,"office_head_of_service":33629445452.406136,"office_auditor_general_state":9518351923.098011,"office_auditor_general_lga":3135683818.4474587,"civil_service_commission":975470622.6854984,"lga_service_commission":0,"state_inec":798350108.3654104,"economic_sector":701858298.7714436,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0,"ministry_finance":150402681.7103557,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":3153706.8416748047,"ministry_labour_productivity":1494065953.3569152,"ministry_science_tech":277782231019.24365,"ministry_transport":849929886.9402552,"ministry_energy":60221655141.92809,"ministry_works":2351292923.9051247,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":223662458.1025694,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":3245421517.067546,"ministry_water_resources":13521494042.107515,"ministry_housing_urban_development":172076246614.0455,"ministry_land_survey":1117843550.1889946,"law_justuce_sector":5840019718.050508,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":1247147929.0385838,"regional_sector":5822717675.5674095,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":11264799562.301609,"state_capital_dev_agency":39948933707.62061,"social_sector":28372843916.521225,"ministry_youth_development":11576089791.099388,"ministry_women_affairs":13276447620.701942,"ministry_education":152475193.04009253,"ministry_health":13123972427.66185,"ministry_environment":198088593030.98083,"ministry_sports":239610686.0197464,"minsitry_lga":1489877671.1468482},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","admin_sector":120461677403.77481,"governors_office":71581700247.31866,"secretary_to_state_gov":650278904.4077622,"state_assembly":3284479900.7458067,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":380968217.5672413,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.08698278285759922,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.05803153072895382,"civil_service_commission":0.016425026481509765,"lga_service_commission":0.005410988180701546,"state_inec":0.0016832883401446334,"economic_sector":0,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0013776462330203582,"ministry_finance":0.0012111383605825149,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00025953737053868324,"ministry_science_tech":0.0000054420890095191535,"ministry_transport":0.0025781850731383987,"ministry_energy":0.47934564065781277,"ministry_works":0.001466653157312194,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.10391949031283283,"state_planning_commission":0.00405743019936147,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.0003859556598595039,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.005600353379678998,"ministry_land_survey":0.023332915141774546,"law_justuce_sector":0.29693763482476765,"judiciary":0.0019289694331939722,"ministry_justice":0.010077635214216596,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0021520992212012654,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.010047778521769718,"social_sector":0.01943872559184407,"ministry_youth_development":0.06893654483014539,"ministry_women_affairs":0.048960651639041695,"ministry_education":0.01997589319110369,"ministry_health":0.02291005895897061,"ministry_environment":0.0002631137305797056,"ministry_sports":0.0226469452283909,"minsitry_lga":0.34182497269547196},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0004134761873614463,"governors_office":0.002570957703655931,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.20787067523346017,"state_assembly":0.12352257319889354,"ministry_of_info":0.0011221320992918565,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.005667753176558077,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0006574050962510392,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.06291555219960428,"lga_service_commission":0.04197481019637735,"state_inec":0.01188039261366341,"economic_sector":0.003913824071272834,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0012175399769024813,"ministry_finance":0,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0009964658595492172,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0008760289823207837,"ministry_science_tech":0,"ministry_transport":0.00018772608150059882,"ministry_energy":0.000003936319624469017,"ministry_works":0.001864828098393132,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.3467156911481201,"state_planning_commission":0.0010608454943164438,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.07516604898738419,"ministry_water_resources":0.0029347814948860913,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.0002791657459887981,"law_justuce_sector":0.004050793890697431,"judiciary":0.016876940382265566,"ministry_justice":0.21477808193868972,"regional_sector":0.0013952436686722268,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.007289258443324473,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.001556635766780215,"ministry_youth_development":0.00726766278691481,"ministry_women_affairs":0.014060232548200224,"ministry_education":0.049862520400408825,"ministry_health":0.035413748936564994,"ministry_environment":0.014448771463843829,"ministry_sports":0.01657108410395264,"minsitry_lga":0.00019031289994274832},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.01638077120400989,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.24724556062960448,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0002990716299778597,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0018596004668205203,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.15035502301447887},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.08934516287720118,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.0008116498271092095,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.004099544865309621,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.00047550794870728413},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":50406782565.6829,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":277782231019.24365,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":39948933707.62061,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":13276447620.701942},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":198088593030.98083,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.08698278285759922,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.47934564065781277,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.06893654483014539,"health_total_expenditure":0.02291005895897061,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.34182497269547196,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.06291555219960428},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.3467156911481201,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.049862520400408825,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.01657108410395264,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.24724556062960448,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"delta","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.7698173942886135,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.9679232606383352,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.7785106885926395,"federation_revenue_performance":0.9011659227743636,"igr_performance":0.6162577499342218,"aids_grant_performance":0.09772476736231411,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":1.819649252080153,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.9201902391227078,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.9041677489488643,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.6237835448877561,"total_expenditure_performance":0.7698173942886135},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.5004509198778957,"satutory_allocation":0.32990533348574963,"derivation":0.11949972217254594,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.21040561131320373,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.17054558639214612,"personal_taxes":0.11866490893145466,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.11866490893145466,"personal_income_tax_dat":0,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.11866490893145466,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.051880677460691464,"fees_general":0.0057900580977734515,"fines_general":0.03706170893156156,"sales_general":0.00027035401914735053,"earnings_general":0.003179159262233734,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.004372764957655598,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00001585823304850133,"repayments":0.0010778843723094449,"investment_income":0.00004495570733153267,"interest_earned":0.00006793387963028907,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.011956524427631583,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.011956524427631583,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.4875925556944727,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.29653236062621013,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.19106019506826255,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.6292376474622248,"derivation":0.4148036254553456,"vat":0.15025194492716423,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.2645516805281814,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.21443402200687922,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.14920229969917112,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.14920229969917112,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.14920229969917112,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.0652317223077081,"fines_general":0.007280079607010214,"sales_general":0.046599220048822144,"earnings_general":0.00033992729403263495,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.00399728847648793,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.005498058302164377,"repayments":0.000019939212538127306,"investment_income":0.0013552686182168993,"interest_earned":0.00005652467084723476,"reimbursement":0.00008541607758853699,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.01503343285791775,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.01503343285791775,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.6130702941661937,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.372842405889437,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0.24022788827675676,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.3219174262388194,"ovetimes_payments":0.21354525635353283,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.21354525635353283,"allowances":0.15579549034100718,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.05774976601252567,"contributory_pension":0.00033903197655726246,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.10803313790872934,"gratuity_arrears":0.009282784706544481,"pension_arrears":0.05221082349874135,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0.04653952970344351,"utilities_general":0.1521405281315847,"materials_supplies_general":0.0778013998365467,"maintainance_services_general":0.009273959672270711,"training_general":0.0025975725847733767,"other_servies_general":0.010988946400261431,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.011343607308424035,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.004063493282291463,"financial_general":0.006975659966273796,"miscellaneous_general":0.005315742467970845,"loans_advances":0.0019975404001432253,"staff_loans_advances":0.0005021433244773688,"grants_contribution_general":0.02474273442966044,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.07433912829503801,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.017273606865342097,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.017273606865342097,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.05706552142969592,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.05706552142969592,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.32127099947757654,"preservation_of_environment":0.05596924305566574,"other_capital_projects":0.2102903219563785},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.012730305389794002,"personal_cost":0.021759587698479316,"salaries_wages":0.020521541377258985,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.404760099178221,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.26849928613858803,"allowances":0.26849928613858803,"social_contribution":0.19588811596413472,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.07261117017445334,"group_life_insurance":0.00042627893139932777,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.13583453410823368,"pension_arrears":0.01167162928198738,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.06564682858097096,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.05851607624527534,"materials_supplies_general":0.19129258075604383,"maintainance_services_general":0.09782291900744465,"training_general":0.011660533201263708,"other_servies_general":0.0032660354840669827,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.013816856971061386,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.014262786804807127,"financial_general":0.005109198228772343,"miscellaneous_general":0.008770785889944004,"loans_advances":0.006683702941093853,"staff_loans_advances":0.002511590192308069,"grants_contribution_general":0.0006313655777875132,"grants_to_other_states":0.031110063716339655,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.09346966174859919,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.02171882059840585,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.02171882059840585,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.07175084115019334,"capital_expenditure":0.07175084115019334,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.40394732006573514,"other_capital_projects":0.0703724449925706},"expenditure":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.2644067224498072,"recurrent_expenditure":0.016006339676434406,"capital_expenditure":0.027359229905061958,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.025802583041861036,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":238976338252.50003,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":142442486856.28003,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":96533851396.22},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.5960526799342649,"governors_office":0.4039473200657351,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.47405795437040427,"state_assembly":0.32127099947757654,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":50226222232.70003,"office_head_of_service":25684049065.1,"office_auditor_general_state":1431502181.3000152,"office_auditor_general_lga":2152500576.02,"civil_service_commission":562173781.58,"lga_service_commission":1327176230.2,"state_inec":18577602986.850006,"economic_sector":164527125.03,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":100201658.73,"ministry_finance":147855708.84,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":16021269.5,"ministry_labour_productivity":62611649.55,"ministry_science_tech":128488389236.19998,"ministry_transport":868911864.22,"ministry_energy":40326936589.42,"ministry_works":502863990.88,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":772884742.9300001,"ministry_water_resources":11215279314.83,"ministry_housing_urban_development":72607441888.71,"ministry_land_survey":47904770.68,"law_justuce_sector":515134949.53000003,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":931370853.54,"regional_sector":569748965.1800001,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":129911306.28,"state_capital_dev_agency":3479854512.1500044,"social_sector":3157037042.2000046,"ministry_youth_development":322817469.95,"ministry_women_affairs":115748129.84,"ministry_education":115748129.84,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":56666124141.61,"ministry_sports":627910815.46,"minsitry_lga":240568579.42},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","admin_sector":46844720003.96,"governors_office":8334564420.399999,"secretary_to_state_gov":471985794.03,"state_assembly":937933.75,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":145436594.59,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.21017236518048704,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.1074752808286923,"civil_service_commission":0.005990141918517072,"lga_service_commission":0.009007170298783678,"state_inec":0.0023524244521062705,"economic_sector":0.005553588442708997,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.07773825276049337,"ministry_finance":0.0006884661729822067,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0004192953137650303,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0006187043868911287,"ministry_science_tech":0.00006704123771062257,"ministry_transport":0.00026199936783634684,"ministry_energy":0.5376615533393956,"ministry_works":0.0036359744674885615,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.16874865890199958,"state_planning_commission":0.0021042417611599647,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0032341475670004524,"ministry_land_survey":0.046930501140159106,"law_justuce_sector":0.3038269078003602,"judiciary":0.00020045821703646786,"ministry_justice":0.0021555897679949956,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.003897335026348604,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0023841229192239485,"social_sector":0.0005436157706238557,"ministry_youth_development":0.014561502354568781,"ministry_women_affairs":0.013210667906645683,"ministry_education":0.0013508344479231007,"ministry_health":0.0004843497506338962,"ministry_environment":0.0004843497506338962,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.2371202293749147},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.002627502036609816,"governors_office":0.0010066627565688852,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.19602241940147372,"state_assembly":0.034876107322365034,"ministry_of_info":0.0019750314925794225,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.000003924797563049898,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0006085815677547672,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.16715616732675254,"lga_service_commission":0.08547820266600178,"state_inec":0.004764133305455119,"economic_sector":0.007163663330862227,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0018709512785000891,"ministry_finance":0.004416929686241983,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.06182748324197309,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0005475570811176614,"ministry_science_tech":0.0003334777032501024,"ministry_transport":0.0004920735127672777,"ministry_energy":0.000053319837453063245,"ministry_works":0.00020837568313011404,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.4276178007417018,"state_planning_commission":0.0028917957694456465,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.13421069434777708,"ministry_water_resources":0.001673564398546587,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.002572211201052462,"judiciary":0.03732518637536421,"ministry_justice":0.24164233673172736,"regional_sector":0.00015943022404584544,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0017144029551048711,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.0030996633893009273,"ministry_youth_development":0.0018961619871913768,"ministry_women_affairs":0.00043235336214553504,"ministry_education":0.011581184434114097,"ministry_health":0.010506826685825603,"ministry_environment":0.001074357748288494,"ministry_sports":0.000385217380468187,"minsitry_lga":0.000385217380468187},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.18858858396494413,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0020897284460103236,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.000800628037059656,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.1559023057533242},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.02773797795098648,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.0015707997308100079,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.000003121505139885579,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.000484022541613563},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":50226222232.70003,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":128488389236.19998,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":3479854512.1500044,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":115748129.84},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":56666124141.61,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.21017236518048704,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5376615533393956,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.014561502354568781,"health_total_expenditure":0.0004843497506338962,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.2371202293749147,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.16715616732675254},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.4276178007417018,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.011581184434114097,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.000385217380468187,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.18858858396494413,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"oyo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.7715998786554857,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.8110808113990859,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.0382069722743734,"federation_revenue_performance":0.9762555836030925,"igr_performance":1.2651237623072396,"aids_grant_performance":1.5003007482960493,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.3924456481459574,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.266271691827881,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.8041047408461857,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.5567613632004889,"total_expenditure_performance":0.7715998786554857},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7582146267038997,"satutory_allocation":0.5600653129905706,"derivation":0.3871046288014974,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.1729606841890733,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.19814931371332908,"personal_taxes":0.11351542874292062,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.0842974632399754,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.08009756996665612,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.004199893273319277,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.02921796550294521,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.00031435502573813156,"other_taxes_nec":0.008698376205308896,"non_tax_revenue":0.02020523427189818,"licances_general":0.0846338849704085,"fees_general":0.005642520170782492,"fines_general":0.0572086985746107,"sales_general":0.0004537446269202198,"earnings_general":0.007721221547687701,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.00042417938493190797,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0006199827469526874,"repayments":0.008829010602683434,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.0033584153576631955,"reimbursement":0.0003422953558920704,"miscellaneous_income":0.00003381660228411244,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.06031485840251641,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.05962273054793416,"capital_development_fund":0.0006921278545822457,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.181470514893584,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.1125389400306605,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.06893157486292349,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.727693837191978,"derivation":0.5375207261035794,"vat":0.3715223141393522,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.16599841196422713,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.1901731110883987,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.10894603587578561,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.08090419563299082,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.07687336274713037,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.004030832885860446,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.028041840242794783,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.0003017011369384961,"non_tax_revenue":0.00834823615273323,"licances_general":0.019391902953123055,"fees_general":0.0812270752126131,"fines_general":0.005415389007146316,"sales_general":0.05490584845018472,"earnings_general":0.00043547981935431975,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.007410415386302581,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00040710468171880444,"repayments":0.0005950262738719384,"investment_income":0.008473612058903745,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0032232273981926208,"miscellaneous_income":0.0003285167711218111,"aids_grants":0.00003245536581626884,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.0578869744856008,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.05722270719690724,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.0006642672886935687,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.17416569223174147,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.10800885424808707,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.06615683798365439,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.3643251603100706,"ovetimes_payments":0.22701507776477414,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.22701507776477414,"allowances":0.22701507776477414,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.0800389616576853,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0.005143793953533438,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0.07489516770415186,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.05727112088761115,"gratuity_arrears":0.05727112088761115,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.27949800862971685,"materials_supplies_general":0.1649528022488793,"maintainance_services_general":0.01948363430455532,"training_general":0.0030270822401471096,"other_servies_general":0.01385854061265821,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.022003601369475326,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.003397676214883759,"financial_general":0.026908514210652327,"miscellaneous_general":0.017109548004269663,"loans_advances":0.019191346705450713,"staff_loans_advances":0.0010382008372746376,"grants_contribution_general":0.0389346577495122,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.028948806371573942,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.028948806371573942,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.08559640000926359,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.08559640000926359,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.08559640000926359,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.39811863124048524,"preservation_of_environment":0.01682364283584983,"other_capital_projects":0.3730512378234916},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0.008243750581143829,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.34965979889379284,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.21787692721944443,"allowances":0.21787692721944443,"social_contribution":0.21787692721944443,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.07681711362749559,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0.004936738263733616,"gratuity":0,"pension":0.07188037536376198,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.054965758046852844,"pension_arrears":0.054965758046852844,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.26824723663198774,"maintainance_services_general":0.15831287526840734,"training_general":0.018699349907244665,"other_servies_general":0.0029052315970271815,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.013300685902284044,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.021117879487768273,"financial_general":0.0032609078686505395,"miscellaneous_general":0.02582535243906783,"loans_advances":0.016420828880566497,"staff_loans_advances":0.01841882790586797,"grants_contribution_general":0.0009964096239300625,"grants_to_other_states":0.03736740165600025,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.02778351570746594,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.02778351570746594,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.08215084565611443,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.08215084565611443,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.08215084565611443,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.38209296447421953,"other_capital_projects":0.016146432394725952},"expenditure":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.3580346212801404,"recurrent_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure":0.007911910799353215,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":212945504885.83997,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":131580525652.54999,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":81364979233.29},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6179070355257805,"governors_office":0.38209296447421953,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.6438231689397874,"state_assembly":0.39811863124048524,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":33647049348.229996,"office_head_of_service":3458802978.63,"office_auditor_general_state":5632456927.352499,"office_auditor_general_lga":3432809633.5575,"civil_service_commission":998781255.1300001,"lga_service_commission":0,"state_inec":18816833618.42,"economic_sector":458281366.90999997,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":160780839.55,"ministry_finance":182068580.38,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":2750000,"ministry_labour_productivity":503484148.3,"ministry_science_tech":123331773232.14319,"ministry_transport":4508255420.6359005,"ministry_energy":74001755601.93,"ministry_works":1011083337.13,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":11615700,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":2717703699.7058997,"ministry_water_resources":425233160.75,"ministry_housing_urban_development":26188557345.079998,"ministry_land_survey":202146209.15,"law_justuce_sector":4374667081.8714,"judiciary":3527239143.590008,"ministry_justice":253771079.92,"regional_sector":225939834.60000002,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":5883805617.78,"state_capital_dev_agency":5323930879.650001,"social_sector":4716480712.55,"ministry_youth_development":607450167.1,"ministry_women_affairs":2197185218.85,"ministry_education":2078703990,"ministry_health":118481228.85,"ministry_environment":48445566206.966774,"ministry_sports":645701157.1290693,"minsitry_lga":10928698420.577639},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","admin_sector":26759562190.69377,"governors_office":5452073052.5281,"secretary_to_state_gov":2187579446.6168585,"state_assembly":1938655,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":2470013284.4213343,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.15800779343178983,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.016242667251812917,"civil_service_commission":0.026450226927175843,"lga_service_commission":0.016120601537927878,"state_inec":0.004690313870045985,"economic_sector":0,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.08836454955227957,"ministry_finance":0.002152106320138969,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0007550327941235228,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0008550008157138932,"ministry_science_tech":0.000012914102138358235,"ministry_transport":0.002364380260432911,"ministry_energy":0.5791705877908121,"ministry_works":0.021170934897417885,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.3475149928222355,"state_planning_commission":0.004748084904032332,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.00005454775862128282,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.012762437512653109,"ministry_land_survey":0.001996910716560875,"law_justuce_sector":0.12298243796749632,"judiciary":0.000949286106125464,"ministry_justice":0.020543599096945756,"regional_sector":0.01656404602426785,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0011917184166721274,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0010610218549629697,"social_sector":0.02763056971282069,"ministry_youth_development":0.02500137714813073,"ministry_women_affairs":0.022148768601988122,"ministry_education":0.0028526085461426103,"ministry_health":0.010318063393861779,"ministry_environment":0.009761671142644653,"ministry_sports":0.0005563922512171259,"minsitry_lga":0.2275021782354055},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0030322366160076006,"governors_office":0.0513215736882378,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.12566389793031588,"state_assembly":0.025603137551323072,"ministry_of_info":0.010272954330684836,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.00000910399588401414,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.011599274122952292,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.16463492473083174,"lga_service_commission":0.01692391395608311,"state_inec":0.027559597059678316,"economic_sector":0.016796728586417443,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.004887034077166214,"ministry_finance":0,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.09207071783262108,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0022423695333849396,"ministry_science_tech":0.0007867002287042044,"ministry_transport":0.0008908610890805353,"ministry_energy":0.000013455742829752888,"ministry_works":0.002463546624866169,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.6034620448542254,"state_planning_commission":0.02205888201851495,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.3620903972108346,"ministry_water_resources":0.0049472281323162245,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.000056835589813658404,"law_justuce_sector":0.01329771711662202,"judiciary":0.002080664746812716,"ministry_justice":0.12814054280641182,"regional_sector":0.0009891008743024873,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.021405234625253483,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.01725877193279453,"social_sector":0.0012417012323753405,"ministry_youth_development":0.0011055230215907285,"ministry_women_affairs":0.028789445546582904,"ministry_education":0.026049979912709263,"ministry_health":0.0230777278289318,"ministry_environment":0.0029722520837774614,"ministry_sports":0.010750821546974515,"minsitry_lga":0.010171093203134989},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.0005797283438395267,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.2370440291355316,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0031594140782554973,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.053474092876807,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.13093446802718334},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.026676979230488698,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.010703820528483484,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.000009485833860223485,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.012085768560453363},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":33647049348.229996,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":123331773232.14319,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":5323930879.650001,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":2197185218.85},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":48445566206.966774,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.15800779343178983,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5791705877908121,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.02500137714813073,"health_total_expenditure":0.010318063393861779,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.2275021782354055,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.16463492473083174},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.6034620448542254,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.026049979912709263,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.010750821546974515,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.2370440291355316,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ondo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.5897484062131635,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.7269007744970907,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.7634138244062547,"federation_revenue_performance":0.9209258409142141,"igr_performance":0.6944917319153159,"aids_grant_performance":2.952360779873659,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.40971844343713404,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.9683702822636299,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.8505009121899502,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.3496111177087011,"total_expenditure_performance":0.5897484062131635},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7371460707368029,"satutory_allocation":0.27066668301169666,"derivation":0.1443873141705284,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.12627936884116822,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.4664793877251062,"personal_taxes":0.22419310740226095,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.13699034813160688,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.13699034813160688,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.0872027592706541,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.0872027592706541,"licances_general":0.2422862803228453,"fees_general":0.004649357793363768,"fines_general":0.20558832192233303,"sales_general":0.0014777649431824149,"earnings_general":0.012881395621760463,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.01246477509696659,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0004273350911957751,"repayments":0.0030019961080323732,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.0016689746054710398,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0.00012635914053981683,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.11010329164457866,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.10983755200751946,"capital_development_fund":0.0002657396370592063,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.15275063761861835,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.11820432032213363,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0.034546317296484726,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.8284809900638325,"derivation":0.30420321076213036,"vat":0.16227739622499857,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.1419258145371318,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.524277779301702,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.25197140018729125,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.15396392079499477,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.15396392079499477,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.09800747939229651,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.09800747939229651,"fees_general":0.27230637911441075,"fines_general":0.005225429125542103,"sales_general":0.23106141815492504,"earnings_general":0.0016608650738457575,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.014477444595822102,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.014009203363094457,"repayments":0.0004802833705523516,"investment_income":0.0033739536931459094,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0018757662672609394,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.0001420154702220755,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.12374546605099773,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.12344680036403292,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.000298665686964806,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.17167696405227056,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.13285023988857353,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0.03882672416369705,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.31239452821074853,"ovetimes_payments":0.2255327373208211,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.2255327373208211,"allowances":0.2255327373208211,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.02349263873409095,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.000005218561006654197,"housing_fund_contribution":0.012773907894980431,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0.010713512278103864,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.0633691521558365,"gratuity_arrears":0.017247690236685702,"pension_arrears":0.04611283619847864,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.000008625720672155698,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.27623698461653773,"materials_supplies_general":0.17149503262050475,"maintainance_services_general":0.00553465885488971,"training_general":0.005118585874551077,"other_servies_general":0.008430165994665315,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0077902211539899605,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0036714054208022316,"financial_general":0.012151628451140598,"miscellaneous_general":0.04821267925536602,"loans_advances":0.005331722057833229,"staff_loans_advances":0.0003186476930827601,"grants_contribution_general":0.07493531786418386,"grants_to_other_states":0.00005571576611940569,"grants_to_lga":0.00005571576611940569,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.005272722557197895,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.0026776766813571356,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0.00259504587584076,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.09941351367271568,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.010919808645990117,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.010919808645990117,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.08849370502672557,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.08849370502672557,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.3011246548791177,"preservation_of_environment":0.015722904026549647,"other_capital_projects":0.25759938243017266},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.016292355674109065,"personal_cost":0.011244135915905373,"salaries_wages":0.00026587683238093747,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.35110127869754815,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.2534770148345192,"allowances":0.2534770148345192,"social_contribution":0.2534770148345192,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.02640345702199493,"housing_fund_contribution":0.000005865158563729321,"social_benefit":0.014356638772068038,"gratuity":0,"pension":0.012040953091363162,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.07122080684103405,"pension_arrears":0.019384738046993772,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.05182637431707543,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.000009694476964841852,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.31046369178717353,"maintainance_services_general":0.1927438537038538,"training_general":0.006220422016468674,"other_servies_general":0.005752796170826966,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.009474692393980737,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.008755456198827415,"financial_general":0.004126305109259662,"miscellaneous_general":0.013657256776836768,"loans_advances":0.0541863951105253,"staff_loans_advances":0.005992340656179139,"grants_contribution_general":0.0003581292320840707,"grants_to_other_states":0.08422006003886509,"grants_to_lga":0.00006261914009883033,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.00006261914009883033,"grants_to_private_companies":0.005926030915626936,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.003009449980278977,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.0029165809353479595,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.111731188027594,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.01227281028479857,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.01227281028479857,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.09945837774279544,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.09945837774279544,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.3384350295152782,"other_capital_projects":0.01767102561039823},"expenditure":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.28951682694620406,"recurrent_expenditure":0.01831103426471005,"capital_expenditure":0.012637322812709784,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.00029881988125613054,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":278509094383.52,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":184251860805.56,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":94257233577.96},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6615649704847217,"governors_office":0.3384350295152782,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.5886315128272863,"state_assembly":0.3011246548791177,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":62484618220.641525,"office_head_of_service":56256108965.103516,"office_auditor_general_state":99999999.99999999,"office_auditor_general_lga":2572531083.58,"civil_service_commission":1220059361.358,"lga_service_commission":418697335.24,"state_inec":302092948.37,"economic_sector":238342818.39000002,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":157484881.86,"ministry_finance":158636689.2,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":932118156.0600001,"ministry_labour_productivity":128545981.47999999,"ministry_science_tech":149391510828.0185,"ministry_transport":54479993908.1185,"ministry_energy":13250579570.609997,"ministry_works":764865092.2700001,"ministry_culture_tourism":8408265.780000001,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":1038368585.7599998,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":71536590696.82,"ministry_land_survey":24211561.330000002,"law_justuce_sector":661219928.98,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0,"regional_sector":6721248868.6,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":906024349.75,"state_capital_dev_agency":2927763114.6000004,"social_sector":2419128762.07,"ministry_youth_development":556941205.01,"ministry_women_affairs":16452405,"ministry_education":2849000,"ministry_health":13603405,"ministry_environment":63688749815.259995,"ministry_sports":700938286.8399999,"minsitry_lga":1734601512.5},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","admin_sector":45758762705.659996,"governors_office":13718524670.449997,"secretary_to_state_gov":1132028803.21,"state_assembly":0,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":643893836.5999999,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.22435395999886915,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.20199020462734416,"civil_service_commission":0.00035905470240155,"lga_service_commission":0.00923679382633554,"state_inec":0.00438068050904622,"economic_sector":0.0015033524710092025,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0010846789367459718,"ministry_finance":0.0008557810972656815,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0005654568738898558,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0005695924923067319,"ministry_science_tech":0.003346814071272049,"ministry_transport":0.0004615503912521656,"ministry_energy":0.5363972446167212,"ministry_works":0.1956129799951775,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.047576829043734316,"state_planning_commission":0.0027462840808233904,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.000030190273673510378,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.003728311235431751,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.256855492834682,"judiciary":0.00008693274948020029,"ministry_justice":0.0023741412482188797,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.02413296012281928,"social_sector":0.003253123032680442,"ministry_youth_development":0.010512271138149384,"ministry_women_affairs":0.008685995577360741,"ministry_education":0.0019997235862002625,"ministry_health":0.000059073133810647745,"ministry_environment":0.000010229468471420161,"ministry_sports":0.00004884366533922758,"minsitry_lga":0.22867745111244955},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.002516751879831885,"governors_office":0.0062281682985596614,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.16429898925543898,"state_assembly":0.04925700792936746,"ministry_of_info":0.0040646026504654945,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.002311931098786053,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.1996203196583497,"lga_service_commission":0.1797220303834581,"state_inec":0.00031947113600576654,"economic_sector":0.008218494276814483,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0038977375016751034,"ministry_finance":0.0013376171333171008,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0009650997739509529,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0007614365094986942,"ministry_science_tech":0.0005031187411154815,"ministry_transport":0.0005067984331091771,"ministry_energy":0.002977848462080886,"ministry_works":0.0004106673073239183,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.4772627567384485,"state_planning_commission":0.1740478554341386,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.04233177708157578,"ministry_water_resources":0.002443523199186524,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.000026861982205750133,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.0033172879168544838,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.2285387589589264,"regional_sector":0.00007734895002568389,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.002112406818608929,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0,"ministry_youth_development":0.021472450114291153,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0028944862826351847,"ministry_education":0.009353358081770435,"ministry_health":0.007728418137627267,"ministry_environment":0.0017792663945296523,"ministry_sports":0.00005256068515376954,"minsitry_lga":0.00000910173266480429},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.00004345895248896525,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.20346717254268165,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0022392955076671064,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.005541551157156959,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.14618603903795505},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.04382672660791795,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.003616505277527471,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.002057054954457134},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":62484618220.641525,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":149391510828.0185,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":2927763114.6000004,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":16452405},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":63688749815.259995,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.22435395999886915,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5363972446167212,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.010512271138149384,"health_total_expenditure":0.000059073133810647745,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.22867745111244955,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.1996203196583497},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.4772627567384485,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.009353358081770435,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.00005256068515376954,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.20346717254268165,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ogun","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.6778002258972523,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.8588411097280783,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.0229581071296199,"federation_revenue_performance":1.0068656814956103,"igr_performance":1.152188812769127,"aids_grant_performance":0.7755505990510478,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.4431713719581487,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.8258391281266829,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.6839986961519307,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.6292154815111767,"total_expenditure_performance":0.6778002258972523},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7197042445842178,"satutory_allocation":0.6299393276358339,"derivation":0.2585330605311458,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.2592726054748613,"igr":0.1121336616298269,"tax_revenue":0.08976491694838379,"personal_taxes":0.076930439270553,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.06511226598685903,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.038602782640610685,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.026509483346248336,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.011818173283693974,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0.00029160608087330135,"withholding_tax":0.000015011302391901477,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.011511555900428771,"licances_general":0.012834477677830799,"fees_general":0.0002496931575890996,"fines_general":0.001545068722713049,"sales_general":0.002321494972615047,"earnings_general":0.0035952721511027658,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0015408309218574827,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0005496519735438801,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0.0014827375609176739,"interest_earned":0.0000019334092722219334,"reimbursement":0.0015477948082195793,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.17751738959346242,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.16223636640613992,"capital_development_fund":0.015281023187322499,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.10277836582231996,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.027524702704447842,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.0752536631178721,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.8314343653980244,"derivation":0.7277339393971987,"vat":0.29866889452806195,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.29952324975187566,"tax_revenue":0.12954179511726113,"personal_taxes":0.10370042600082571,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.0888734663384617,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.07522058673099377,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.044595652073632135,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.03062493465736163,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.013652879607467942,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.00033687631915685796,"other_taxes_nec":0.000017341724426286847,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.013298661563884795,"fees_general":0.014826959662364013,"fines_general":0.00028845664533249635,"sales_general":0.0017849321337647568,"earnings_general":0.0026818942834580333,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.004153418354663499,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.001780036437662441,"repayments":0.0006349824156966617,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.0017129244023364129,"reimbursement":0.00000223356041513021,"miscellaneous_income":0.0017880814290345826,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.2050759868020804,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.1874226689121409,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.01765331788993952,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.11873414115195909,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.03179776123046603,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0.08693637992149304,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.19237541755469192,"ovetimes_payments":0.19237541755469192,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.19237541755469192,"allowances":0.19237541755469192,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.20282693198172977,"materials_supplies_general":0.15046774476076008,"maintainance_services_general":0.08436101611234291,"training_general":0.012297883605434662,"other_servies_general":0.01852840421522222,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.03528044082776029,"fuel_lubricant_general":0,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.006966459714771435,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.006966459714771435,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.04539272750619821,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.007852930195965733,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.007852930195965733,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.03753979731023248,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.03753979731023248,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.47041528011216854,"preservation_of_environment":0.14818624628541371,"other_capital_projects":0.24276402691313193},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.0016978514969670459,"personal_cost":0.0690037505923528,"salaries_wages":0.008763404824303074,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.2222406417863618,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.2222406417863618,"allowances":0.2222406417863618,"social_contribution":0.2222406417863618,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.2343146962753869,"maintainance_services_general":0.17382703356197193,"training_general":0.09745759931736887,"other_servies_general":0.014207062315063017,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.02140483694023664,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0407575349893034,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.00804796422364869,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.00804796422364869,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.05243969848976624,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.009072054365567557,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.009072054365567557,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.04336764412419869,"capital_expenditure":0.04336764412419869,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.5434446619382514,"other_capital_projects":0.1711913450117369},"expenditure":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.2804518052753679,"recurrent_expenditure":0.001961433592400738,"capital_expenditure":0.07971620289245478,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.010123875166291036,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":113182521631.01,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":51674084425.84,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":61508437205.17},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.4565553380609804,"governors_office":0.5434446619390196,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.39520234953519795,"state_assembly":0.47041528011216854,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":23101335626.96,"office_head_of_service":1781988469.68,"office_auditor_general_state":14134299630.84,"office_auditor_general_lga":363097335.78,"civil_service_commission":361850636.32,"lga_service_commission":203530265,"state_inec":5991402248.01,"economic_sector":138643463.12,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":45069495.36,"ministry_finance":14837891.749999998,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":33724082.22,"ministry_labour_productivity":32892108.880000003,"ministry_science_tech":63526911699.77,"ministry_transport":11567088173.509998,"ministry_energy":31650402388.07,"ministry_works":337230711.15,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":14453459398.939999,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":2166332702,"judiciary":27000000,"ministry_justice":1257210439.57,"regional_sector":1187099719.68,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":881088166.85,"state_capital_dev_agency":1905555374.96,"social_sector":1320516159.36,"ministry_youth_development":585039215.6,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":24648718929.32,"ministry_sports":522096461.24,"minsitry_lga":1070601120.5},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","admin_sector":14299254198.029999,"governors_office":7111723132.669999,"secretary_to_state_gov":390660069.03999996,"state_assembly":0,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":1254383947.84,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.20410691769388875,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.01574437858423935,"civil_service_commission":0.12488058604048165,"lga_service_commission":0.0032080689716671275,"state_inec":0.0031970540248181557,"economic_sector":0.0017982481929784873,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.05293575511185636,"ministry_finance":0.0012249547113979318,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00039820190176420356,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00013109702395880976,"ministry_science_tech":0.00029796192675311914,"ministry_transport":0.0002906112039735794,"ministry_energy":0.5612784622946141,"ministry_works":0.10219853743145858,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.2796403714277524,"state_planning_commission":0.0029795299335081083,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.1277004540156806,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.019140169973058816,"regional_sector":0.00023855273421090055,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.011107814364367098,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.010488366070765098,"social_sector":0.007784666343812506,"ministry_youth_development":0.01683612758840688,"ministry_women_affairs":0.011667138532777973,"ministry_education":0.005168989055628909,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.21777849242167657},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.004612871790764351,"governors_office":0.00945906757572329,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.12633800689321312,"state_assembly":0.06283411104627183,"ministry_of_info":0.00345159361542634,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.011082841500277617,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.17667854628906388,"lga_service_commission":0.013628611670379294,"state_inec":0.10809883687748854,"economic_sector":0.002776961059003689,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.002767426326821577,"ministry_finance":0.0015565953383258988,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.045822122863583344,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0010603423937071506,"ministry_science_tech":0.00034469058632669063,"ministry_transport":0.00011347989513320935,"ministry_energy":0.00025792109676156186,"ministry_works":0.0002515581815329327,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.4858525321042695,"state_planning_commission":0.08846485572497191,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.2420616354693424,"ministry_water_resources":0.0025791336385103105,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.11053976431010223,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.016568068563150292,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0002064954523338299,"social_sector":0.00961511994066001,"ministry_youth_development":0.009078914577062381,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0067385444281361385,"ministry_education":0.014573648855538001,"ministry_health":0.010099280801525,"ministry_environment":0.004474368054013002,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.18851290239849514,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.003992983145394285,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.00818793565358343,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.1093604060614304},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.05439031426495012,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.002987760283895556,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.009593502989241337},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":23101335626.96,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":63526911699.77,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":1905555374.96,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":24648718929.32,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.20410691769388875,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5612784622946141,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.01683612758840688,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.21777849242167657,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.17667854628906388},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.4858525321042695,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.014573648855538001,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.18851290239849514,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kebbi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.6341947417111674,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.7691153487780008,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.9449701942761668,"federation_revenue_performance":1.1781235676554793,"igr_performance":0.6991647512931551,"aids_grant_performance":0.28192263502629195,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.7192279890274846,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.0056254193749252,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.6767755798101921,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.5335580488221718,"total_expenditure_performance":0.6341947417111674},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.674990605846569,"satutory_allocation":0.4318806890333143,"derivation":0.2439406656794298,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.18794002335388446,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.24310991681325478,"personal_taxes":0.18166548244828767,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.18166548244828767,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.18166548244828767,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.06144443436496709,"fees_general":0.004886702089004514,"fines_general":0.024704049411107522,"sales_general":0.005536339126896764,"earnings_general":0.01268105347790949,"rent_on_government_building_general":0,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.01343792929228648,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.00019836096776232358,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.062136956787034306,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.062136956787034306,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.26287243736639665,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.26287243736639665,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.7259013325188932,"derivation":0.4644550086223309,"vat":0.26233973145471445,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.20211527716761646,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.2614463238965623,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.195367483102239,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.195367483102239,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.195367483102239,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.06607884079432333,"fines_general":0.005255278410256214,"sales_general":0.026567336242619918,"earnings_general":0.0059539138984763314,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.013637513674449951,"rent_on_land_others_general":0,"repayments":0.014451476354002365,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0.00021332221451855011,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.06682359626887889,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.06682359626887889,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.28269941968663703,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.28269941968663703,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.22012067518400993,"ovetimes_payments":0.16702129023810267,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.16702129023810267,"allowances":0.16702129023810267,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.03405450033378277,"group_life_insurance":0.0000038947765121210206,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0.0000038947765121210206,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.01904098983561239,"gratuity_arrears":0.01904098983561239,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.20898305290089075,"materials_supplies_general":0.06425561784021534,"maintainance_services_general":0.004707682581401384,"training_general":0.003833679152975378,"other_servies_general":0.03382410872398476,"consulting_professional_services_general":0,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0102649249738387,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0.009502432891731232,"loans_advances":0.0021227895162838806,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.024474004436419092,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.024474004436419092,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.10683798384292201,"domestic_debt_interest":0.010442722315761956,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.010442722315761956,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.004466380208541077,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.004466380208541077,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.05917542645598442,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.05917542645598442,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.03275345486263456,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.03275345486263456,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.013415446781334286,"construction_provision":0.013415446781334286,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.5007617723741453,"preservation_of_environment":0.09061088164769514,"other_capital_projects":0.34044754644120634},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.015221667856618196,"personal_cost":0.024451599072521646,"salaries_wages":0.030030077356104017,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.23672313369551096,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.17961876223566675,"allowances":0.17961876223566675,"social_contribution":0.17961876223566675,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.036623038834079885,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.00000418853749300118,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0.00000418853749300118,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.0204771440882713,"pension_arrears":0.0204771440882713,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.2247454635081334,"maintainance_services_general":0.0691020559516342,"training_general":0.005062756472927908,"other_servies_general":0.004122831905348471,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.03637527008721889,"fuel_lubricant_general":0,"financial_general":0.011039150252129176,"miscellaneous_general":0,"loans_advances":0.010219147701511857,"staff_loans_advances":0.0022828995324978983,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.026319940275595803,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.026319940275595803,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.11489616916659386,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.011230357842727476,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.011230357842727476,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0048032540258092825,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.0048032540258092825,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.06363869444212236,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.06363869444212236,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.03522386285593474,"capital_expenditure":0.03522386285593474,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0.014427298114309534,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.014427298114309534,"preservation_of_environment":0.5385314027963557,"other_capital_projects":0.09744514836066434},"expenditure":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.36612558082124547,"recurrent_expenditure":0.016369752237397478,"capital_expenditure":0.02629584500172406,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.03229507637532427,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":238746818351.5,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":110174159351.49998,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":128572659000},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.4614685972036443,"governors_office":0.5385314027963557,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.42910372808490066,"state_assembly":0.5007617723741453,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":20429948893.420002,"office_head_of_service":5084982321.32,"office_auditor_general_state":1786462971.980002,"office_auditor_general_lga":4084856855.75,"civil_service_commission":711027849.79,"lga_service_commission":7526656065.66,"state_inec":626463004.0699999,"economic_sector":151735618.52,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":33350174.51,"ministry_finance":128534581.32,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":77965803.67,"ministry_labour_productivity":217913646.83,"ministry_science_tech":103284410330.37,"ministry_transport":1326209638.35,"ministry_energy":61038540815.31,"ministry_works":5088029296.49,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":6666555000,"ministry_water_resources":1934126982.11,"ministry_housing_urban_development":14267059673.57,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":5334847854.2,"judiciary":49866171.2,"ministry_justice":711100953.13,"regional_sector":6868073946.01,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0,"state_capital_dev_agency":2784266553.76,"social_sector":2532087250.38,"ministry_youth_development":252179303.38,"ministry_women_affairs":11481227764.99,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":11481227764.99,"ministry_environment":100766964808.95999,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":1886214161.27},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","admin_sector":68237210281.869995,"governors_office":26861267743.239998,"secretary_to_state_gov":2028513171.78,"state_assembly":567384040.75,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":1186375410.05,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.08557160692018766,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.021298639104096993,"civil_service_commission":0.007482667137996555,"lga_service_commission":0.01710957609385179,"state_inec":0.0029781668074134265,"economic_sector":0.031525681127941664,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0026239637805253457,"ministry_finance":0.0006355503271947443,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00013968845633326727,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0005383719130060291,"ministry_science_tech":0.00032656269184376405,"ministry_transport":0.0009127394799840729,"ministry_energy":0.43261062511127313,"ministry_works":0.00555487879380851,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.25566221672300876,"state_planning_commission":0.021311401473836783,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.027923115566654482,"ministry_land_survey":0.008101163380792958,"law_justuce_sector":0.059758114357633126,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.022345210256773593,"regional_sector":0.00020886632770361567,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.00297847300349388,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.02876718522756745,"social_sector":0,"ministry_youth_development":0.011662004850932947,"ministry_women_affairs":0.010605742383766898,"ministry_education":0.0010562624671660492,"ministry_health":0.048089552959346756,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0.048089552959346756,"minsitry_lga":0.42206621015825946},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","admin_sector":0,"governors_office":0.00790047873430917,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.28581411368341814,"state_assembly":0.11250942705210393,"ministry_of_info":0.008496503475047273,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0023765093276118844,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.004969177885769074,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.07957008509392506,"lga_service_commission":0.01980486970962776,"state_inec":0.006957874023041624,"economic_sector":0.015909604537151623,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.002769294568826005,"ministry_finance":0.02931464325934578,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.002439933393964611,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0005909763230638514,"ministry_science_tech":0.00012989147635668517,"ministry_transport":0.0005006134683204453,"ministry_energy":0.0003036593808825549,"ministry_works":0.0008487249533441194,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.40226969542299473,"state_planning_commission":0.005165290149594093,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.23773147510160964,"ministry_water_resources":0.01981673699695289,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.02596474183076295,"judiciary":0.007532992341381541,"ministry_justice":0.05556700891364943,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.020778040118277386,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0001942175923391657,"social_sector":0.002769579289997595,"ministry_youth_development":0.026749613088430085,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0.010844095977068587,"ministry_health":0.009861913949421122,"ministry_environment":0.0009821820276474651,"ministry_sports":0.044716816229394774,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.044716816229394774,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.39246480773566284,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0073463826121444465,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.2657686838584903},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.10461863469216516,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.007900605455976857,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.002209834035265416,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.004620667081620684},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":20429948893.420002,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":103284410330.37,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":2784266553.76,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":11481227764.99},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":100766964808.95999,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.08557160692018766,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.43261062511127313,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.011662004850932947,"health_total_expenditure":0.048089552959346756,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.42206621015825946,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.07957008509392506},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.40226969542299473,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.010844095977068587,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.044716816229394774,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.39246480773566284,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kaduna","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.0231210158895303,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.1239074687868107,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.126363420182443,"federation_revenue_performance":1.1603328552640089,"igr_performance":0.9960836927893594,"aids_grant_performance":1.3840864902716887,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.7914859838510707,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.0250039103364532,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.4343048170952655,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.9261293341128637,"total_expenditure_performance":1.0231210158895303},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.8068706163763381,"satutory_allocation":0.6592978042286888,"derivation":0.18855339771222046,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.22271543618364453,"igr":0.2480289703328238,"tax_revenue":0.14757281214764928,"personal_taxes":0.0808553617283771,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.07211381803997922,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.067017825167738,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.004792152663485719,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.00011003356615279655,"other_taxes":0.0001938066426027178,"sales_taxes":0.008741543688397874,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.00011245970253058534,"other_taxes_nec":0.00782421286815848,"non_tax_revenue":0.00080487111770881,"licances_general":0.06671745041927217,"fees_general":0.01251336312868553,"fines_general":0.029228812435578747,"sales_general":0,"earnings_general":0.0069394624306048066,"rent_on_government_building_general":0,"rent_on_land_others_general":0,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.018035812424403084,"domestic_aids":0.13052231795779293,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.12183593989456361,"capital_development_fund":0.008686378063229317,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.06260706566586899,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.03304179302079159,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0.029565272645077398,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.8004011279425258,"derivation":0.6540115545718964,"vat":0.18704157660869147,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.220929703862777,"tax_revenue":0.24604027410042795,"personal_taxes":0.14638957337062944,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.0802070634549034,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.07153560946197582,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.06648047625952133,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.004753729184429414,"other_taxes":0.00010915131704233371,"sales_taxes":0.00019225270098275246,"lottery_tax":0.00867145399292757,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.00011155800065915142,"non_tax_revenue":0.007761478331013523,"licances_general":0.000798417661254897,"fees_general":0.06618250991572605,"fines_general":0.012413030985729708,"sales_general":0.028994455823566686,"earnings_general":0,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.006883821822283617,"rent_on_land_others_general":0,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.017891201284146046,"foreign_aids":0.12947579003963106,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.12085905935390096,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.008616730685730108,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.062105082226418334,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.032776863931242586,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0.029328218295175748,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.27481752790460656,"ovetimes_payments":0.24236881653978787,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.24236881653978787,"allowances":0.2422236578243167,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.00014515871547115858,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.03244871136481867,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0.03244871136481867,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.1949090185185489,"materials_supplies_general":0.1412899877471716,"maintainance_services_general":0.010392749770364364,"training_general":0.011795280832555035,"other_servies_general":0.03866375345867862,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.008698827719382223,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.013519093196375516,"financial_general":0.025098799005559565,"miscellaneous_general":0.011432459799775758,"loans_advances":0.009926007961975382,"staff_loans_advances":0.0012123565007111023,"grants_contribution_general":0.010550659501794069,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.031143382971770252,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.031143382971770252,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.022475647799607028,"domestic_debt_interest":0.0026420294785418556,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0026420294785418556,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.010765164992358559,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.010765164992358559,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.009068453328706615,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.009068453328706615,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.5383562613190604,"preservation_of_environment":0.00716388679815649,"other_capital_projects":0.3946849119719959},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.005804585200557566,"personal_cost":0.13070287734835057,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.27261404102318754,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.24042550341932398,"allowances":0.24042550341932398,"social_contribution":0.24028150858640318,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.00014399483292078734,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.03218853760386355,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0.03218853760386355,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.19334623804872036,"maintainance_services_general":0.1401571246548844,"training_general":0.010309420704873253,"other_servies_general":0.011700706273299813,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.038353747491511235,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.008629080520542577,"financial_general":0.013410697109946725,"miscellaneous_general":0.024897556840367974,"loans_advances":0.011340794339485684,"staff_loans_advances":0.009846421232206583,"grants_contribution_general":0.0012026358265412682,"grants_to_other_states":0.01046606431610929,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.030893675333598335,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.030893675333598335,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.022295438060237642,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0026208456867339693,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.0026208456867339693,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.010678849901695174,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.010678849901695174,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.0089957424718085,"capital_expenditure":0.0089957424718085,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.534039720928092,"other_capital_projects":0.007106446755303081},"expenditure":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.39152032843012596,"recurrent_expenditure":0.005758044037630188,"capital_expenditure":0.12965490170503288,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":274398734999.99716,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":127858911137.57718,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":146539823862.41998},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.4659602790719079,"governors_office":0.5340397209280922,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.46972654642315537,"state_assembly":0.5383562613190604,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":30455081724.652676,"office_head_of_service":5603660891.141298,"office_auditor_general_state":7555212184.852688,"office_auditor_general_lga":7614609671.020703,"civil_service_commission":3637414798.8500986,"lga_service_commission":0,"state_inec":2219704061.114987,"economic_sector":202396155.93179983,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":150972831.78079936,"ministry_finance":3471111129.9603004,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0,"ministry_labour_productivity":0,"ministry_science_tech":142481730542.8011,"ministry_transport":19723386842.630505,"ministry_energy":29158413544.403473,"ministry_works":339137577.2352,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":1792297426.1489,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":4086464567.4810433,"ministry_water_resources":448217236.67059946,"ministry_housing_urban_development":60919320544.777245,"ministry_land_survey":310812067.02390057,"law_justuce_sector":6766843775.8267,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":8895354965.8753,"regional_sector":9370292155.73,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":671189838.9982017,"state_capital_dev_agency":6959059845.9313,"social_sector":6200561509.7300005,"ministry_youth_development":758498336.2012995,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":94502862886.61212,"ministry_sports":874238645.7079998,"minsitry_lga":196403436.65070018},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","admin_sector":60107791472.380325,"governors_office":30209460213.4134,"secretary_to_state_gov":2413316333.734303,"state_assembly":602991323.3378007,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":98661461.38759972,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.11098841882289649,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.020421598850087104,"civil_service_commission":0.02753369903419112,"lga_service_commission":0.027750163174115147,"state_inec":0.013255945946143433,"economic_sector":0,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.008089337806586498,"ministry_finance":0.0007375987208242848,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0005501950720756818,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.012649880218873224,"ministry_science_tech":0,"ministry_transport":0,"ministry_energy":0.5192506829260803,"ministry_works":0.07187856329815334,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.10626292990892895,"state_planning_commission":0.0012359298129971461,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.006531726271073802,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.014892432239095728,"ministry_land_survey":0.0016334522703634331,"law_justuce_sector":0.2220102091388208,"judiciary":0.0011327022590825857,"ministry_justice":0.024660623074034105,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.032417623812571114,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.03414845245452788,"social_sector":0.002446038386431368,"ministry_youth_development":0.025361122185681255,"ministry_women_affairs":0.02259690267788612,"ministry_education":0.0027642195077951337,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.3443997760653419},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0031860155831549618,"governors_office":0.0007157592641624321,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.2190527280396571,"state_assembly":0.1100932925708047,"ministry_of_info":0.008794925143274904,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0021975003760050385,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.00035955508828275297,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.11188551687385451,"lga_service_commission":0.020586662707381017,"state_inec":0.027756248629916526,"economic_sector":0.027974462407866642,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.013363091208667317,"ministry_finance":0,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.008154722368838975,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0007435605894756119,"ministry_science_tech":0.0005546421930639841,"ministry_transport":0.012752126768644437,"ministry_energy":0,"ministry_works":0,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.5234476863661862,"state_planning_commission":0.07245954390607902,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.1071218327415074,"ministry_water_resources":0.001245919596058475,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.006584520958747672,"law_justuce_sector":0.015012804905698318,"judiciary":0.001646655151020867,"ministry_justice":0.22380467497609904,"regional_sector":0.0011418576736719238,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.024859950149144775,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.03267964923330761,"ministry_youth_development":0.03442446783041203,"ministry_women_affairs":0.002465809244438973,"ministry_education":0.025566111260434964,"ministry_health":0.022779549097801038,"ministry_environment":0.0027865621626339244,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.34718349324174025,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0032117675345773073,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.000721544608684367,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.22082328912580956},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.11098315548836205,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.008866012832315178,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0022152623490577345,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.00036246130293407795},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":30455081724.652676,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":142481730542.8011,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":6959059845.9313,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":94502862886.61212,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.11098841882289649,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5192506829260803,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.025361122185681255,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.3443997760653419,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.11188551687385451},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.5234476863661862,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.025566111260434964,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.34718349324174025,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kano","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.6623985352602597,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.8021393929940716,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.7715783579158955,"federation_revenue_performance":0.808614623809407,"igr_performance":0.6401883770894004,"aids_grant_performance":2.1456342037231435,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.5677746545288654,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.0728841992394642,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.5987822336226238,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.5283235407061948,"total_expenditure_performance":0.6623985352602597},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.6420004951391911,"satutory_allocation":0.5248671535340739,"derivation":0.2967788396864645,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.22808831384760941,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.11713334160511717,"personal_taxes":0.08291450669618392,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.08291450669618392,"personal_income_tax_dat":0,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.08291450669618392,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.03421883490893326,"fees_general":0.0007255532500112428,"fines_general":0.007845544424301304,"sales_general":0.000022120998732787022,"earnings_general":0.013674002625612823,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0015153766959141626,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.001305235881056032,"repayments":0.001877636662613195,"investment_income":0.005649097260788142,"interest_earned":0.0009546063910786504,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.00064966071882492,"domestic_aids":0.16671267103372045,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.16671267103372045,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.19128683382708836,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.19128683382708836,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.756991594354473,"derivation":0.6188780637807924,"vat":0.34993600273815884,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.2689420610426335,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.13811353057368062,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.09776563272813486,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.09776563272813486,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.09776563272813486,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.04034789784554577,"fines_general":0.0008555097942658143,"sales_general":0.00925078909953654,"earnings_general":0.000026083173184804446,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.016123204151930904,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0017868014585237487,"repayments":0.0015390215398432877,"investment_income":0.0022139471567569624,"interest_earned":0.006660928105951631,"reimbursement":0.0011255894963241814,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.0007660238692278976,"foreign_aids":0.19657319830812214,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.19657319830812214,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.22554893090291522,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.22554893090291522,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.2989589721009344,"ovetimes_payments":0.26552125427740636,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.26552125427740636,"allowances":0.2634777360919425,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.0020435181854638355,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.03343771782352805,"gratuity_arrears":0.00828659219275996,"pension_arrears":0.025151125630768087,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.16928456179321577,"materials_supplies_general":0.11233691432251904,"maintainance_services_general":0.013268834040538373,"training_general":0.002061517437852046,"other_servies_general":0.009438006922067388,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.014984993574708467,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0023139010471078607,"financial_general":0.018325359825458038,"miscellaneous_general":0.011652022894116834,"loans_advances":0.013069778998547582,"staff_loans_advances":0.0007070402982940589,"grants_contribution_general":0.02651545928382839,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.05694764747069674,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.05694764747069674,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.00565882902970527,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.05128881844099148,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.379851081590529,"preservation_of_environment":0.06215254302179081,"other_capital_projects":0.19764504042288078},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.046666743598897324,"personal_cost":0.004058978062933457,"salaries_wages":0.06932777648402666,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.35250662678725037,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.3130797548168174,"allowances":0.3130797548168174,"social_contribution":0.3106702144799813,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.002409540336836099,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.03942687197043299,"pension_arrears":0.009770834576074083,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.02965603739435891,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.1996057499981544,"maintainance_services_general":0.13245799734068514,"training_general":0.015645464312912,"other_servies_general":0.002430763502340957,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.011128483484915942,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.01766901157147975,"financial_general":0.0027283524796174836,"miscellaneous_general":0.021607683259473643,"loans_advances":0.013739060101752677,"staff_loans_advances":0.01541075578115575,"grants_contribution_general":0.000833680918832377,"grants_to_other_states":0.031264741928204574,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.06714775265746926,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.06714775265746926,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.006672402968236386,"transfers_payment":0.060475349689232884,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.4478876232145952,"other_capital_projects":0.07328491643148935},"expenditure":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.2330459795572788,"recurrent_expenditure":0.05502539781157277,"capital_expenditure":0.004785996737656191,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.08174533267659811,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":131486834661.59,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":72595508801,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":58891325860.59},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.5521123767854048,"governors_office":0.4478876232145952,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.46824353389415024,"state_assembly":0.379851081590529,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":38193652901.06,"office_head_of_service":2153067350.91,"office_auditor_general_state":12385389361.46,"office_auditor_general_lga":2383039791.94,"civil_service_commission":549066789.16,"lga_service_commission":3803073891.96,"state_inec":16380977477.52,"economic_sector":167855299.35,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":84719924.11,"ministry_finance":79466554.83,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":129180669.36000001,"ministry_labour_productivity":77815790.46,"ministry_science_tech":56893757888.67,"ministry_transport":11363451136.359999,"ministry_energy":12425140152.230001,"ministry_works":111900516.32000001,"ministry_culture_tourism":6612000000,"state_planning_commission":3261044447.99,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":113668036.24000001,"ministry_housing_urban_development":3988344309.05,"ministry_land_survey":105080570.32,"law_justuce_sector":253590914.39,"judiciary":5055134.88,"ministry_justice":2038743656.64,"regional_sector":15965980481.249998,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":649758533,"state_capital_dev_agency":1763537279.2699912,"social_sector":1205051364.04,"ministry_youth_development":558485915.2299912,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":34635886592.59,"ministry_sports":312879239.04,"minsitry_lga":2571922866.58},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","admin_sector":15446516893.79,"governors_office":13313852002.73,"secretary_to_state_gov":2667852703.13,"state_assembly":0,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":322862887.32,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.2904751110585305,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.016374775135863506,"civil_service_commission":0.09419490090651658,"lga_service_commission":0.01812379009710951,"state_inec":0.004175830915491599,"economic_sector":0.028923609741979408,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.1245826437276402,"ministry_finance":0.0012765939630535038,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.000644322485426356,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0006043689091347014,"ministry_science_tech":0.0009824608653214186,"ministry_transport":0.0005918143109937651,"ministry_energy":0.4326954712621874,"ministry_works":0.08642272943604061,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.0944972185558258,"state_planning_commission":0.0008510396999669233,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.05028640332712717,"ministry_water_resources":0.02480130011786357,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.000864482261912757,"law_justuce_sector":0.030332651320680682,"judiciary":0.0007991717999026117,"ministry_justice":0.0019286411072459949,"regional_sector":0.000038445939420554844,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.01550530638209636,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.12142645704676006,"social_sector":0.004941624267344294,"ministry_youth_development":0.013412272672080353,"ministry_women_affairs":0.009164806249549334,"ministry_education":0.004247466422531019,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.26341714500720165},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0023795480349440524,"governors_office":0.019560307107547335,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.1174757680762867,"state_assembly":0.10125616026118582,"ministry_of_info":0.020289884610853248,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.002455476916384503,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.24635037762105397,"lga_service_commission":0.013887358622498248,"state_inec":0.07988618826492964,"economic_sector":0.015370688793533127,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0035414997146028843,"ministry_finance":0.024529957682552946,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.10565786932825781,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0010826724662259242,"ministry_science_tech":0.0005464464305257982,"ministry_transport":0.0005125620176034897,"ministry_energy":0.0008332197698035137,"ministry_works":0.0005019145305205875,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.3669666993220669,"state_planning_commission":0.07329465149019533,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.08014258223547478,"ministry_water_resources":0.0007217621871056446,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.042647627893827415,"ministry_land_survey":0.021033849086979636,"law_justuce_sector":0,"judiciary":0.0007331627515102253,"ministry_justice":0.02572495825844353,"regional_sector":0.0006777733003446046,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.001635670138257738,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.000032605794209822735,"social_sector":0.013149966854096154,"ministry_youth_development":0.10298112439873888,"ministry_women_affairs":0.004190964932883119,"ministry_education":0.011374876234603658,"ministry_health":0.0077726228322031275,"ministry_environment":0.00360225340240053,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.22340266230695466,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0020180818757232002,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.016588991135137593,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.09963056635542572},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.08587480430216544,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.017207741887270096,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.002082476751232621},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":38193652901.06,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":56893757888.67,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":1763537279.2699912,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":34635886592.59,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.2904751110585305,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.4326954712621874,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.013412272672080353,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.26341714500720165,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.24635037762105397},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.3669666993220669,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.011374876234603658,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.22340266230695466,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"sokoto","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.6436816351373875,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.8549077721331111,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.8285476075394861,"federation_revenue_performance":0.8161123901693866,"igr_performance":0.8674826392297127,"aids_grant_performance":0.9332232677196682,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.8687458111737514,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.109713700303668,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.6519451620556471,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.4588844084651557,"total_expenditure_performance":0.6436816351373875},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.5532675358662044,"satutory_allocation":0.4130442233834952,"derivation":0.20156876583032346,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.21147545755317176,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.14022331248270917,"personal_taxes":0.09324733986115866,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.0770914363898598,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.0770914363898598,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.016155903471298857,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.016155903471298857,"licances_general":0.04697597262155051,"fees_general":0.00867893764642691,"fines_general":0.019354756277858487,"sales_general":0.0031086742827171705,"earnings_general":0.006472214766643896,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.003558874377970906,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0001563674225513095,"repayments":0.0005103292181656942,"investment_income":0.00001265433452708446,"interest_earned":0.0012956676548196969,"reimbursement":0.0006600189551571301,"miscellaneous_income":0.00004392541768755483,"aids_grants":0.0031235522670246705,"domestic_aids":0.1542310673113468,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.1542310673113468,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.29250139682244874,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.08288589115240322,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0.2096155056700455,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.7348240040746188,"derivation":0.548585974073761,"vat":0.26771418527552365,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.2808717887982373,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.18623803000085776,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.12384674538838937,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.10238923178308401,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.10238923178308401,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.021457513605305373,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.021457513605305373,"fees_general":0.06239128461246837,"fines_general":0.011526958115257328,"sales_general":0.025706079941447527,"earnings_general":0.00412879544832437,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.008596092237022672,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.004726730109556916,"repayments":0.00020767988016157112,"investment_income":0.0006777953434438833,"interest_earned":0.000016806893886397466,"reimbursement":0.0017208450385110291,"miscellaneous_income":0.0008766062346932907,"aids_grants":0.000058339680558493334,"domestic_aids":0.004148555689604892,"foreign_aids":0.204842473283726,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.204842473283726,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.388486642857116,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.11008515495590339,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0.27840148790121255,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.21428891229513322,"ovetimes_payments":0.19824720028620726,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.19824720028620726,"allowances":0.19824720028620726,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.016041712008925933,"gratuity_arrears":0,"pension_arrears":0.014088239362975333,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.0019534726459506002,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.30555264243315805,"materials_supplies_general":0.14069997949243537,"maintainance_services_general":0.016618977730083813,"training_general":0.0025820137839671488,"other_servies_general":0.011820935160920195,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.018768436905811554,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0028981197484283924,"financial_general":0.02295218599498762,"miscellaneous_general":0.014593950636215616,"loans_advances":0.01636966484397799,"staff_loans_advances":0.0008855553499065411,"grants_contribution_general":0.0332101393381365,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.16485266294072268,"domestic_debt_interest":0.0010566867566697993,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0010566867566697993,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.035307190278224904,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0047807552975713185,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.03052643498065359,"domestic_debt_principal":0.006735495718975592,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.006735495718975592,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.12175329018685237,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.11936966166503249,"capital_expenditure":0.002383628521819872,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.23308368015560085,"preservation_of_environment":0.1341992826664983,"other_capital_projects":0.08012928352690321},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.00505537609688257,"personal_cost":0.004938492586260454,"salaries_wages":0.008761245279056279,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.2846084874923584,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.2633026376341056,"allowances":0.2633026376341056,"social_contribution":0.2633026376341056,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.021305849858252807,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.018711339068277964,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.0025945107899748416,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.40582069543767785,"maintainance_services_general":0.1868711167771294,"training_general":0.022072547127002073,"other_servies_general":0.0034293096636152974,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.01570001191784081,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.024927358038020625,"financial_general":0.0038491467866332155,"miscellaneous_general":0.030484017445008407,"loans_advances":0.01938300107376018,"staff_loans_advances":0.021741421439410703,"grants_contribution_general":0.0011761531011018668,"grants_to_other_states":0.04410815018473621,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.21894957866054848,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0014034418129613493,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.0014034418129613493,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.04689335493406539,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.006349575065455941,"domestic_debt_principal":0.04054377986860946,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.008945769655355311,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.008945769655355311,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.16170701225816642,"capital_expenditure":0.15854118859947677,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.00316582365868963,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.30957081706996376,"other_capital_projects":0.17823719600418633},"expenditure":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.10642395793688583,"recurrent_expenditure":0.0067143135369372425,"capital_expenditure":0.006559074337602743,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.011636275254351573,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":118998787849.71002,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":82160235864.74002,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":36838551984.97},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6904291829300363,"governors_office":0.3095708170699637,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.5198415547282913,"state_assembly":0.23308368015560085,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":32758277534.097267,"office_head_of_service":12980621860.718344,"office_auditor_general_state":11340864755.61767,"office_auditor_general_lga":4438266812.829115,"civil_service_commission":545672170.31,"lga_service_commission":2143529769.822134,"state_inec":1078105097.52,"economic_sector":93505468.4,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":77768294.49000001,"ministry_finance":22664142.54,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":4457134.91,"ministry_labour_productivity":32822026.939999998,"ministry_science_tech":53981207750.75267,"ministry_transport":1908890998.9451046,"ministry_energy":40509887773.71001,"ministry_works":1434530078.4596515,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":7676801577.6896515,"ministry_land_survey":322411241.3696513,"law_justuce_sector":722652720.8996513,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":510358329.25965136,"regional_sector":437074814.4896513,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":458600215.9296514,"state_capital_dev_agency":2035852188.8065488,"social_sector":1714115073.5687895,"ministry_youth_development":321737115.2377594,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":30223450376.053524,"ministry_sports":361563219.10604185,"minsitry_lga":236595071.38604188},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","admin_sector":19563177256.0112,"governors_office":9159425751.762117,"secretary_to_state_gov":714416048.2060418,"state_assembly":53872810.50604187,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":134400219.07604188,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.27528244720836537,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.1090819670962722,"civil_service_commission":0.09530235526382555,"lga_service_commission":0.037296739681369206,"state_inec":0.004585527131580187,"economic_sector":0.018013038691867295,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.009059798986201415,"ministry_finance":0.0007857682425983457,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0006535217366097694,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00019045691934798336,"ministry_science_tech":0.00003745529673486386,"ministry_transport":0.0002758181619585294,"ministry_energy":0.45362821526323827,"ministry_works":0.016041264229984815,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.34042269258130703,"state_planning_commission":0.012054997402758396,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.0645115947515793,"judiciary":0.002709365760740705,"ministry_justice":0.006072773798438421,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.00428876914195303,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0036729350137722134,"social_sector":0.0038538225827043074,"ministry_youth_development":0.01710817585283084,"ministry_women_affairs":0.014404475075272514,"ministry_education":0.0027037007775583275,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.25398116167556556},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0030383773283697607,"governors_office":0.0019882141294149196,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.16439812211128227,"state_assembly":0.07697074833510112,"ministry_of_info":0.00600355735646918,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0004527173047685221,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0011294251101598041,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.20726710122377112,"lga_service_commission":0.08213056569755774,"state_inec":0.07175554822200397,"economic_sector":0.028081656484998288,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0034525590926114723,"ministry_finance":0.013562471388046818,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.006821351279686548,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0005916247386226625,"ministry_science_tech":0.0004920530070386396,"ministry_transport":0.00014339982073534286,"ministry_energy":0.000028201038091743247,"ministry_works":0.00020767045437786915,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.3415481305270344,"state_planning_commission":0.012077872638195892,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.2563128357715876,"ministry_water_resources":0.009076511750996575,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.04857240763106731,"regional_sector":0.00203994985179207,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.004572344638585994,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.003229122513567773,"ministry_youth_development":0.002765445457957715,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0029016402732834883,"ministry_education":0.012881177322427592,"ministry_health":0.010845492779428726,"ministry_environment":0.0020356845429988653,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.19122882581065898,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0022876709636286945,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0014969765903892012,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.12377949470510799},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.05795321876939495,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.004520229832758476,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.00034086228302884205,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0008503726663508361},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":32758277534.097267,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":53981207750.75267,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":2035852188.8065488,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":30223450376.053524,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.27528244720836537,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.45362821526323827,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.01710817585283084,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.25398116167556556,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.20726710122377112},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.3415481305270344,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.012881177322427592,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.19122882581065898,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"zamfara","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.9207180991358884,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.2730276059895729,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.9324815665597674,"federation_revenue_performance":1.4075306551113198,"igr_performance":0.8206228067586177,"aids_grant_performance":0.22329622370740612,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":2.519508599605167,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.8337470624046045,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.510514933899536,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.6323506447422875,"total_expenditure_performance":0.9207180991358884},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.5403969178893382,"satutory_allocation":0.15546425611278017,"derivation":0.0202228257888468,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.10489448851972451,"igr":0.030346941804208855,"tax_revenue":0.38493266177655805,"personal_taxes":0.3203738332872813,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.24785841481795162,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.22977600042382246,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.01557354624046009,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.00002032725690616231,"other_taxes":0.002488540896762911,"sales_taxes":0.07251541846932968,"lottery_tax":0.010472316720334694,"property_tax":0.003531529393022276,"capital_gain_tax":0.0025032445370349707,"withholding_tax":0.0008293037958127326,"other_taxes_nec":0.05330100578968214,"non_tax_revenue":0.001878018233442876,"licances_general":0.06455882848927676,"fees_general":0.003739940832960844,"fines_general":0.024891391428155427,"sales_general":0.0011760351741518095,"earnings_general":0.0013375870716609013,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.012826227027728223,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0016269600123534722,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0.0011209462708722275,"interest_earned":0.0024210169444930625,"reimbursement":0.0005696502968425286,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.014849073430058266,"domestic_aids":0.00577872490245641,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.0047505626475360906,"capital_development_fund":0.0010281622549203197,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.45382435720820535,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.013449686932870599,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.17847113333711276,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0.261903536938222,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.73534783372434,"derivation":0.2115487712265399,"vat":0.027518312268869076,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.14273570471842967,"tax_revenue":0.04129475423924114,"personal_taxes":0.5237990624978002,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.4359503107640007,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.33727458905317625,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.31266885239360553,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.02119178165570753,"other_taxes":0.00002766041743888246,"sales_taxes":0.0033862945864242817,"lottery_tax":0.09867572171082443,"property_tax":0.014250257837240777,"capital_gain_tax":0.004805546447295901,"withholding_tax":0.0034063026391425526,"other_taxes_nec":0.0011284793261443894,"non_tax_revenue":0.07252961267036227,"licances_general":0.002555522790638546,"fees_general":0.08784875173379944,"fines_general":0.005089143366169484,"sales_general":0.03387108652760106,"earnings_general":0.0016002957993799137,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0018201283593644515,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.017453353169619573,"repayments":0.002213894049050155,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.0015253332961755824,"reimbursement":0.003294411027539316,"miscellaneous_income":0.0007751545167941921,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.020205951622105714,"foreign_aids":0.007863429079698047,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.006464352101565439,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.0013990769781326068,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.617543784794001,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.018301729382517055,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.24285549553901883,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0.3563865598724651,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.09722346660340452,"ovetimes_payments":0.08408494919476621,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.08408494919476621,"allowances":0.08394388393555037,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.00014106525921584853,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.006569258940090435,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.0005305773367943143,"housing_fund_contribution":0.004887373178184984,"social_benefit":0.0011513084251111364,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.0065692584685478695,"gratuity_arrears":0.0031922658342902993,"pension_arrears":0.0033769926342575697,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.3555071160311705,"materials_supplies_general":0.0931141325279575,"maintainance_services_general":0.004083880679313179,"training_general":0.0032930406105542566,"other_servies_general":0.0007387416884286508,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.029060303492103954,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.007690383454052356,"financial_general":0.01553543051181949,"miscellaneous_general":0.023346891950371134,"loans_advances":0.001892677548713795,"staff_loans_advances":0.0003332674234712646,"grants_contribution_general":0.00713951516912941,"grants_to_other_states":0.06644523829421221,"grants_to_lga":0.06644523829421221,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.012481076731610691,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.012481076731610691,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.06053630021313842,"public_debt_charges":0.06053630021313842,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.060186798050685476,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.0012374823573822753,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0012374823573822753,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.0042636058272900144,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0042636058272900144,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.054685709866013184,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.03173805650171554,"capital_expenditure":0.022947653364297646,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.06274357021356622,"construction_provision":0.06274357021356622,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.2821555394232985,"preservation_of_environment":0.021545078296283233,"other_capital_projects":0.2285361759145182},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.0025537613636011317,"personal_cost":0.02952052384889593,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.13229732292556207,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.11441901904380279,"allowances":0.11441901904380279,"social_contribution":0.11422706378028409,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.00019195526351869168,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.008939152261706603,"housing_fund_contribution":0.000721985789183988,"social_benefit":0.006650517721710487,"gratuity":0.0015666487508121277,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.008939151620052677,"pension_arrears":0.0043438918472852904,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.0045952597727673865,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.48375810259643703,"maintainance_services_general":0.12670552584013092,"training_general":0.005557161248163516,"other_servies_general":0.004481021632757033,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0010052464814003844,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.039543954661611376,"financial_general":0.010464728103066185,"miscellaneous_general":0.02113991548556696,"loans_advances":0.031769401067193545,"staff_loans_advances":0.00257547052788778,"grants_contribution_general":0.0004534953286885165,"grants_to_other_states":0.009715131303795612,"grants_to_lga":0.09041569339770379,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.09041569339770379,"grants_to_private_companies":0.016983688161997683,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.016983688161997683,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0.08237507607793834,"foreign_debt_interest":0.08237507607793834,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.08189948924623407,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0016839103641214516,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.0016839103641214516,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0058017231504533,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.0058017231504533,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.07441385573165932,"capital_expenditure":0.04318772058566118,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.031226135145998146,"construction_provision":0.08537862987243221,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.08537862987243221,"preservation_of_environment":0.3839445744780009,"other_capital_projects":0.029317574042562366},"expenditure":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.31098175493443403,"recurrent_expenditure":0.0034750436658810913,"capital_expenditure":0.040170201835123424,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":1558472502999.8972,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":960105440999.8972,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":598367062000},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6160554255219738,"governors_office":0.3839445744780262,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.4527305826345266,"state_assembly":0.2821555394232985,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":238627403876.0206,"office_head_of_service":68549004010.384445,"office_auditor_general_state":1742805121.9793346,"office_auditor_general_lga":45117080769.53456,"civil_service_commission":16812252276.140003,"lga_service_commission":21175105811.33847,"state_inec":32887948930.369026,"economic_sector":1837744258.948208,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":950620226.9913828,"ministry_finance":46313134789.00477,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":2461486138.9139767,"ministry_labour_productivity":780221542.4164033,"ministry_science_tech":969834093332.6648,"ministry_transport":30819422699.641304,"ministry_energy":482638256950.21204,"ministry_works":4099318403.3817143,"ministry_culture_tourism":7214964850.214149,"state_planning_commission":17383060931.793888,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":116275182410.4188,"ministry_water_resources":43489425552.046585,"ministry_housing_urban_development":106480808986.00386,"ministry_land_survey":17533628933.71058,"law_justuce_sector":90611347948.35585,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":11968485384.237045,"regional_sector":41320190282.64906,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0,"state_capital_dev_agency":25939484718.96175,"social_sector":16860483080.23565,"ministry_youth_development":9079001638.7261,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":324071521072.2502,"ministry_sports":10452926067.87,"minsitry_lga":4263727926.6700006},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","admin_sector":114484026675.86888,"governors_office":127805411863.27347,"secretary_to_state_gov":54093582511.37498,"state_assembly":6727620281.900001,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":6244225745.292847,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.1531162105309346,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.04398473754168279,"civil_service_commission":0.001118277748644587,"lga_service_commission":0.028949552002159745,"state_inec":0.0107876476766687,"economic_sector":0.013587089775775447,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.021102681546874252,"ministry_finance":0.001179195818604833,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0006099692007151074,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.029717004759374166,"ministry_science_tech":0.001579422244650265,"ministry_transport":0.0005006322157846909,"ministry_energy":0.6222978534852371,"ministry_works":0.019775403570043804,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.30968673237490674,"state_planning_commission":0.0026303437471567083,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.0046295105215687915,"ministry_water_resources":0.01115390929152241,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.07460842728158085,"ministry_land_survey":0.027905160641802214,"law_justuce_sector":0.06832382912180508,"judiciary":0.011250521841071314,"ministry_justice":0.05814112714464482,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.007679625634201545,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.02651326231493291,"social_sector":0,"ministry_youth_development":0.016644172206458075,"ministry_women_affairs":0.01081859516146731,"ministry_education":0.005825577044990765,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.2079417637773043},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.006707161048878641,"governors_office":0.002735837763234505,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.07345912517255936,"state_assembly":0.08200684427684989,"ministry_of_info":0.034709359585906645,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.004316803966030577,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.004006631963844694,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.11252297818127546,"lga_service_commission":0.03232377320174063,"state_inec":0.00082180679808503,"economic_sector":0.021274624006179924,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.00792769256723369,"ministry_finance":0.009984963715371801,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.015508067807004667,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0008665746422813654,"ministry_science_tech":0.00044825790048826596,"ministry_transport":0.02183861438679185,"ministry_energy":0.0011606954884629751,"ministry_works":0.00036790766763525204,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.45731805631270467,"state_planning_commission":0.014532669641718919,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.22758448180776972,"ministry_water_resources":0.0019330031160271692,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0034021630342218126,"ministry_land_survey":0.008196853145032188,"law_justuce_sector":0.0548286977977978,"judiciary":0.02050711528945603,"ministry_justice":0.05021023382746814,"regional_sector":0.008267852366912305,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.042727107459401795,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.005643650301174611,"ministry_youth_development":0.019484228525724203,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0.012231571167667415,"ministry_health":0.007950435444324786,"ministry_environment":0.004281135723342629,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.15281351639617757,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.004928999573228044,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0020105292044028922,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.05398409162782606},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.06026569177281813,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.025507426665199215,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0031723593262802594,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0029444182264229497},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":238627403876.0206,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":969834093332.6648,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":25939484718.96175,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":324071521072.2502,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.1531162105309346,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.6222978534852371,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.016644172206458075,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.2079417637773043,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.11252297818127546},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.45731805631270467,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.012231571167667415,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.15281351639617757,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"lagos","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.49463809506949524,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.6599275346740379,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.9533226466250727,"federation_revenue_performance":0.8629019959240491,"igr_performance":1.2784387991936528,"aids_grant_performance":0.2174889175229312,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.3691263157245276,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.8319833567671853,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.8213888290308832,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.3040532976518871,"total_expenditure_performance":0.49463809506949524},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7917068049102158,"satutory_allocation":0.5606799084583122,"derivation":0.3271624479645107,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.23351746049380145,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.23102689645190358,"personal_taxes":0.06562679499906265,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.05892059882317662,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.04557272239708583,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0.013347876426090791,"sales_taxes":0.0067061961758860264,"lottery_tax":0.00000804960291099785,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0.003198749019512619,"withholding_tax":0.000028769887126856447,"other_taxes_nec":0.0034698770248990647,"non_tax_revenue":7.506414364884135e-7,"licances_general":0.16540010145284093,"fees_general":0.00036761160956432626,"fines_general":0.001051826826191027,"sales_general":0.00002150410291199771,"earnings_general":0.0006188102663307641,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.000030211268704017295,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.000003985223626447577,"repayments":0.00000396502454779298,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.00015923669463047867,"reimbursement":0.00019627379671261305,"miscellaneous_income":0.0205508739291305,"aids_grants":0.14239580271049093,"domestic_aids":0.06382760563393236,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.052006178942332,"capital_development_fund":0.011821426691600358,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.1444655894558518,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.0374714474089042,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.00006508699965599235,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.10614677596892878,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0.0005061012299409268,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0.0002761778484218955,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":1.0122750928755337,"derivation":0.7168844613789174,"vat":0.41830939856102367,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.2985750628178938,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.29539063149661626,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.08391031830316727,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.07533578627352729,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.05826921217676364,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.017066574096763654,"lottery_tax":0.00857453202963998,"property_tax":0.000010292209797622736,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.004089915535309651,"other_taxes_nec":0.00003678513306028734,"non_tax_revenue":0.004436579382495918,"licances_general":9.597689765009724e-7,"fees_general":0.21148031319344898,"fines_general":0.0004700276338486871,"sales_general":0.0013448641486569605,"earnings_general":0.000027495112631899315,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0007912098467984574,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00003862808130936175,"repayments":0.000005095500747968799,"investment_income":0.0000050696742373284095,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.00020359979078939564,"miscellaneous_income":0.00025095537206962096,"aids_grants":0.026276315532797728,"domestic_aids":0.18206705249956157,"foreign_aids":0.08160987757133033,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.06649501973766786,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.015114857833662478,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.18471347862208345,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.04791093454139354,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.00008322013681470295,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0.13571910312754137,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0.0006471002476743558,"extraordinary_items":0.0003531205686594345,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.21991842721714108,"ovetimes_payments":0.17471548975227164,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.17471548975227164,"allowances":0.17263224753369633,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.002083242218575286,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.04520293746486947,"gratuity_arrears":0.008114819774679512,"pension_arrears":0.03708811769018996,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.2568927649383921,"materials_supplies_general":0.1527433909261137,"maintainance_services_general":0.015259064753518757,"training_general":0.006842903913489894,"other_servies_general":0.05411698340512208,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.025309579876457034,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0049183371878208605,"financial_general":0.005758425837914486,"miscellaneous_general":0.006491594114359831,"loans_advances":0.0091340547773816,"staff_loans_advances":0.005391841699691813,"grants_contribution_general":0.019520605360357327,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.0023909632916631284,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.0023909632916631284,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.10175841072061527,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.09712657618634775,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.09712657618634775,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.004631834534267522,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.004631834534267522,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.30529518434459624,"preservation_of_environment":0.12014077486411447,"other_capital_projects":0.11730931556192169},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.004792147007206106,"personal_cost":0.06305294691135394,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.28118735996151883,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.22339095422557612,"allowances":0.22339095422557612,"social_contribution":0.22072732395587077,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.002663630269705314,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.05779640573594273,"pension_arrears":0.010375595978379252,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.04742080975756348,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.32846269082726187,"maintainance_services_general":0.19529746274366094,"training_general":0.019510216528091727,"other_servies_general":0.008749326330916012,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.06919389105007907,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.03236078957662461,"financial_general":0.006288578300345881,"miscellaneous_general":0.007362714345436017,"loans_advances":0.00830014216660559,"staff_loans_advances":0.011678788272070926,"grants_contribution_general":0.0068940004348512305,"grants_to_other_states":0.024959015738639866,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.003057081956501262,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.003057081956501262,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.13010814612709964,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.1241858896752412,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.1241858896752412,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.0059222564518584455,"capital_expenditure":0.0059222564518584455,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.3903499492112192,"other_capital_projects":0.15361180841119837},"expenditure":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.14999150893881283,"recurrent_expenditure":0.006127231731124126,"capital_expenditure":0.08061940013008384,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":143263642987.58997,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":87340687223.56998,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":55922955764.020004},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6096500507887808,"governors_office":0.39034994921121935,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.476811192155533,"state_assembly":0.30529518434459624,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":41014292227.869995,"office_head_of_service":15818837375.3,"office_auditor_general_state":3840707488.94,"office_auditor_general_lga":6457875632.97,"civil_service_commission":925069120.2,"lga_service_commission":4953519382.959999,"state_inec":8375147771.309999,"economic_sector":284637683.36,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":154337723.29999998,"ministry_finance":61469484.62,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":64717749.51,"ministry_labour_productivity":77972815.4,"ministry_science_tech":61628205101.51998,"ministry_transport":7357823596.830001,"ministry_energy":38383860990.29999,"ministry_works":286726885.15,"ministry_culture_tourism":69592964.6,"state_planning_commission":361584390.80999994,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":154519777.14000002,"ministry_water_resources":576696509.06,"ministry_housing_urban_development":8928021618.230001,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":307235054.22,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":4647419995.9,"regional_sector":28728009.98,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":525995309.3,"state_capital_dev_agency":3689448661.16,"social_sector":3026480198.83,"ministry_youth_development":662968462.33,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":36931696997.04,"ministry_sports":772188709.0999999,"minsitry_lga":810750777.13},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","admin_sector":21603324558.15,"governors_office":10168674535.29,"secretary_to_state_gov":3011574284.33,"state_assembly":246556693.87,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":318627439.16999996,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.28628542017057873,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.1104176680518328,"civil_service_commission":0.026808668332360463,"lga_service_commission":0.045076863175463174,"state_inec":0.006457110128632794,"economic_sector":0.03457624893280907,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.05845968730556072,"ministry_finance":0.0019868103129602552,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.001077298608924591,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0004290654861074885,"ministry_science_tech":0.0004517388233357019,"ministry_transport":0.0005442610125916892,"ministry_energy":0.43017337697365704,"ministry_works":0.05135862416584897,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.26792464710411507,"state_planning_commission":0.002001393229787108,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.00048576849749680295,"ministry_water_resources":0.002523908950446846,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0010785693698532085,"ministry_land_survey":0.0040254212236523635,"law_justuce_sector":0.062318823059688465,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.0021445430802469107,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.032439632966073426,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0002005254744393769,"social_sector":0.0036715198520085343,"ministry_youth_development":0.025752860839086664,"ministry_women_affairs":0.02112524947513839,"ministry_education":0.004627611363948274,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.2577883420166772},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.005389983759989193,"governors_office":0.0056591523168249315,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.15079418691050145,"state_assembly":0.07097875164441299,"ministry_of_info":0.021021204134749474,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0017209997507278071,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0022240634994713944,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.2239056526144284,"lga_service_commission":0.08635836226161306,"state_inec":0.02096723044821621,"economic_sector":0.035254902122153625,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.005050147005367279,"ministry_finance":0.02704230476580577,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.04572169420988271,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0015538970146624334,"ministry_science_tech":0.0008425621114346419,"ministry_transport":0.00033557485262079444,"ministry_energy":0.00035330781424351796,"ministry_works":0.0004256700084283774,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.33644134113169116,"state_planning_commission":0.040167907448384124,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.20954557492167536,"ministry_water_resources":0.001565302406900686,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.00037992263939513676,"ministry_land_survey":0.0019739652838502274,"law_justuce_sector":0.000843555981659921,"judiciary":0.003148307607117467,"ministry_justice":0.04873994889096566,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0016772608177403378,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.025371243794089837,"ministry_youth_development":0.0001568322522097504,"ministry_women_affairs":0.002871519087702686,"ministry_education":0.020141476675370154,"ministry_health":0.01652219231966175,"ministry_environment":0.0036192843557084063,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.20161790607863952,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.004215540667919691,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.00442605911257426,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.11793709512185555},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.05551293425711445,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.016440817795498452,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0013460048789993514,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0017394542446777699},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":41014292227.869995,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":61628205101.51998,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":3689448661.16,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":36931696997.04,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.28628542017057873,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.43017337697365704,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.025752860839086664,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.2577883420166772,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.2239056526144284},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.33644134113169116,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.020141476675370154,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.20161790607863952,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"katsina","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.9044032699661153,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.0484961507459096,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.1937734470302306,"federation_revenue_performance":1.449995899093345,"igr_performance":0.5816631783290089,"aids_grant_performance":1.9843809239118757,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.20810592399963476,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.6836276083122004,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.657212670544991,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.7336101889996506,"total_expenditure_performance":0.9044032699661153},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7433351909783142,"satutory_allocation":0.6364628389041006,"derivation":0.2101211365213925,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.18984675132179837,"igr":0.23649495106090976,"tax_revenue":0.10687235207421368,"personal_taxes":0.06890231865031946,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.06881038506460137,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.06881038506460137,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.00009193358571809923,"lottery_tax":0.00009193358571809923,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.03797003342389423,"fees_general":0.0030210997442138778,"fines_general":0.03135929216853125,"sales_general":0.0006154261988800262,"earnings_general":0.0002649048209845884,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0016410503226491069,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.000003637079970248047,"repayments":0.00011696407921073975,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.000014899360600235857,"reimbursement":0.00003479563432702658,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.0008979640145271291,"domestic_aids":0.2097657219404365,"foreign_aids":0.000042650651289362136,"domestic_grants":0.000016731230018134283,"foreign_grants":0.16357863862203792,"capital_development_fund":0.04612770143709108,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.04689908708124929,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.009988270422452988,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.03674118522637712,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.0001696314324191775,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.8617661084793942,"derivation":0.7378664571931124,"vat":0.24359841472188626,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.22009383933339752,"tax_revenue":0.2741742031378286,"personal_taxes":0.12389965128628182,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.07988009141655886,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.0797735106312491,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.0797735106312491,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.00010658078530975195,"property_tax":0.00010658078530975195,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.04401955986972296,"fines_general":0.00350243255195924,"sales_general":0.036355570817488594,"earnings_general":0.0007134781817165147,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.00030711043882756145,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.001902508541949862,"repayments":0.000004216553030489376,"investment_income":0.0001355992297911473,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.00001727318194958302,"miscellaneous_income":0.00004033940374410245,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.0010410309692658608,"foreign_aids":0.2431863741726904,"domestic_grants":0.000049445911120354224,"foreign_grants":0.000019396911592231936,"capital_development_fund":0.18964059356606358,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.05347693778391426,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.054371223447731945,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.011579638683685377,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.04259492702314335,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0.00019665774090322144,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.17762390624968988,"ovetimes_payments":0.12909528750515584,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.12909528750515584,"allowances":0.11045097146601138,"social_contribution":0.0019107264657791756,"nhis_contribution":0.016733589573365255,"contributory_pension":0.02522952263090765,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.02329909611362642,"gratuity_arrears":0.00021645529656986556,"pension_arrears":0.023080060954442313,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.00000257986261424342,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.3155803337400965,"materials_supplies_general":0.14271165503775252,"maintainance_services_general":0.014376932666373994,"training_general":0.001070477909377678,"other_servies_general":0.006421210295304118,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.005500327736939517,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.00099945733833335,"financial_general":0.07867603806348275,"miscellaneous_general":0.0013821207720553827,"loans_advances":0.006026941902047462,"staff_loans_advances":0.0035756703076329412,"grants_contribution_general":0.024682478046205332,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.0000014432390648456612,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.0000014432390648456612,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.15557870939926072,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.01190948745342634,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.01190948745342634,"transfers_payment":0.14366922194583437,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.14366922194583437,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.017288526064018383,"construction_provision":0.017288526064018383,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.36936761525518985,"preservation_of_environment":0.057395276150080686,"other_capital_projects":0.18948009300004112},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.046751984883059323,"personal_cost":0.007110557629585338,"salaries_wages":0.06862970359242337,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.2059236052853168,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.14966322715049857,"allowances":0.14966322715049857,"social_contribution":0.1280484295823014,"nhis_contribution":0.0022151504876501177,"contributory_pension":0.01939964708054705,"group_life_insurance":0.029249183679593047,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.02701119445522521,"pension_arrears":0.0002509417566243114,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.026757261802713726,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.0000029908958871730425,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.36585976208378557,"maintainance_services_general":0.16544900482200578,"training_general":0.016667518861128213,"other_servies_general":0.001241030417197713,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0074442613171982665,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.006376660336752337,"financial_general":0.0011586945855652775,"miscellaneous_general":0.09121099602900705,"loans_advances":0.0016023253757367858,"staff_loans_advances":0.0069871766223299405,"grants_contribution_general":0.004145359352836092,"grants_to_other_states":0.02861498192425412,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.0000016731812614449051,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.0000016731812614449051,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.18036608597097728,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.01380695113225549,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.01380695113225549,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.16655913483872178,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.16655913483872178,"construction_provision":0.020042998109541063,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.020042998109541063,"preservation_of_environment":0.42821663263089776,"other_capital_projects":0.06653970425893395},"expenditure":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.21966876364894558,"recurrent_expenditure":0.05420068438215093,"capital_expenditure":0.008243438023567199,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.07956404231730015,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":145172555775.71997,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":83007252791.01999,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":62165302984.7},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.5717833673691023,"governors_office":0.42821663263089776,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.4932042399897863,"state_assembly":0.36936761525518985,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":20798002841.561142,"office_head_of_service":14250091185.513699,"office_auditor_general_state":0,"office_auditor_general_lga":4992413028.376541,"civil_service_commission":1024390796.3664567,"lga_service_commission":70700514.76782587,"state_inec":200047339.7987075,"economic_sector":47488939.121170886,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":27871736.0855486,"ministry_finance":64815753.71295048,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":23703178.53768156,"ministry_labour_productivity":96480369.28056091,"ministry_science_tech":97653165172.44247,"ministry_transport":503709655.5801375,"ministry_energy":62172687147.85436,"ministry_works":722823331.1127323,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":42498345.60944946,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":96629853.56582707,"ministry_water_resources":39488055.516979665,"ministry_housing_urban_development":26084253216.111633,"ministry_land_survey":76691446.35361792,"law_justuce_sector":1470875451.4871156,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":3115584291.2581105,"regional_sector":2884677263.778647,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":443247114.21385527,"state_capital_dev_agency":2141258219.0170338,"social_sector":70142180.03160848,"ministry_youth_development":2071116038.9854252,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":24580129542.69933,"ministry_sports":259570668.7250266,"minsitry_lga":191121952.66035533},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","admin_sector":5520150396.12148,"governors_office":6898629071.06438,"secretary_to_state_gov":10022600995.944616,"state_assembly":1147517115.347183,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":540539342.8362906,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.14326401247417866,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.09815967700898615,"civil_service_commission":0,"lga_service_commission":0.034389509791984525,"state_inec":0.007056366755360145,"economic_sector":0.00048701019548799934,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0013779969549324784,"ministry_finance":0.0003271206383838658,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00019199039333996578,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00044647387632332973,"ministry_science_tech":0.00016327589199642586,"ministry_transport":0.000664590967383776,"ministry_energy":0.6726696010181762,"ministry_works":0.0034697305760623843,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.4282674973629741,"state_planning_commission":0.004979063206887648,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.00029274366206727127,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.000665620668104187,"ministry_land_survey":0.0002720077173400843,"law_justuce_sector":0.17967757801557013,"judiciary":0.0005282778548867052,"ministry_justice":0.010131911252974708,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.021461248475031603,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.019870679057515824,"social_sector":0.003053243168761434,"ministry_youth_development":0.014749745277785886,"ministry_women_affairs":0.00048316418800239735,"ministry_education":0.014266581089783488,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.1693166412298594},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0017880147341763591,"governors_office":0.0013165157259862775,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.03802475176265183,"state_assembly":0.047520201281860824,"ministry_of_info":0.06903922674908841,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.007904504465155284,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.003723426510940407,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.12357550502969167,"lga_service_commission":0.0846697747078888,"state_inec":0,"economic_sector":0.02966342326223736,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.006086623363459972,"ministry_finance":0.00042008128784530206,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0011886213899380354,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0002821650559396921,"ministry_science_tech":0.00016560550977246698,"ministry_transport":0.0003851157998186305,"ministry_energy":0.00014083718907613538,"ministry_works":0.000573257463715277,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.5802258657171461,"state_planning_commission":0.0029928919401943505,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.36941148974150345,"ministry_water_resources":0.004294799787747079,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.00025251244370057453,"law_justuce_sector":0.000574145654576029,"judiciary":0.00023462620138698758,"ministry_justice":0.15498482181481427,"regional_sector":0.0004556776093744616,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.008739501486655844,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.018511868912981424,"ministry_youth_development":0.017139888499618918,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0026336416245926,"ministry_education":0.012722715148650596,"ministry_health":0.00041676383003316027,"ministry_environment":0.012305951318617435,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.14604776934948782,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0015422911864638547,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0011355894122231699,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.03279908067314027},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.04098958818130938,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.059551293901639775,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.006818203081301191,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.003211722913410195},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":20798002841.561142,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":97653165172.44247,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":2141258219.0170338,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":24580129542.69933,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.14326401247417866,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.6726696010181762,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.014749745277785886,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.1693166412298594,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.12357550502969167},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.5802258657171461,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.012722715148650596,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.14604776934948782,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"abia","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.40721824412305063,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.41356337645649366,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.9838662656672493,"federation_revenue_performance":1.8889946604561232,"igr_performance":0.21833832079189858,"aids_grant_performance":0,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.17059177150253318,"personnel_expenditure_performance":2.4619497696971377,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.7429894610970635,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.20244918865209574,"total_expenditure_performance":0.40721824412305063},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7725992115947505,"satutory_allocation":0.6797087282096184,"derivation":0.32058564663897043,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.18074392948309653,"igr":0.17837915208755137,"tax_revenue":0.09289048338513214,"personal_taxes":0.05736580045500359,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.05736580045500359,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.05736580045500359,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.03552468293012855,"fees_general":0.0016577213662977365,"fines_general":0,"sales_general":0.031090433299957438,"earnings_general":0.0015786043781842373,"rent_on_government_building_general":0,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0004273296804073882,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0007695370346693559,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.0000010571706123961005,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.22740078840524933,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.214043413616642,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0.013357374788607325,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.784637582441419,"derivation":0.6902997120148111,"vat":0.3255809001215526,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.18356021821177687,"tax_revenue":0.18115859368148168,"personal_taxes":0.09433787042660774,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.05825965430500667,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.05825965430500667,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.05825965430500667,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.03607821612160107,"fines_general":0.0016835514011572666,"sales_general":0,"earnings_general":0.03157487356372102,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0016032016397909761,"rent_on_land_others_general":0,"repayments":0.000433988182110896,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0.0007815276917455818,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.0000010736430753357847,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.23094406800036635,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.21737856326698302,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0.013565504733383322,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.3110362283473788,"ovetimes_payments":0.25943695969952896,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.25943695969952896,"allowances":0.06436675689329949,"social_contribution":0.06110780550050564,"nhis_contribution":0.13396239730572385,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.05159926864784986,"gratuity_arrears":0.00008551899552751503,"pension_arrears":0.05151374965232234,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.28820359307692,"materials_supplies_general":0.17352312666717362,"maintainance_services_general":0.16330016891568935,"training_general":0,"other_servies_general":0,"consulting_professional_services_general":0,"fuel_lubricant_general":0,"financial_general":0.0014895508700586999,"miscellaneous_general":0.008017380700160377,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0.0007160261812651953,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.11468046640974641,"domestic_debt_interest":0.009653070268296043,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.009653070268296043,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.10502739614145037,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.10502739614145037,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.38541759097084716,"preservation_of_environment":0.22190641661745136,"other_capital_projects":0.13249848896560304},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.008359362077222052,"personal_cost":0.008166088309371308,"salaries_wages":0.014487235001199365,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.31588268613221904,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.2634794157172466,"allowances":0.2634794157172466,"social_contribution":0.06536969719928226,"nhis_contribution":0.06205996596507912,"contributory_pension":0.1360497525528852,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.05240327041497243,"pension_arrears":0.00008685152262195737,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.052316418892350475,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.2926942807203112,"maintainance_services_general":0.17622690337046718,"training_general":0.16584465506481813,"other_servies_general":0,"consulting_professional_services_general":0,"fuel_lubricant_general":0,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0.001512760531031212,"loans_advances":0.008142304723688992,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0.0007271830509288361,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.116467377349844,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.009803481034906624,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.009803481034906624,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.10666389631493738,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.10666389631493738,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.3914230331474699,"other_capital_projects":0.22536408483197368},"expenditure":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.13456303410472983,"recurrent_expenditure":0.008489614735025642,"capital_expenditure":0.00829332944288468,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.014712970032856052,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":193211323917.25,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":117583961471.19998,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":75627362446.05},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6085769668529352,"governors_office":0.3914230331470647,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.599239821425318,"state_assembly":0.38541759097084716,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":74918237731.33,"office_head_of_service":63007090796.75,"office_auditor_general_state":7212383563.84,"office_auditor_general_lga":2326924164.31,"civil_service_commission":1639377876.66,"lga_service_commission":93114675.25,"state_inec":354652751.49,"economic_sector":73846476.75,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":59026291.47,"ministry_finance":65463560.32,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0,"ministry_labour_productivity":86357574.49,"ministry_science_tech":103284158293.43999,"ministry_transport":404668955.67,"ministry_energy":57082941168.04,"ministry_works":6447552164.2,"ministry_culture_tourism":165186798.09,"state_planning_commission":31530007.86,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":51693812.73,"ministry_water_resources":11824056798.4,"ministry_housing_urban_development":24230231191.54,"ministry_land_survey":106618452.75999999,"law_justuce_sector":137230042.37,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":1724600000,"regional_sector":713432001.84,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":364416899.94,"state_capital_dev_agency":4053406286.3599997,"social_sector":3270403119.08,"ministry_youth_development":783003167.28,"ministry_women_affairs":3000000,"ministry_education":3000000,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":10952521606.119999,"ministry_sports":921712651.01,"minsitry_lga":226200000},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","admin_sector":4430649877.29,"governors_office":4843877079.299999,"secretary_to_state_gov":238804743.25,"state_assembly":170674039.29,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":120603215.97999999,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.3877528304888284,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.3261045445959491,"civil_service_commission":0.0373289899247129,"lga_service_commission":0.012043415039736497,"state_inec":0.008484895416191145,"economic_sector":0.0004819317696408739,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0018355691804185375,"ministry_finance":0.0003822057385296111,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00030550120082682795,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0003388184449691209,"ministry_science_tech":0,"ministry_transport":0.0004469591778537539,"ministry_energy":0.5345657604301818,"ministry_works":0.0020944370519594057,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.29544304138481553,"state_planning_commission":0.0333704672867315,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.0008549540199875575,"ministry_water_resources":0.00016318923353341624,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0002675506366914256,"ministry_land_survey":0.06119753521008083,"law_justuce_sector":0.1254079248581858,"judiciary":0.0005518230018742261,"ministry_justice":0.000710258796368043,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.008925977862148545,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.003692495798777781,"social_sector":0.0018861052890277407,"ministry_youth_development":0.02097913416348319,"ministry_women_affairs":0.016926560269749296,"ministry_education":0.0040525738937338945,"ministry_health":0.00001552704023335593,"ministry_environment":0.00001552704023335593,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.05668674787830844},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.004770489805275141,"governors_office":0.0011707388335950371,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.022931626301531782,"state_assembly":0.0250703580985739,"ministry_of_info":0.001235976952119661,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0008833542249484002,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0006242036622645248,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.38180369871802344,"lga_service_commission":0.3211012570521447,"state_inec":0.03675626662659228,"economic_sector":0.011858637889427724,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.008354715164950208,"ministry_finance":0.0004745376892455964,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0018074067994631958,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00037634171350314256,"ministry_science_tech":0.0003008140218897542,"ministry_transport":0.00033362009329504174,"ministry_energy":0,"ministry_works":0.0004401016675117391,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.5263641384202262,"state_planning_commission":0.0020623029680068663,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.29091018064012447,"ministry_water_resources":0.0328584779689699,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0008418368130377762,"ministry_land_survey":0.0001606854884217608,"law_justuce_sector":0.00026344571760925295,"judiciary":0.06025860666491902,"ministry_justice":0.12348384278470612,"regional_sector":0.0005433566091255972,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0006993615885626481,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.008789030264839542,"ministry_youth_development":0.003635843358504477,"ministry_women_affairs":0.001857167553398854,"ministry_education":0.020657259959705958,"ministry_health":0.016666863035961824,"ministry_environment":0.003990396923744137,"ministry_sports":0.000015288815258331574,"minsitry_lga":0.000015288815258331574},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.05581702648295122,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.004697298147519644,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0011527766704782006,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.022579795816078753},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.024685713933161466,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.0012170138674541845,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0008698012853660114,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0006146267628929607},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":74918237731.33,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":103284158293.43999,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":4053406286.3599997,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":3000000},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":10952521606.119999,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.3877528304888284,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5345657604301818,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.02097913416348319,"health_total_expenditure":0.00001552704023335593,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.05668674787830844,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.38180369871802344},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.5263641384202262,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.020657259959705958,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.000015288815258331574,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.05581702648295122,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"imo","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.0785781124922873,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.3195148985546086,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.5499209457966003,"federation_revenue_performance":1.6833907678171922,"igr_performance":1.2414377147688742,"aids_grant_performance":1.4467414029969143,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.771186495192917,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.2272196114064728,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.6270528867284746,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.7508939596100184,"total_expenditure_performance":1.0785781124922873},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7747991303354945,"satutory_allocation":0.5873810629547596,"derivation":0.17683275608248972,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.1730521063955838,"igr":0.23749620047668604,"tax_revenue":0.1874180673807348,"personal_taxes":0.08372813924276182,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.08372813924276182,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.08372813924276182,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.10368992813797297,"fees_general":0.0011498510230594735,"fines_general":0.05730042442304516,"sales_general":0.0007518335557407829,"earnings_general":0.009842545133579583,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0016422128461053393,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00019194157173547648,"repayments":0.00314962974728848,"investment_income":0.02762067981921116,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.000021480976945944536,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.0020193290412615647,"domestic_aids":0.05625205935046199,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.04772399221746177,"capital_development_fund":0.008528067133000226,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.1689488103140434,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.002561588414795079,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.15346804213342902,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.01291917976581932,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.862534842024379,"derivation":0.6538941675430346,"vat":0.19685671725818985,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.19264795920365652,"tax_revenue":0.26438949108118825,"personal_taxes":0.20864067448134424,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.09320923904945477,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.09320923904945477,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.09320923904945477,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.11543143543188944,"fines_general":0.001280056380673429,"sales_general":0.06378893650314281,"earnings_general":0.0008369687211041459,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.010957082654744134,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.001828171641303383,"repayments":0.0002136764056292667,"investment_income":0.0035062834870973783,"interest_earned":0.030748354988670866,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0.000023913412304137175,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.0022479912372198917,"foreign_aids":0.06262185800903963,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.053128100531342745,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.00949375747769689,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.1880800193352442,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.0028516542832592476,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.17084625975255024,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0.014382105299434712,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.26341281293159835,"ovetimes_payments":0.20982892591246788,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.20982892591246788,"allowances":0.1766194235115715,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.03320950240089635,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.053583887019130486,"gratuity_arrears":0.0005872466273311548,"pension_arrears":0.05298378298194967,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.00001285740984965846,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.31693653644170305,"materials_supplies_general":0.2814579606750849,"maintainance_services_general":0.024091496076009026,"training_general":0.007345692772882958,"other_servies_general":0.015996891859490724,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.04363583902159831,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.00154975844656761,"financial_general":0.09795407089523042,"miscellaneous_general":0.022915585035633467,"loans_advances":0.01649989741265832,"staff_loans_advances":0.006766925718333166,"grants_contribution_general":0.044701803436680926,"grants_to_other_states":0.0016656293725464742,"grants_to_lga":0.0016656293725464742,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.03381294639407166,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.015034295366536549,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.015034295366536549,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.01877865102753511,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.01877865102753511,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.317932195424393,"preservation_of_environment":0.033060991581131224,"other_capital_projects":0.12158561180864787},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.08468392728454373,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0.07860166475007019,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.2932408157076438,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.23358926511144595,"allowances":0.23358926511144595,"social_contribution":0.19661922760680636,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.03697003750463959,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.05965155059619791,"pension_arrears":0.0006537445088704466,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.05898349274656684,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.000014313340760612117,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.3528253900764282,"maintainance_services_general":0.31332933678212566,"training_general":0.026819538056339305,"other_servies_general":0.008177494923974321,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.017808327413754724,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.04857701827930319,"financial_general":0.0017252480088708014,"miscellaneous_general":0.10904606853221174,"loans_advances":0.025510470707482226,"staff_loans_advances":0.018368291665587236,"grants_contribution_general":0.007533190186888647,"grants_to_other_states":0.049763689007713496,"grants_to_lga":0.0018542397783777214,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.0018542397783777214,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.03764181351592479,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.01673672965186264,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.01673672965186264,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.020905083864062157,"capital_expenditure":0.020905083864062157,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.35393379421592785,"other_capital_projects":0.03680470980685351},"expenditure":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.13535356761229092,"recurrent_expenditure":0.09427325739349987,"capital_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.0875022594032836,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":179693720216.44,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":116094040023.46002,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":63599680192.979996},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6460662057840723,"governors_office":0.35393379421592785,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.5803493493733015,"state_assembly":0.317932195424393,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":58967866293.34,"office_head_of_service":48018026117.439995,"office_auditor_general_state":5380618204.93,"office_auditor_general_lga":2376194603.66,"civil_service_commission":442156230.79,"lga_service_commission":1152185361.2,"state_inec":1263022213.55,"economic_sector":59435171.33,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":32379095.65,"ministry_finance":106319649.78999999,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":21965469.33,"ministry_labour_productivity":115564175.67,"ministry_science_tech":78564968409.17001,"ministry_transport":4344054990.25,"ministry_energy":27432802909.97001,"ministry_works":418201472.99,"ministry_culture_tourism":79143315.21000001,"state_planning_commission":1799141837.5,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":617001949.5899999,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":34620077468.91,"ministry_land_survey":185129634.56,"law_justuce_sector":866735681.22,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":4901221103.47,"regional_sector":2804550761.6400003,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":496907283.86,"state_capital_dev_agency":3371550867.7100005,"social_sector":2545205087.6400003,"ministry_youth_development":826345780.07,"ministry_women_affairs":188339818.49,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":188339818.49,"ministry_environment":38600994827.72998,"ministry_sports":1122347342.4499998,"minsitry_lga":160591564.44},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","admin_sector":23734911457.83,"governors_office":11679332635.71999,"secretary_to_state_gov":1729492603.3400002,"state_assembly":0,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":174319223.95,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.32815763523796804,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.267221503676381,"civil_service_commission":0.02994327346803816,"lga_service_commission":0.013223581774576694,"state_inec":0.002460610366669606,"economic_sector":0.006411940048946617,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.007028749875224895,"ministry_finance":0.0003307581993316778,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00018019046859845504,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0005916714822417757,"ministry_science_tech":0.00012223838041497902,"ministry_transport":0.0006431174975441749,"ministry_energy":0.4372159934945917,"ministry_works":0.02417477352585061,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.1526642270911157,"state_planning_commission":0.002327301546688882,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.0004404345077539291,"ministry_water_resources":0.010012268850202136,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0034336311188105225,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.1926615878797007,"judiciary":0.001030250997847963,"ministry_justice":0.004823405515651978,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.027275416734466342,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.015607394394539419,"social_sector":0.002765301331963511,"ministry_youth_development":0.018762764016733515,"ministry_women_affairs":0.014164129300536024,"ministry_education":0.004598634716197492,"ministry_health":0.0010481157508628895,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0.0010481157508628895,"minsitry_lga":0.21481549149984383},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.006245890736182317,"governors_office":0.0008936960303708355,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.1320853696458699,"state_assembly":0.06499577515370211,"ministry_of_info":0.009624669138447558,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0009700907952711621,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.2947779475187202,"lga_service_commission":0.24004014512558228,"state_inec":0.026897489947169135,"economic_sector":0.011878499464225391,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.002210320881317195,"ministry_finance":0.0057597274123179715,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.006313796295913621,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00029711398625016324,"ministry_science_tech":0.00016186177249044063,"ministry_transport":0.0005314875730808839,"ministry_energy":0.00010980448119273558,"ministry_works":0.0005777005791804088,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.39274305804658055,"state_planning_commission":0.021715752907935492,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.13713545774675345,"ministry_water_resources":0.002090572028569752,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.00039563419000741157,"ministry_land_survey":0.008993836329689411,"law_justuce_sector":0.0030843674656705522,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.1730643487837543,"regional_sector":0.0009254554578762344,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.004332776157785579,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.02450100347923731,"ministry_youth_development":0.014019834346993746,"ministry_women_affairs":0.002484019152307305,"ministry_education":0.016854244645625977,"ministry_health":0.012723375948799787,"ministry_environment":0.00413086869682619,"ministry_sports":0.0009415030358119118,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.0009415030358119118,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.1929647915509557,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.005610568379135461,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0008027906507410814,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.11864984989066651},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.05838450531039114,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.008645662661851367,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0008714146581702035},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":58967866293.34,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":78564968409.17001,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":3371550867.7100005,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":188339818.49},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":38600994827.72998,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.32815763523796804,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.4372159934945917,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.018762764016733515,"health_total_expenditure":0.0010481157508628895,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.21481549149984383,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.2947779475187202},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.39274305804658055,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.016854244645625977,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.0009415030358119118,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.1929647915509557,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"enugu","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.5009650014096447,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.7269238035197763,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.9981743844802866,"federation_revenue_performance":1.681112031310863,"igr_performance":3.6246938774373336,"aids_grant_performance":0.09629774735525608,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":28.42530249409412,"personnel_expenditure_performance":2.2198542965155816,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.4130865557862697,"capital_expenditure_performance":1.0984561227862366,"total_expenditure_performance":1.5009650014096447},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.6462726950329473,"satutory_allocation":0.4550252688935409,"derivation":0.12232893901025056,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.13274841727757258,"igr":0.19994791260571773,"tax_revenue":0.19124742613940648,"personal_taxes":0.02332211648342488,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.021673678272405378,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.021591903250441375,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.00008177502196400383,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.0016484382110195015,"lottery_tax":0.0000010250680252090773,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0.0005112477973950039,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.0011361653455992883,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.1679253096559816,"fees_general":0.00010630733191782258,"fines_general":0.010903025103607088,"sales_general":0.0000236281665041978,"earnings_general":0.02228124395540536,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0008775134090591051,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00005172729420627332,"repayments":0.00004814135647918316,"investment_income":0.0029050493422719463,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0010124302002304487,"miscellaneous_income":0.12971624349630015,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.023498126439679936,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.01681308904046125,"capital_development_fund":0.006685037399218688,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.33022917852737277,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.07309773135778234,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.2571314471695904,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.6808729041966011,"derivation":0.47938645512261663,"vat":0.12887819741007625,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.13985551469828883,"tax_revenue":0.21065274301425155,"personal_taxes":0.20148644907398447,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.024570738179293464,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.02283404572616688,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.022747892625280368,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.00008615310088651294,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.001736692453126583,"property_tax":0.0000010799482148748334,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.0005386190307153636,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.0011969934741963447,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.17691571089469102,"fines_general":0.0001119988239896006,"sales_general":0.011486752301121042,"earnings_general":0.00002489317353525797,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.023474139318629888,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0009244938056172608,"repayments":0.00005449667501527635,"investment_income":0.000050718753012262494,"interest_earned":0.0030605801509319343,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0.0010666337848175827,"aids_grants":0.1366610041080209,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.024756171373367657,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.01771322980450426,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.007042941568863396,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.3479090197721064,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.07701124466850469,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.2708977751036017,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.43325551606040386,"ovetimes_payments":0.1793462850255314,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.1793462850255314,"allowances":0.14774460973679748,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.03160167528873393,"contributory_pension":0.24737020716740477,"group_life_insurance":0.004514804368989709,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0.004514804368989709,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.0020242194984779155,"gratuity_arrears":0.00014321866837014154,"pension_arrears":0.001871222688857486,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.000009778141250287949,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.16021484561024096,"materials_supplies_general":0.10304393904323383,"maintainance_services_general":0.005805148776712325,"training_general":0.0028013741901090914,"other_servies_general":0.007652980135565809,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.02277210652963325,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.010648822007740996,"financial_general":0.005704113176559505,"miscellaneous_general":0.0007391265991240787,"loans_advances":0.004666893263012692,"staff_loans_advances":0.0006390266800396021,"grants_contribution_general":0.04161434768473648,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.0015715825036976844,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0.0015715825036976844,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.040506368678465104,"public_debt_charges":0.040506368678465104,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.015092955384844328,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.0028278512042450286,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0028278512042450286,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.012265104180599302,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.008783188420832222,"capital_expenditure":0.0034819157597670786,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.3557122112436344,"preservation_of_environment":0.03415070281335769,"other_capital_projects":0.17365865380823778},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.002655419064205603,"personal_cost":0.1452474355578333,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.45645119118672567,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.18894814353247527,"allowances":0.18894814353247527,"social_contribution":0.15565457473916383,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.03329356879331146,"group_life_insurance":0.26061393690352214,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.004756518395747497,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0.004756518395747497,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.0021325923549807137,"pension_arrears":0.00015088632309210722,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.0019714043875797924,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.000010301644308814142,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.1687924432897379,"maintainance_services_general":0.10856071527615346,"training_general":0.0061159453853948794,"other_servies_general":0.0029513544285879804,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.008062706115714737,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.023991281740156644,"financial_general":0.01121893965567222,"miscellaneous_general":0.006009500531648135,"loans_advances":0.0007786980294578473,"staff_loans_advances":0.0049167498394791535,"grants_contribution_general":0.0006732389513616921,"grants_to_other_states":0.04384230059868016,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.0016557220376185882,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.0016557220376185882,"public_debt_charges":0.04267500250673401,"foreign_debt_interest":0.04267500250673401,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.01590100346923181,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.002979248971631101,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.002979248971631101,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.012921754497600711,"capital_expenditure":0.009253423599914148,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.0036683308976865627,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.37475636552353647,"other_capital_projects":0.03597906639657811},"expenditure":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.18295600737279963,"recurrent_expenditure":0.0027975851432382065,"capital_expenditure":0.1530237066109205,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":277791097635.89,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":173687115511.07,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":104103982124.82},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6252436344764635,"governors_office":0.37475636552353647,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.5934703616706447,"state_assembly":0.3557122112436344,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":26661024476.429996,"office_head_of_service":11866467645.92,"office_auditor_general_state":4249286452.8699994,"office_auditor_general_lga":5144676709.429999,"civil_service_commission":396848424.76,"lga_service_commission":0,"state_inec":2184679988,"economic_sector":90207139.52000001,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":204720719.38,"ministry_finance":1650540444.77,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":749061576.36,"ministry_labour_productivity":124535375.42,"ministry_science_tech":155225016978.68002,"ministry_transport":7503067070.510035,"ministry_energy":92263659897.70001,"ministry_works":203063066.94,"ministry_culture_tourism":895297444.21,"state_planning_commission":1324519581.4499998,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":3008702193.6400003,"ministry_water_resources":2051812057.05,"ministry_housing_urban_development":35586429242.17,"ministry_land_survey":9369226.38,"law_justuce_sector":480054122.04999995,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":10281270721.619999,"regional_sector":1122544139.65,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":495228215.31,"state_capital_dev_agency":3265256145.3200006,"social_sector":2952393078.5200005,"ministry_youth_development":312863066.8,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":92639800035.45999,"ministry_sports":86955234.18,"minsitry_lga":948549639.7199999},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","admin_sector":51338908185.899994,"governors_office":29469378508.17,"secretary_to_state_gov":10165127724.449999,"state_assembly":298369734.08,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":332511008.96000004,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0959750859668494,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.04271723517027091,"civil_service_commission":0.015296697730895897,"lga_service_commission":0.018519948094856867,"state_inec":0.001428585826318172,"economic_sector":0,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.007864470843711242,"ministry_finance":0.0003247301309786302,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.000736959251474409,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.005941660689693584,"ministry_science_tech":0.002696492374071036,"ministry_transport":0.00044830585457865407,"ministry_energy":0.5587832666334707,"ministry_works":0.027009746296278194,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.33213324934779964,"state_planning_commission":0.0007309919888295394,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.003222916255521968,"ministry_water_resources":0.004768041858512297,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.010830808543705047,"ministry_land_survey":0.007386169227566025,"law_justuce_sector":0.1281050024461702,"judiciary":0.000033727597679463996,"ministry_justice":0.001728111973837343,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.03701079987486136,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.004040965132444078,"social_sector":0.001782736090265614,"ministry_youth_development":0.011754358484158048,"ministry_women_affairs":0.010628105449188295,"ministry_education":0.0011262530349697526,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.3334872889155219},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.000313023833089047,"governors_office":0.0034146149671192678,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.18481120749661892,"state_assembly":0.10608467571122991,"ministry_of_info":0.03659270513331485,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0010740795389745825,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0011969822351752728,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.09109787903368323,"lga_service_commission":0.04054645518670207,"state_inec":0.014519358909303783,"economic_sector":0.017578811982915145,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0013559887702535543,"ministry_finance":0,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.007464818670043169,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0003082281812250871,"ministry_science_tech":0.0006995088784474609,"ministry_transport":0.005639720780826986,"ministry_energy":0.0025594635694644787,"ministry_works":0.00042552410450150157,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.5303873387246034,"state_planning_commission":0.02563718048326326,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.3152550921663243,"ministry_water_resources":0.0006938448567369482,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.003059135943703596,"ministry_land_survey":0.004525742239025683,"law_justuce_sector":0.010280414720255914,"judiciary":0.0070108231114013935,"ministry_justice":0.12159503582504587,"regional_sector":0.00003201364794361131,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0016402937696109027,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.03513000625083639,"ministry_youth_development":0.003835613681470161,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0016921420289854581,"ministry_education":0.011157032228949922,"ministry_health":0.010088012475464817,"ministry_environment":0.0010690197534851055,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.3165403229270426,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0002971167672749516,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0032410930200018734,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.17541957743503547},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.10069372543836215,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.03473315800833334,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.001019497580318477,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0011361546777163502},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":26661024476.429996,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":155225016978.68002,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":3265256145.3200006,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":92639800035.45999,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.0959750859668494,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5587832666334707,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.011754358484158048,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.3334872889155219,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.09109787903368323},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.5303873387246034,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.011157032228949922,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.3165403229270426,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"jigawa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.6242523449478274,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.0169746314274613,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.1341499797980852,"federation_revenue_performance":1.3143826204257265,"igr_performance":0.7535631229042019,"aids_grant_performance":0.5840650433105271,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.9476920641844614,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.5665448022736869,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.5752198097178227,"total_expenditure_performance":0.6242523449478274},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.9783242792956819,"satutory_allocation":0.7694224123597281,"derivation":0.18382017883355123,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.22888349539197853,"igr":0.3567187381341983,"tax_revenue":0.20890186693595375,"personal_taxes":0.14158462808364813,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.13251343475717794,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.13251343475717794,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.009071193326470184,"lottery_tax":0.009071193326470184,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.06731723885230562,"fees_general":0.004526610421805681,"fines_general":0.04877996935369834,"sales_general":0.0005502183945060691,"earnings_general":0.0016097408159707945,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0002215656884182918,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.000005343733724211411,"repayments":0.0003255453541272484,"investment_income":0.00006237988605976243,"interest_earned":0.00003278797116329485,"reimbursement":0.00004466878830048207,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.011158408444531424,"domestic_aids":0.021675720704318113,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.009636547731276951,"capital_development_fund":0.012039172973041164,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":1.042933702804327,"derivation":0.8202357669388273,"vat":0.1959598303121407,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.24399916920369835,"tax_revenue":0.38027676742298816,"personal_taxes":0.2226979358654998,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.15093500545009364,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.1412647422816886,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.1412647422816886,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.009670263168405052,"property_tax":0.009670263168405052,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.07176293041540617,"fines_general":0.00482555188323158,"sales_general":0.052001442811334266,"earnings_general":0.0005865553167569226,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0017160495607492481,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00023619808761450494,"repayments":0.000005696638750296998,"investment_income":0.00034704466483762107,"interest_earned":0.00006649951036240956,"reimbursement":0.000034953318543208245,"miscellaneous_income":0.00004761875562931252,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.011895319867596784,"foreign_aids":0.02310720497643351,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.010272954091323111,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.012834250885110402,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.195149712525897,"ovetimes_payments":0.074406708881535,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.074406708881535,"allowances":0.07008538286358373,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.00432132601795127,"contributory_pension":0.051247298455968725,"group_life_insurance":0.0007155755743004482,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0.00034047547486876163,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0.00037510009943168653,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.06878012961409283,"gratuity_arrears":0.03523531182476517,"pension_arrears":0.026706784206825332,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0.006838033582502331,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.19721292057603346,"materials_supplies_general":0.1278773679319071,"maintainance_services_general":0.007880417995277276,"training_general":0.001552491246336425,"other_servies_general":0.005387279058571703,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.01890901579013596,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.00021274019656930378,"financial_general":0.06714017442803989,"miscellaneous_general":0.0005298391367969887,"loans_advances":0.0058073527599735485,"staff_loans_advances":0.0031867233534136276,"grants_contribution_general":0.017271333966792386,"grants_to_other_states":3.589419413023216e-7,"grants_to_lga":3.589419413023216e-7,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.010262781424154571,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.010262781424154571,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.04080287905473978,"domestic_debt_interest":0.009786651801271385,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.009786651801271385,"foreign_debt_principal":0.031016227253468396,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.031016227253468396,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.01826953322329071,"construction_provision":0.01826953322329071,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.5456876731304618,"preservation_of_environment":0.029620230572113018,"other_capital_projects":0.07037046885587513},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.37178262375416976,"personal_cost":0.019542891803659274,"salaries_wages":0.05437145814464469,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.2080375766942617,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.07932059548105036,"allowances":0.07932059548105036,"social_contribution":0.07471388517005698,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.004606710310993391,"group_life_insurance":0.05463171656731247,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.0007628328348129889,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0.0003629607843061802,"gratuity":0,"pension":0.0003998720505068087,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.0733224318110859,"pension_arrears":0.03756228380361083,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.02847052447974896,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0.007289623527726112,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.21023704087696976,"maintainance_services_general":0.13632250539474458,"training_general":0.008400847953377229,"other_servies_general":0.0016550191775661668,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.00574305985806806,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.02015778435815728,"financial_general":0.00022678975227219804,"miscellaneous_general":0.07157417249582626,"loans_advances":0.0005648301943688365,"staff_loans_advances":0.006190875608045308,"grants_contribution_general":0.003397177456519213,"grants_to_other_states":0.01841194854054404,"grants_to_lga":3.826467929465154e-7,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":3.826467929465154e-7,"grants_to_private_companies":0.010940544825761267,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.010940544825761267,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.043497538227583385,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.010432971170361563,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.010432971170361563,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.03306456705722182,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.03306456705722182,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0.019476069782087595,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.019476069782087595,"preservation_of_environment":0.5817253824287686,"other_capital_projects":0.0315763774877708},"expenditure":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.07501779850007487,"recurrent_expenditure":0.3963354857240081,"capital_expenditure":0.02083352211903412,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.057962198597880654,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":162551996113.8,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":67991374009.93999,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":94560622103.86},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.4182746175712314,"governors_office":0.5817253824287686,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.3923626331019304,"state_assembly":0.5456876731304618,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":33819920411.84253,"office_head_of_service":27059905947.115025,"office_auditor_general_state":695713755.8775729,"office_auditor_general_lga":3533939967.584075,"civil_service_commission":1208648898.9015281,"lga_service_commission":87538940.97891577,"state_inec":881335129.8749117,"economic_sector":169062036.7402532,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":69204785.6663516,"ministry_finance":72333660.31380033,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":23845978.593570493,"ministry_labour_productivity":18391310.196530484,"ministry_science_tech":106361392440.44595,"ministry_transport":1708775873.5585513,"ministry_energy":28995955533.529827,"ministry_works":298718432.39158475,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":7401515.963062768,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":244806742.16253623,"ministry_water_resources":20321937.407165755,"ministry_housing_urban_development":65809743731.093704,"ministry_land_survey":766179219.3054229,"law_justuce_sector":1768399049.6554565,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":1742253392.056742,"regional_sector":3076324684.99065,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":1922512328.331277,"state_capital_dev_agency":5750906979.393974,"social_sector":3013095580.4180636,"ministry_youth_development":2737811398.9759107,"ministry_women_affairs":38653594.94702401,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":38653594.94702401,"ministry_environment":16581122687.170475,"ministry_sports":666822365.6782843,"minsitry_lga":244386854.59232047},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","admin_sector":9526582979.643154,"governors_office":5461630867.5428095,"secretary_to_state_gov":448275763.0208758,"state_assembly":7469706.896781262,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":225954149.79624885,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.20805601420093148,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.1664692319629888,"civil_service_commission":0.00427994594043936,"lga_service_commission":0.02174036648008937,"state_inec":0.007435460208408471,"economic_sector":0.0005385288588989777,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.005421865931796392,"ministry_finance":0.0010400489737566534,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00042573937768135723,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0004449878318514202,"ministry_science_tech":0.00014669754394696152,"ministry_transport":0.00011314109107374497,"ministry_energy":0.6543222783064693,"ministry_works":0.010512180191021864,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.17837957223995105,"state_planning_commission":0.0018376792628400384,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.00004553322100013517,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0015060211379449998,"ministry_land_survey":0.00012501807355806753,"law_justuce_sector":0.4048534949089237,"judiciary":0.0047134408535286975,"ministry_justice":0.010878974678461835,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.010718129790525728,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.01892517322787575,"social_sector":0.011827060720837642,"ministry_youth_development":0.03537887640191055,"ministry_women_affairs":0.01853619550945806,"ministry_education":0.016842680892452493,"ministry_health":0.0002377921887834786,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0.0002377921887834786,"minsitry_lga":0.10200503890190499},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.004102209641347332,"governors_office":0.0015034380409652383,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.05860637339066418,"state_assembly":0.03359928514024037,"ministry_of_info":0.0027577376700255673,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.000045952723284627296,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0013900422953776713,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.19516700783467475,"lga_service_commission":0.1561565140211528,"state_inec":0.004014804600087226,"economic_sector":0.020393557434252273,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.006974835725476333,"ministry_finance":0.0005051671610051668,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.005085982997672581,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0009756182583291142,"ministry_science_tech":0.00039936495360918525,"ministry_transport":0.000417420971937913,"ministry_energy":0.0001376096760229871,"ministry_works":0.00010613203512919347,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.6137872135400602,"state_planning_commission":0.009860953847358148,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.16732901236528924,"ministry_water_resources":0.0017238355952640151,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.00004271245190292399,"law_justuce_sector":0.001412723589641763,"judiciary":0.000117273242185729,"ministry_justice":0.37977294487857016,"regional_sector":0.004421444636060863,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.010205025528625565,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.010054144932241186,"ministry_youth_development":0.017752764541909917,"ministry_women_affairs":0.011094377931010849,"ministry_education":0.03318716584297015,"ministry_health":0.01738788387403063,"ministry_environment":0.01579928196893952,"ministry_sports":0.00022306103550801296,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.00022306103550801296,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.09568585797917906,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0038480790102953365,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0014103005147288697,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.054975726506282456},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.03151781971499194,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.0025868966658760873,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.00004310596614935702,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0013039296008550022},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":33819920411.84253,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":106361392440.44595,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":5750906979.393974,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":38653594.94702401},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":16581122687.170475,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.20805601420093148,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.6543222783064693,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.03537887640191055,"health_total_expenditure":0.0002377921887834786,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.10200503890190499,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.19516700783467475},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.6137872135400602,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.03318716584297015,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.00022306103550801296,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.09568585797917906,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"anambra","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.9388337970566522,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.9818334994542829,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.1231126714020851,"federation_revenue_performance":1.2251489941882832,"igr_performance":0.7968652199205659,"aids_grant_performance":1.2580232198062276,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.01619395164519234,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.7085383063825493,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.222706608060215,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.9056633697805297,"total_expenditure_performance":0.9388337970566522},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.6865910677862312,"satutory_allocation":0.5705309861485307,"derivation":0.24257074873718704,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.23613638747879112,"igr":0.09182384993255258,"tax_revenue":0.11606008163770058,"personal_taxes":0.06644648806727069,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.04454108607044624,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.04454108607044624,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.02190540199682445,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.02190540199682445,"licances_general":0.04961359357042988,"fees_general":0.00020354698797716227,"fines_general":0.022677009092181864,"sales_general":0.00007456475260278807,"earnings_general":0.0028595675319916187,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.01663851658437406,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0027326865991515797,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.0007338079416409605,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.0036938940805098497,"domestic_aids":0.31081617110551185,"foreign_aids":0.015156483010160987,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.23729385025895416,"capital_development_fund":0.05836583783639671,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.002592761108256832,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.002592761108256832,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.6922828538120963,"derivation":0.5752606432131844,"vat":0.2445816411922806,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.23809393958441874,"tax_revenue":0.09258506243648507,"personal_taxes":0.11702221059891203,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.06699732423452309,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.04491032817563418,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.04491032817563418,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.02208699605888892,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.02208699605888892,"fees_general":0.050024886364388926,"fines_general":0.00020523437652055073,"sales_general":0.022864999716463455,"earnings_general":0.00007518288854541699,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0028832731222363127,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.016776448580039856,"repayments":0.0027553403564284837,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0007398911518425841,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.00372451617231227,"foreign_aids":0.31339281275192205,"domestic_grants":0.01528212906389811,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.23926099764012015,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.0588496860479038,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.0026142548942042158,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.0026142548942042158,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.14552332753181166,"ovetimes_payments":0.09512036372847639,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.09512036372847639,"allowances":0.09512036372847639,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.05040296380333526,"gratuity_arrears":0.017988421129435894,"pension_arrears":0.031004105101263443,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.0014104375726359199,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.29127925385970405,"materials_supplies_general":0.21206200246096263,"maintainance_services_general":0.010433638071540638,"training_general":0.00016012900082650134,"other_servies_general":0.0017276473589596007,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.005162383561495576,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0008372572520730016,"financial_general":0.046056045110390895,"miscellaneous_general":0.003425823026053411,"loans_advances":0.0035651198504348344,"staff_loans_advances":8.976340670814687e-7,"grants_contribution_general":0.1406930615951211,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.07921725139874145,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.036706065374405454,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.036706065374405454,"domestic_debt_principal":0.0016122469212164446,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.0016122469212164446,"transfers_payment":0.04089893910311955,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.04089893910311955,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.5549756549254421,"preservation_of_environment":0.034269449244417924,"other_capital_projects":0.421610640872085},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.047731151001913615,"personal_cost":0.0011373556977731763,"salaries_wages":0.0502270581092524,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.1467297044873896,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.09590890407286304,"allowances":0.09590890407286304,"social_contribution":0.09590890407286304,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.05082080041452655,"pension_arrears":0.01813754372775635,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.031261126697435394,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.001422129989334798,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.2936939359966107,"maintainance_services_general":0.21381997980563744,"training_general":0.010520132111677231,"other_servies_general":0.0001614564576665367,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0017419694198728816,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.005205179315757594,"financial_general":0.0008441980489330141,"miscellaneous_general":0.046437846107032395,"loans_advances":0.0034542228298691646,"staff_loans_advances":0.0035946744139840896,"grants_contribution_general":9.05075382995799e-7,"grants_to_other_states":0.14185939602546152,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.07987395619097329,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.03701035577339966,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.03701035577339966,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0016256123215645903,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.0016256123215645903,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.041237988096009044,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.041237988096009044,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.5595763595159997,"other_capital_projects":0.0345535402870707},"expenditure":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.42510575997086547,"recurrent_expenditure":0.04812683849483005,"capital_expenditure":0.001146784287177778,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.05064343647605569,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":130871817116.42,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":57639042131.17,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":73232774985.25},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.4404236404840003,"governors_office":0.5595763595159997,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.43680258139151573,"state_assembly":0.5549756549254421,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":32760272044.44422,"office_head_of_service":8380148491.515055,"office_auditor_general_state":14897431701.987381,"office_auditor_general_lga":4076387370.2403316,"civil_service_commission":1342043259.863694,"lga_service_commission":3542786644.578339,"state_inec":81621385.57702774,"economic_sector":154739248.04467148,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":85364505.96309517,"ministry_finance":46766990.436026454,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":43738744.06550559,"ministry_labour_productivity":109243702.17309517,"ministry_science_tech":70894119649.96353,"ministry_transport":746691576.7085594,"ministry_energy":20755550698.60113,"ministry_works":1372483304.2234983,"ministry_culture_tourism":60422280.521577775,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":2830053121.534444,"ministry_housing_urban_development":40461760526.37829,"ministry_land_survey":93762989.2727237,"law_justuce_sector":2579820976.578616,"judiciary":11059923.00170613,"ministry_justice":271273303.2302008,"regional_sector":1574201532.2843397,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":137039417.6284482,"state_capital_dev_agency":2253179223.1556163,"social_sector":1433116487.3529031,"ministry_youth_development":820062735.8027132,"ministry_women_affairs":41577864.08668782,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":41577864.08668782,"ministry_environment":24922668334.769947,"ministry_sports":1977533810.6727157,"minsitry_lga":133732966.87141107},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","admin_sector":15029789035.293348,"governors_office":7275521132.66083,"secretary_to_state_gov":431630405.1871098,"state_assembly":23361149.73936012,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":51099834.34517072,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.25032335277580486,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.06403325541098205,"civil_service_commission":0.11383223699518921,"lga_service_commission":0.031147938953228475,"state_inec":0.01025463915328576,"economic_sector":0.027070661374150345,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0006236742743811648,"ministry_finance":0.0011823725799346063,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0006522756988019601,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0003573495918867224,"ministry_science_tech":0.00033421056595093194,"ministry_transport":0.0008347381780136433,"ministry_energy":0.5417065431810888,"ministry_works":0.00570551852309289,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.15859450228415153,"state_planning_commission":0.010487233496594417,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.00046169054463290416,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.021624618530488544,"law_justuce_sector":0.30917092325832546,"judiciary":0.0007164490517413287,"ministry_justice":0.019712578562913037,"regional_sector":0.00008450958537442424,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0020728168157769485,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.012028575494477722,"social_sector":0.0010471270335196895,"ministry_youth_development":0.017216687846178903,"ministry_women_affairs":0.010950535561663683,"ministry_education":0.006266152284515219,"ministry_health":0.00031769914258698867,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0.00031769914258698867,"minsitry_lga":0.19043571705434045},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.015110463461461344,"governors_office":0.001021862229913457,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.1148435879202568,"state_assembly":0.05559272647822047,"ministry_of_info":0.003298115779986024,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0001785040526989755,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.00039045713180335613,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.2482652533249354,"lga_service_commission":0.06350678911713707,"state_inec":0.1128963352431027,"economic_sector":0.030891847959941206,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.010170327933512573,"ministry_finance":0.026848092793588425,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0006185465718820099,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.001172651391997075,"ministry_science_tech":0.0006469128421502192,"ministry_transport":0.00035441154798999816,"ministry_energy":0.00033146276565730755,"ministry_works":0.0008278751579768019,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.5372527599974962,"state_planning_commission":0.0056586090981068,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.15729057576494154,"ministry_water_resources":0.010401009941096533,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.00045789463408023735,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0,"judiciary":0.021446826027194933,"ministry_justice":0.3066289929896275,"regional_sector":0.0007105585769469719,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.019550506400385362,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.00008381476753452383,"social_sector":0.0020557746057593943,"ministry_youth_development":0.011929679389318494,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0010385178025039655,"ministry_education":0.017075136307302913,"ministry_health":0.010860502846072935,"ministry_environment":0.00621463346122998,"ministry_sports":0.0003150870953143333,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.0003150870953143333,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.18886999959190898,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.014986228801739965,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.001013460720142482,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.11389937107986377},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.05513565621862054,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.0032709994514436664,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.00017703643456121922,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.00038724688553731047},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":32760272044.44422,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":70894119649.96353,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":2253179223.1556163,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":41577864.08668782},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":24922668334.769947,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.25032335277580486,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5417065431810888,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.017216687846178903,"health_total_expenditure":0.00031769914258698867,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.19043571705434045,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.2482652533249354},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.5372527599974962,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.017075136307302913,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.0003150870953143333,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.18886999959190898,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"ebonyi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.9188387931211583,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.250345628343503,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.4922354536645377,"federation_revenue_performance":1.5240532628721382,"igr_performance":1.3656100934988156,"aids_grant_performance":0.9351816557593075,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.9661723654098837,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.3952297288374411,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.680841273972922,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.8928043461493568,"total_expenditure_performance":0.9188387931211583},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.6545107536812068,"satutory_allocation":0.5342281272274116,"derivation":0.14589882661943576,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.15185966304776616,"igr":0.23646963756020972,"tax_revenue":0.12028262645379517,"personal_taxes":0.07338937599363743,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.04557685833240316,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.04557685833240316,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.02781251766123427,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0.0026100576393651167,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.025202460021869152,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.04689325046015776,"fees_general":0.0005679412507835124,"fines_general":0.016352156310154492,"sales_general":0.00006490367015142625,"earnings_general":0.00040678432388570893,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.006936821059990232,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.000051903964795669924,"repayments":0.00015269235890646123,"investment_income":0.00010610491692580437,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0006337657627578443,"miscellaneous_income":0.01696236528284647,"aids_grants":0.004657811558960139,"domestic_aids":0.10444714119771337,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.10444714119771337,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.2410421051210798,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.1136929039932619,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.026902022548801773,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.07823781686774146,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.022209361711274633,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.8370207408163903,"derivation":0.6831973658214936,"vat":0.18658263940568268,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.1942056520071786,"tax_revenue":0.30240907440863224,"personal_taxes":0.15382337499489676,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.09385396575495689,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.058285941844208294,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.058285941844208294,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.03556802391074859,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.003337870870092624,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.03223015304065597,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.059969409239939875,"fines_general":0.0007263113765469864,"sales_general":0.020911946689477174,"earnings_general":0.00008300202520172787,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0005202159234455479,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.008871150045873537,"repayments":0.00006637735869155807,"investment_income":0.0001952705446779248,"interest_earned":0.00013569221845475754,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0.0008104910198404693,"aids_grants":0.02169231212045407,"domestic_aids":0.00595663991727613,"foreign_aids":0.13357217281726444,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.13357217281726444,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.3082565721978321,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.14539611181447157,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.03440363770436221,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.10005439187388919,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0.028402430805109073,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.19649371713101138,"ovetimes_payments":0.15600901135639178,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.15600901135639178,"allowances":0.11071715835952761,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.045291852996864154,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.003956441041583623,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.0034270107848579047,"housing_fund_contribution":0.0005294302567257183,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.03652826473303596,"gratuity_arrears":0.011481240435703293,"pension_arrears":0.025041286223448273,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.000005738073884397316,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.15611301529279478,"materials_supplies_general":0.09177227684081814,"maintainance_services_general":0.006468181339668698,"training_general":0.009191313903653653,"other_servies_general":0.004145852281323627,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.002828437351568963,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0009075298046027498,"financial_general":0.020455649427018906,"miscellaneous_general":0.007365118070795138,"loans_advances":0.005204877279699285,"staff_loans_advances":0.002161281646561649,"grants_contribution_general":0.03304403573592544,"grants_to_other_states":0.0006286315707216448,"grants_to_lga":0.0006286315707216448,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.0012762754415871452,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0.0012762754415871452,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.062435831439667855,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.008049643196108913,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.008049643196108913,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.054386188243558946,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.054386188243558946,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.42934611744563456,"preservation_of_environment":0.03366484759014841,"other_capital_projects":0.23576472447611618},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.011102476640261082,"personal_cost":0.01428059610171138,"salaries_wages":0.13453347263739748,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.2512858891221115,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.1995120439582002,"allowances":0.1995120439582002,"social_contribution":0.14159058104080519,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.057921462917395014,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.005059692591751808,"housing_fund_contribution":0.004382630980154492,"social_benefit":0.0006770616115973169,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.046714152572159474,"pension_arrears":0.014682778427906832,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.032024036011415916,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.00000733813283672459,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.19964504933879365,"maintainance_services_general":0.11736292905146513,"training_general":0.008271830380500132,"other_servies_general":0.01175430705980327,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.005301921058304017,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.00361714565276054,"financial_general":0.0011605940239929763,"miscellaneous_general":0.026159696752092277,"loans_advances":0.009418877457924555,"staff_loans_advances":0.006656254632959418,"grants_contribution_general":0.002763953922442394,"grants_to_other_states":0.042258348110685524,"grants_to_lga":0.0008039251609948154,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.0008039251609948154,"grants_to_private_companies":0.0016321641922530743,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.0016321641922530743,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.07984603093408062,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.010294282062470808,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.010294282062470808,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.06955174887160981,"capital_expenditure":0.06955174887160981,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.549069061539095,"other_capital_projects":0.04305227303125666},"expenditure":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.3015075966734833,"recurrent_expenditure":0.014198396542853977,"capital_expenditure":0.018262732982040734,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.17204806230946015,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":146495889372.5,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":57694667490.35997,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":88801221882.14001},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.3938313063765073,"governors_office":0.6061686936234926,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.2789486558775037,"state_assembly":0.42934611744563456,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":21344650844.88,"office_head_of_service":11965805270.33,"office_auditor_general_state":4061936740.42,"office_auditor_general_lga":1721743570.6999998,"civil_service_commission":334778941.4,"lga_service_commission":440138295.14,"state_inec":1926514439.5100002,"economic_sector":534747673.90999997,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":109313439.53999999,"ministry_finance":115666671.36,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":39536414.76,"ministry_labour_productivity":94469387.81,"ministry_science_tech":76655212595.90997,"ministry_transport":9212416239.38,"ministry_energy":27091664297.629967,"ministry_works":4182544786.98,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":67968718.9,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":37016530.19,"ministry_housing_urban_development":15200374960.05,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":854043866.29,"judiciary":5020988.93,"ministry_justice":12484116327.75,"regional_sector":5328797072.2699995,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":2191248807.54,"state_capital_dev_agency":4627949406.620001,"social_sector":3573424718.92,"ministry_youth_development":1054524687.7,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":43868076525.09001,"ministry_sports":6224044429.360001,"minsitry_lga":150085915.93},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","admin_sector":21522522473.260002,"governors_office":11751322560.170002,"secretary_to_state_gov":3868050169.37,"state_assembly":274658697.14,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":77392279.86,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.13197664581499427,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.07398607058650214,"civil_service_commission":0.025115462904932634,"lga_service_commission":0.010645755841399658,"state_inec":0.002069980066507615,"economic_sector":0.0027214301283003143,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.011911879734573982,"ministry_finance":0.0033064117503210856,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0006758986688437666,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0007151814958050621,"ministry_science_tech":0.0002444585974020212,"ministry_transport":0.0005841160404059916,"ministry_energy":0.47396876698361257,"ministry_works":0.05696152183330741,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.16751114878998793,"state_planning_commission":0.025861197541632283,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.00042025909001532975,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.0002288778359360011,"law_justuce_sector":0.09398581953561605,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.005280660043163021,"regional_sector":0.000031045402544711545,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.07719085268128739,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.032948618786877604,"social_sector":0.013548765443244756,"ministry_youth_development":0.0286151900129915,"ministry_women_affairs":0.02209493197629777,"ministry_education":0.006520258036693726,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.27124180386982655},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.038484045167104304,"governors_office":0.0009279999899021059,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.13307644834021923,"state_assembly":0.07265989716357092,"ministry_of_info":0.023916637986140975,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.001698249076824257,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0004785261460647499,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.10319951431124456,"lga_service_commission":0.057853618745756945,"state_inec":0.019639107794302293,"economic_sector":0.008324479119196709,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0016186268121785637,"ministry_finance":0.0021280300445449883,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.009314528305752162,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0025854580910053783,"ministry_science_tech":0.0005285208903253446,"ministry_transport":0.0005592382088186578,"ministry_energy":0.0001911550969135967,"ministry_works":0.0004567512024499184,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.3706212280919407,"state_planning_commission":0.0445412243304551,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.13098582018123497,"ministry_water_resources":0.020222237118715937,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.0003286227931210249,"law_justuce_sector":0,"judiciary":0.00017897167608210636,"ministry_justice":0.07349247943318993,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0041292271699430085,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.00002427604099518118,"social_sector":0.060359607237984836,"ministry_youth_development":0.025764266359660736,"ministry_women_affairs":0.010594495750557832,"ministry_education":0.02237572938021426,"ministry_health":0.017277195026537472,"ministry_environment":0.005098534353676783,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.21209830153973877,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.030092708792921485,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0007256522367827639,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.10405950803013782},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.05681661365827477,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.018701683232558657,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0013279507054108745,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0003741848836523714},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":21344650844.88,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":76655212595.90997,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":4627949406.620001,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":43868076525.09001,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.13197664581499427,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.47396876698361257,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.0286151900129915,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.27124180386982655,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.10319951431124456},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.3706212280919407,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.02237572938021426,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.21209830153973877,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"gombe","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.8481336141012726,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.9453726036637305,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.1861857237576123,"federation_revenue_performance":1.3584534924796912,"igr_performance":0.6425766087111554,"aids_grant_performance":0.5135519851642634,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.736365962783309,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.8505216561007872,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.3013479938373589,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.6326044912277522,"total_expenditure_performance":0.8481336141012726},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7390458965045981,"satutory_allocation":0.6427053026602341,"derivation":0.4688620750139089,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.1738432276463252,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.09634059384436398,"personal_taxes":0.07258001254643949,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.06439044227416463,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.06439044227416463,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.008189570272274856,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.0001342857173351255,"other_taxes_nec":0.008055284554939729,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.02376058129792449,"fees_general":0.0006890646994948907,"fines_general":0.009891993131772189,"sales_general":0.00020306612071493968,"earnings_general":0.001940014910054585,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.001910435402317635,"rent_on_land_others_general":0,"repayments":0.00046023698720040453,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0.008665770046369847,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.13638611435125866,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0.1307787613150758,"foreign_grants":0.005607353036182867,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.12456798914414324,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.07936971664391462,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.04519827250022863,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.8192272773874073,"derivation":0.712434393792101,"vat":0.5197303753400452,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.19270401845205587,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.10679288359530628,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.08045444315756857,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.07137636101292759,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.07137636101292759,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.009078082144640981,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.00014885479119061096,"non_tax_revenue":0.00892922735345037,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.026338440437737715,"fines_general":0.0007638234653366473,"sales_general":0.010965206138894033,"earnings_general":0.0002250973938015602,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0021504931430806006,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0021177044628316326,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0.0005101695250057107,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.009605946308787531,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.1511830667917579,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.14496735463787336,"capital_development_fund":0.0062157121538845075,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.13808275653627916,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.08798078330551913,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.05010197323076003,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.16195278651395933,"ovetimes_payments":0.08510610371523443,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.08510610371523443,"allowances":0.08510610371523443,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.013427701332299705,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.06341898146642519,"gratuity_arrears":0.03356342976538554,"pension_arrears":0.029855551701039644,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.3653632552804304,"materials_supplies_general":0.17622226383605477,"maintainance_services_general":0.015191924427082244,"training_general":0.004526391815482005,"other_servies_general":0.012680272008608896,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.004925658543275127,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.006186647181681267,"financial_general":0.0354275270519915,"miscellaneous_general":0.008144570854094318,"loans_advances":0.016837243481754534,"staff_loans_advances":0.0024041244038859187,"grants_contribution_general":0.06989790406819894,"grants_to_other_states":0.000015878153129330318,"grants_to_lga":0.000015878153129330318,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.12196426137219431,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.07590281495780894,"subsidies_general":0.03748314211691242,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.0009039654500045725,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0.007674338847468377,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.06716085191905201,"domestic_debt_interest":0.0027010464685414196,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0027010464685414196,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.06445980545051058,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.06445980545051058,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.3748095549771006,"preservation_of_environment":0.07775630961710923,"other_capital_projects":0.19654725083585012},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.018316738345907354,"personal_cost":1.807930900009145e-7,"salaries_wages":0.08218907538514392,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.17952354649236518,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.09433952879711043,"allowances":0.09433952879711043,"social_contribution":0.09433952879711043,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.014884514285321802,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.07029950340993295,"pension_arrears":0.03720483033127726,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.0330946730786557,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.40500264773329275,"maintainance_services_general":0.19534116365472345,"training_general":0.016840143414011098,"other_servies_general":0.005017474098596657,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.014055994036738132,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.005460058511700564,"financial_general":0.006857855717454333,"miscellaneous_general":0.03927116931254235,"loans_advances":0.009028200600051646,"staff_loans_advances":0.01866396823459099,"grants_contribution_general":0.002664955314969171,"grants_to_other_states":0.07748134441406852,"grants_to_lga":0.000017600823195965998,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.000017600823195965998,"grants_to_private_companies":0.13519654226493258,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.08413774670561223,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.04154980442973392,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0.0010020394646152006,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0.00850695166497121,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.07444734099044076,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0029940913750899794,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.0029940913750899794,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.07145324961535078,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.07145324961535078,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.41547380577434206,"other_capital_projects":0.08619233274765954},"expenditure":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.2178712715161277,"recurrent_expenditure":0.020303978084048324,"capital_expenditure":2.004078929230401e-7,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.09110602301861359,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":199592937267,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":116667300015,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":82925637252},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.5845261942256579,"governors_office":0.41547380577434206,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.5273160417943897,"state_assembly":0.3748095549771006,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":29343437326.742527,"office_head_of_service":20270499885.114567,"office_auditor_general_state":4411519118.727264,"office_auditor_general_lga":995507443.8608656,"civil_service_commission":747033038.3691525,"lga_service_commission":900301123.6472007,"state_inec":800800819.9395683,"economic_sector":207190955.1142018,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":351905804.6939851,"ministry_finance":49531572.05819824,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":565259947.1770793,"ministry_labour_productivity":43887618.04044593,"ministry_science_tech":87003792791.1847,"ministry_transport":2374331554.7189617,"ministry_energy":55132692907.47248,"ministry_works":1940210768.8416226,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":1630753034.51332,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":933171897.1739635,"ministry_water_resources":483511051,"ministry_housing_urban_development":18933608833.779213,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":175412191.66985038,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":4615806694.023809,"regional_sector":567342522.3764307,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":216951335.6150393,"state_capital_dev_agency":3183303577.19708,"social_sector":2519797605.5273294,"ministry_youth_development":663505971.6697507,"ministry_women_affairs":9087633476,"ministry_education":9087633476,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":70974770095.87569,"ministry_sports":2263646999.497468,"minsitry_lga":8182373273.712044},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","admin_sector":51381385480.87132,"governors_office":5539025458.3504925,"secretary_to_state_gov":904122699.0600657,"state_assembly":242320201.8176398,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":2461895982.566651,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.14701641114429387,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.10155920426181343,"civil_service_commission":0.02210258127934595,"lga_service_commission":0.004987688730333943,"state_inec":0.003742782929086461,"economic_sector":0.004510686279659523,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.004012170124378293,"ministry_finance":0.0010380675686787343,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0017631175206527109,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00024816294973373096,"ministry_science_tech":0.0028320638741886855,"ministry_transport":0.0002198856264224243,"ministry_energy":0.4359061697398528,"ministry_works":0.011895869599547826,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.27622567041899,"state_planning_commission":0.00972083880025353,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.008170394488116704,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.004675375341190747,"ministry_land_survey":0.0024224857733978647,"law_justuce_sector":0.09486111629516877,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.0008788496931391791,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.023126102342234386,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0028424979868775808,"social_sector":0.0010869690009362334,"ministry_youth_development":0.015948979061011077,"ministry_women_affairs":0.012624683217906349,"ministry_education":0.003324295843104727,"ministry_health":0.04553083691455107,"ministry_environment":0.04553083691455107,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.3555976031402911},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.01134131813727124,"governors_office":0.04099530467236071,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.2574308799921977,"state_assembly":0.02775161052387747,"ministry_of_info":0.004529833126562992,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0012140720264739756,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.012334584661547,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.1326272676387489,"lga_service_commission":0.09161915775232612,"state_inec":0.019939304326820333,"economic_sector":0.004499521672362945,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0033764602834882706,"ministry_finance":0.00406920555188682,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0036194813678035124,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0009364673248834332,"ministry_science_tech":0.0015905534454970973,"ministry_transport":0.00022387414912511543,"ministry_energy":0.002554877312597447,"ministry_works":0.0001983644519578025,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.39324211351293925,"state_planning_commission":0.010731568461607912,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.24919024777033633,"ministry_water_resources":0.008769417503798175,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.0073707220034507775,"law_justuce_sector":0.004217775769802413,"judiciary":0.0021853864239969943,"ministry_justice":0.08557664114818887,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0007928328038956232,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.020862648876486756,"ministry_youth_development":0.0025642901927336974,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0009805825586417102,"ministry_education":0.01438798225331062,"ministry_health":0.011389049882004783,"ministry_environment":0.0029989323713058365,"ministry_sports":0.04107453342304479,"minsitry_lga":0.04107453342304479},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.3207936999434467,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.010231293392761145,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.03698291369238248,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.23223498624037128},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.025035438205222933,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.004086478412575905,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.001095245451406408,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.01112734454872656},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":29343437326.742527,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":87003792791.1847,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":3183303577.19708,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":9087633476},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":70974770095.87569,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.14701641114429387,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.4359061697398528,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.015948979061011077,"health_total_expenditure":0.04553083691455107,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.3555976031402911,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.1326272676387489},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.39324211351293925,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.01438798225331062,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.04107453342304479,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.3207936999434467,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"borno","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.3417821047623426,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.4239410486997601,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.1305182727521907,"federation_revenue_performance":1.2910422362647158,"igr_performance":0.9386760442891556,"aids_grant_performance":4.2240539242918915,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":3.690725434046709,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.9963655645282733,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.8514373129256854,"capital_expenditure_performance":1.5238876667544303,"total_expenditure_performance":1.3417821047623426},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7040673629520984,"satutory_allocation":0.4377509070932726,"derivation":0.22176742132730792,"vat":0.17725392059484882,"other_federation_transfers":0.12607235236965145,"igr":0.08991113339631328,"tax_revenue":0.26631645585882574,"personal_taxes":0.2431501517955749,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.009261772356364524,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.009261772356364524,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.23388837943921037,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.22802523267412134,"non_tax_revenue":0.0058631467650890265,"licances_general":0.02316630406325083,"fees_general":0.000022678624134498487,"fines_general":0.0015024880941244757,"sales_general":0.0010016587294592934,"earnings_general":0.0008336732436301075,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0012670902733037206,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00006528806671554028,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.014587245702244504,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.0038861813296386907,"domestic_aids":0.020150324372348823,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.020150324372348823,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.27578231267555287,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.27578231267555287,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.7471782606124876,"derivation":0.46455492550042127,"vat":0.2353465092219139,"other_federation_transfers":0.18810739290838824,"igr":0.13379191525071393,"tax_revenue":0.09541650102779344,"personal_taxes":0.2826233351120664,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.25803853018342576,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.009828881899029434,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.009828881899029434,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.2482096482843963,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.24198749393926866,"licances_general":0.006222154345127632,"fees_general":0.024584804928640635,"fines_general":0.000024067263766992455,"sales_general":0.0015944872604970839,"earnings_general":0.001062991507043664,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0008847200663909965,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0013446757459065573,"repayments":0.00006928573414158999,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.015480440430060914,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.004124136920832836,"foreign_aids":0.02138415314719445,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.02138415314719445,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.29266879781022903,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.29266879781022903,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.16534291183838007,"ovetimes_payments":0.11276429624121817,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.11276429624121817,"allowances":0.1121294805984175,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.0006348156428006756,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.052578615597161885,"gratuity_arrears":0.010802323101783674,"pension_arrears":0.037107126704951435,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.004669165790426778,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.051087749156484355,"materials_supplies_general":0.02333722957919871,"maintainance_services_general":0.01985975351589108,"training_general":0.00013401354169668238,"other_servies_general":0,"consulting_professional_services_general":0,"fuel_lubricant_general":0,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0.0033434625216109464,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.02775051957728564,"domestic_debt_interest":0.00037722871962184395,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.00037722871962184395,"foreign_debt_principal":0.005979316678998695,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.005979316678998695,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.021393974178665107,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.021393974178665107,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.725871062793178,"preservation_of_environment":0,"other_capital_projects":0.725871062793178},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.17546705865474108,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.11966899072189634,"allowances":0.11966899072189634,"social_contribution":0.11899530454816344,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.0006736861737328928,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.05579806793284473,"pension_arrears":0.01146376243307553,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.03937924103097381,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.004955064468795391,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.054215913933715595,"maintainance_services_general":0.024766196421018214,"training_general":0.021075790285148895,"other_servies_general":0.00014221935322154505,"consulting_professional_services_general":0,"fuel_lubricant_general":0,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0,"loans_advances":0.0035481867826477743,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.029449717512697378,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0004003268911632557,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.0004003268911632557,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.006345437483613962,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.006345437483613962,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.022703953137920164,"capital_expenditure":0.022703953137920164,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.7703170274115433,"other_capital_projects":0},"expenditure":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.7703170274115433,"recurrent_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":730868293558.33,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":167868002235.13,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":563000291323.2},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.22968297258845669,"governors_office":0.7703170274115433,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.21643066099486444,"state_assembly":0.725871062793178,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":222696686526.57,"office_head_of_service":166185282477.34656,"office_auditor_general_state":18979232268.4759,"office_auditor_general_lga":6239290062.15,"civil_service_commission":2214606223.9575367,"lga_service_commission":23283190230.31,"state_inec":4520473119.469999,"economic_sector":364474883.5,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":165532383.8,"ministry_finance":596162110.26,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":20940136.6,"ministry_labour_productivity":127502630.7,"ministry_science_tech":390861342277.6298,"ministry_transport":3051126423.6,"ministry_energy":52217253975.99,"ministry_works":185437988.78,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":113004253.25,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":718543756.28,"ministry_water_resources":5500845443.700001,"ministry_housing_urban_development":312530694507.11005,"ministry_land_survey":411356237.8,"law_justuce_sector":652060878.02,"judiciary":31801636.12,"ministry_justice":1375039620.1798096,"regional_sector":1140751043.7,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":12933426513.1,"state_capital_dev_agency":11102764901.86,"social_sector":6080925306.110472,"ministry_youth_development":5021839595.749529,"ministry_women_affairs":23009458430.3,"ministry_education":8393400111.75,"ministry_health":14616058318.55,"ministry_environment":83198041421.97,"ministry_sports":90561620.21,"minsitry_lga":212618561.48000002},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","admin_sector":43483382331.32,"governors_office":32373398791.760002,"secretary_to_state_gov":4785465568.8,"state_assembly":2094560666.9,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":158053881.5,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.3047015289749969,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.22738061555283962,"civil_service_commission":0.025968060778875725,"lga_service_commission":0.008536818626750358,"state_inec":0.003030103020580398,"economic_sector":0.03185688917623267,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0061850721385948645,"ministry_finance":0.0004986875018555058,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00022648729635552184,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.000815690207817752,"ministry_science_tech":0.000028651039844744322,"ministry_transport":0.0001744536352497061,"ministry_energy":0.5347903934574438,"ministry_works":0.00417465971706774,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.0714455045269009,"state_planning_commission":0.00025372285323415846,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.00015461643944057786,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0009831371296484537,"ministry_land_survey":0.007526452429504637,"law_justuce_sector":0.4276156145528117,"judiciary":0.0005628322386202543,"ministry_justice":0.0008921728904743623,"regional_sector":0.00004351212988754716,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0018813781255788856,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.001560816160386574,"social_sector":0.017695974263888074,"ministry_youth_development":0.015191197921317267,"ministry_women_affairs":0.00832013833368619,"ministry_education":0.006871059587631079,"ministry_health":0.03148235958940752,"ministry_environment":0.01148414862941394,"ministry_sports":0.01999821095999358,"minsitry_lga":0.11383452005683434},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.00012390963051508042,"governors_office":0.00029091227975541,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.05949551063381795,"state_assembly":0.044294435915595384,"ministry_of_info":0.0065476442349158715,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.002865852418774868,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.00021625494345977654,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.2871207759939917,"lga_service_commission":0.21426114599142695,"state_inec":0.024469748435367252,"economic_sector":0.008044258907652731,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0028552712995482633,"ministry_finance":0.030018801585288673,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.005828204137951335,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0004699140926299957,"ministry_science_tech":0.00021341936977190145,"ministry_transport":0.0007686262889036944,"ministry_energy":0.000026997924234022464,"ministry_works":0.00016438796121688844,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.5039339096202348,"state_planning_commission":0.003933789047621433,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.0673232220726051,"ministry_water_resources":0.00023908348196696803,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.000145695337410826,"law_justuce_sector":0.0009264118119877661,"judiciary":0.007092189098330919,"ministry_justice":0.4029429307117976,"regional_sector":0.0005303577886553485,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.000840696052610952,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.00004100155499872489,"social_sector":0.0017728258508301002,"ministry_youth_development":0.0014707597584485024,"ministry_women_affairs":0.016674947052970568,"ministry_education":0.014314691987662588,"ministry_health":0.007840080693987467,"ministry_environment":0.0064746112936751215,"ministry_sports":0.029665881710013713,"minsitry_lga":0.01082153304973484},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.018844348660278874,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.1072664644761395,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0001167602584282997,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0002741271426846321,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.05606272222789647},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.04173872331748451,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.006169856449312065,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0027004976743336888,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.00020377740599983307},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":222696686526.57,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":390861342277.6298,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":11102764901.86,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":23009458430.3},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":83198041421.97,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.3047015289749969,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5347903934574438,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.015191197921317267,"health_total_expenditure":0.03148235958940752,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.11383452005683434,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.2871207759939917},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.5039339096202348,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.014314691987662588,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.029665881710013713,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.1072664644761395,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"rivers","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.7919357469235269,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.1408918636828487,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.2427224322971957,"federation_revenue_performance":1.1896245250113118,"igr_performance":1.5157251357548756,"aids_grant_performance":0.5444260908108373,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":1.1055325499691278,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.002615074213588,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.7504715801122785,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.33127502382327917,"total_expenditure_performance":0.7919357469235269},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.6949699839192484,"satutory_allocation":0.5569512131451558,"derivation":0.3823867466159764,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.17456446652917942,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.1380187707740926,"personal_taxes":0.09099620770143912,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.08695135955632342,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.08695135955632342,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.004044848145115692,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.004044848145115692,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.04702256307265351,"fees_general":0.0002884855388601583,"fines_general":0.005532617912739213,"sales_general":0.00019134801185126556,"earnings_general":0.00027184509401363086,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0018409249628720693,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.000011720504861437598,"repayments":1.027819118089578e-7,"investment_income":0.030922980548478363,"interest_earned":0.000051347029035618366,"reimbursement":0.007911045091696257,"miscellaneous_income":1.4559633368245462e-7,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.04436886565526022,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.01625117179027075,"capital_development_fund":0.02811769386498947,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.26066115042549143,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.0963370239127766,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.16030925217334216,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0.004014874339372678,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.9518031174367911,"derivation":0.762778124520206,"vat":0.5237016071443575,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.23907651737584854,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.18902499291658517,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.1246247696579931,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.1190851072795286,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.1190851072795286,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.005539662378464499,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.005539662378464499,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.06440022325859208,"fines_general":0.00039509826550211994,"sales_general":0.007577252397628286,"earnings_general":0.0002620625903413529,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.00037230817722932894,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0025212572617128166,"repayments":0.000016051935080905006,"investment_income":1.4076599902082457e-7,"interest_earned":0.04235087840843909,"reimbursement":0.00007032283902623581,"miscellaneous_income":0.01083465121471266,"aids_grants":1.994029202596895e-7,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.06076582532335352,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.022256955451154883,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.038508869872198634,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.3569910950261569,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.13193933811020214,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.21955314546401622,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0.0054986114519384975,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.19181191946071877,"ovetimes_payments":0.1915045277233379,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.1915045277233379,"allowances":0.14763063378123667,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.043873893942101214,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.0003073917373808669,"gratuity_arrears":0.0000980970077123384,"pension_arrears":0.0002092947296685285,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.36545392587252945,"materials_supplies_general":0.23489822603575533,"maintainance_services_general":0.015375309704177829,"training_general":0.004985692871501129,"other_servies_general":0.02108124896387981,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.015730753634143904,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.017728549502974002,"financial_general":0.04020655813594313,"miscellaneous_general":0.031194193774919336,"loans_advances":0.011542999330780328,"staff_loans_advances":0.0005880456085867033,"grants_contribution_general":0.07646487450884913,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.01894831849830116,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.01894831849830116,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.11160738133847291,"domestic_debt_interest":0.028038358223389917,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.028038358223389917,"foreign_debt_principal":0.014106401405214677,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.014106401405214677,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.0694626217098683,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.0694626217098683,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.17289564624791487,"preservation_of_environment":0.03809359308763057,"other_capital_projects":0.09231780092625042},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.03694634484844004,"personal_cost":0.0010440737160174207,"salaries_wages":0.004493833669576433,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.262697939664485,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.26227694822502245,"allowances":0.26227694822502245,"social_contribution":0.20218901637984613,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.06008793184517632,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.0004209914394625369,"pension_arrears":0.00013434974158923327,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.00028664169787330366,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.5005110925271337,"maintainance_services_general":0.32170722332546425,"training_general":0.021057409739429874,"other_servies_general":0.006828205717483981,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.02887203612755366,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.02154421154158512,"financial_general":0.02428031292718939,"miscellaneous_general":0.0550652952799194,"loans_advances":0.042722321205091736,"staff_loans_advances":0.015808830599630758,"grants_contribution_general":0.0008053637659160741,"grants_to_other_states":0.10472323642166421,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.025950859798520208,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.025950859798520208,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.1528530094031491,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.03840021494789175,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.03840021494789175,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.01931956364155455,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.01931956364155455,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.09513323081370281,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.09513323081370281,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.2367909678083813,"other_capital_projects":0.052171462788511314},"expenditure":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.12643477092490377,"recurrent_expenditure":0.05060023744669526,"capital_expenditure":0.0014299216379605028,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.006154575010310454,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":160479094079.09003,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":122479094079.09003,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":38000000000},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.7632090321916187,"governors_office":0.2367909678083813,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.5572658453332483,"state_assembly":0.17289564624791487,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":46184702306.733475,"office_head_of_service":4632619395.840103,"office_auditor_general_state":34037585045.101154,"office_auditor_general_lga":2543371341.947788,"civil_service_commission":1088465553.667781,"lga_service_commission":387840801.11893433,"state_inec":2131042696.0070603,"economic_sector":342312436.31536144,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":172044352.3323651,"ministry_finance":47646477.17812389,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":744812235.8083935,"ministry_labour_productivity":56961971.41641295,"ministry_science_tech":75544492685.63957,"ministry_transport":2347913411.5819755,"ministry_energy":41708898981.03784,"ministry_works":544248802.2615194,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":455301854.17502004,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":17707076.79856598,"ministry_water_resources":68026896.1057556,"ministry_housing_urban_development":22154647877.776287,"ministry_land_survey":313560419.56828105,"law_justuce_sector":205599228.55924943,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":1475661829.8628106,"regional_sector":5934178771.309018,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":318747536.6032606,"state_capital_dev_agency":4688592513.197166,"social_sector":3904034510.234536,"ministry_youth_development":784558002.9626299,"ministry_women_affairs":2413610036.3307443,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":2413610036.3307443,"ministry_environment":31647696537.189064,"ministry_sports":832837825.6674458,"minsitry_lga":336994421.0232353},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","admin_sector":15028705620.84175,"governors_office":14570386368.410662,"secretary_to_state_gov":0,"state_assembly":805909277.2110157,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":72863024.03495869,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.28779264097772106,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.028867432374443596,"civil_service_commission":0.21209980801814707,"lga_service_commission":0.01584861477778732,"state_inec":0.006782600312607355,"economic_sector":0.002416768385592905,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.013279254274434051,"ministry_finance":0.002133065607577877,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0010720670709143914,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00029690145904389233,"ministry_science_tech":0.004641179214541942,"ministry_transport":0.0003549494826306783,"ministry_energy":0.47074351409541515,"ministry_works":0.014630649712073007,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.2599023830511042,"state_planning_commission":0.00339140001621204,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.002837141228817197,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.00011033883821552032,"ministry_land_survey":0.0004238988043653177,"law_justuce_sector":0.13805317137980389,"judiciary":0.001953901979367773,"ministry_justice":0.0012811589555579278,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.009195352443450048,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.03697789301068983,"social_sector":0.0019862246757585134,"ministry_youth_development":0.029216219969975993,"ministry_women_affairs":0.024327371316730413,"ministry_education":0.0048888486532455795,"ministry_health":0.015040027800388928,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0.015040027800388928,"minsitry_lga":0.19720759715649883},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0051896967044005905,"governors_office":0.002099927239476763,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.09364899339122046,"state_assembly":0.09079304972415807,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.005021895729382881,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.00045403436786008465,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.21013510400237495,"lga_service_commission":0.021077887480642096,"state_inec":0.1548671121866086,"economic_sector":0.011572048205644454,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.004952393561052249,"ministry_finance":0.0017646312092307152,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.009696000108106301,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0015574823656695426,"ministry_science_tech":0.0007827820915739006,"ministry_transport":0.00021678601218811205,"ministry_energy":0.0033888103379854356,"ministry_works":0.0002591704436735782,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.3437187864040666,"state_planning_commission":0.01068273701656874,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.18977071167409304,"ministry_water_resources":0.002476269694385764,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.0020715712714595787,"law_justuce_sector":0.00008056517069077697,"judiciary":0.000309514583274852,"ministry_justice":0.10080110953218754,"regional_sector":0.00142666398365856,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0009354529339427417,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.00671409225572398,"ministry_youth_development":0.02699983351621395,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0014502647718671483,"ministry_education":0.021332558751641036,"ministry_health":0.017762909726872684,"ministry_environment":0.003569649024768353,"ministry_sports":0.01098164913215414,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.01098164913215414,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.14399339329092634,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0037893166865389815,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0015332860053882678,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.06837888869960802},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.06629358861179396,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.003666794876331277,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0003315184112658299},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":46184702306.733475,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":75544492685.63957,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":4688592513.197166,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":2413610036.3307443},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":31647696537.189064,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.28779264097772106,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.47074351409541515,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.029216219969975993,"health_total_expenditure":0.015040027800388928,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.19720759715649883,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.21013510400237495},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.3437187864040666,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.021332558751641036,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.01098164913215414,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.14399339329092634,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"bauchi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.9036010606341637,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.9524153501616884,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.1794894954881785,"federation_revenue_performance":1.2222101010402364,"igr_performance":0.9249315438204908,"aids_grant_performance":0.7919156772754491,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.6245427606690545,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.2997485941246432,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.948789415876498,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.6721341105974239,"total_expenditure_performance":0.9036010606341637},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.6543631010799043,"satutory_allocation":0.5806222525255414,"derivation":0.20129551176730318,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.20109745750915123,"igr":0.17822928324908702,"tax_revenue":0.07374084855436286,"personal_taxes":0.049037412161205766,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.049037412161205766,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.049037412161205766,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.02470343639315709,"fees_general":0.00077047682195152,"fines_general":0.007938592725053994,"sales_general":0.0002886598252006905,"earnings_general":0.007444429971441396,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0006371429120421291,"rent_on_land_others_general":0,"repayments":0.0037486790610400337,"investment_income":0.0029819252987813116,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":4.555132783738128e-7,"aids_grants":0.0008930742643676424,"domestic_aids":0.17211883931621946,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.17211883931621946,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.17351805960387615,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.1019498683111198,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0.07156819129275634},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.6827114196437715,"derivation":0.605775970014655,"vat":0.210016036020029,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.20980940165521492,"tax_revenue":0.18595053233941106,"personal_taxes":0.07693544962911646,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.0511618109532516,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.0511618109532516,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.0511618109532516,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.025773638675864855,"fines_general":0.0008038554191840227,"sales_general":0.008282508442714774,"earnings_general":0.00030116514627988165,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.00776693757006446,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0006647452175686364,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0.003911079337034638,"interest_earned":0.0031111082679371243,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":4.75247024827581e-7,"domestic_aids":0.0009317640280564934,"foreign_aids":0.17957537175169283,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.17957537175169283,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.18103520906129048,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.10636654055266022,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.07466866850863024,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.32348455987695635,"ovetimes_payments":0.2747777652928448,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.2747777652928448,"allowances":0.2095895254636784,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.06518823982916645,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.005703051390549202,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.005703051390549202,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.043003743193562295,"gratuity_arrears":0.012688935584201423,"pension_arrears":0.026690837533536252,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.0022601643940832923,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0.0013638056817413251,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.3063289998277282,"materials_supplies_general":0.2044135909285536,"maintainance_services_general":0.024144601354051654,"training_general":0.003751235155198614,"other_servies_general":0.017173846173212916,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.02726740684592068,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.00421048437145689,"financial_general":0.03334569611040863,"miscellaneous_general":0.02120257491255195,"loans_advances":0.023782391334565528,"staff_loans_advances":0.001286564146586249,"grants_contribution_general":0.04824879052460051,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.10191540889917462,"domestic_debt_interest":0.0007187028076489043,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.0007187028076489043,"foreign_debt_principal":0.04364320481304457,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.04364320481304457,"domestic_debt_principal":0.011852978607317134,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.011852978607317134,"transfers_payment":0.04570052267116402,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0.04570052267116402,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.32866330511960834,"preservation_of_environment":0.05377702263107031,"other_capital_projects":0.17101089183130608},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.040378050593302135,"personal_cost":0.0035120003870615737,"salaries_wages":0.0599853396768682,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.337498558127699,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.28668168776636754,"allowances":0.28668168776636754,"social_contribution":0.21866936298154693,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.06801232478482064,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.005950118985495472,"housing_fund_contribution":0.005950118985495472,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.04486675137583597,"pension_arrears":0.01323864565737593,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.02784713800935528,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.0023580792369961097,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0.0014228884721086477,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.31959978489818236,"maintainance_services_general":0.2132691966081273,"training_general":0.025190593784940044,"other_servies_general":0.003913746166305523,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.017917851544973086,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.02844868545775418,"financial_general":0.0043928909773203045,"miscellaneous_general":0.03479029837253456,"loans_advances":0.022121112872597902,"staff_loans_advances":0.0248126921028243,"grants_contribution_general":0.001342300679132303,"grants_to_other_states":0.05033902464974512,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.10633058829005503,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0007498384510101412,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.0007498384510101412,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.045533915751889524,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.045533915751889524,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.012366473351957234,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.012366473351957234,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.04768036073519813,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.04768036073519813,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.34290165697411856,"other_capital_projects":0.05610675083005645},"expenditure":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.17841942576533198,"recurrent_expenditure":0.04212730851954804,"capital_expenditure":0.0036641472694339786,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.06258402458974809,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":147291821606.66,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":96785211919,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":50506609687.66},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6570983430258813,"governors_office":0.3429016569741186,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.6298135597046844,"state_assembly":0.32866330511960834,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":49809106650.38999,"office_head_of_service":11921653218.319998,"office_auditor_general_state":13548961416.880001,"office_auditor_general_lga":2674052897.36,"civil_service_commission":640609739.5300001,"lga_service_commission":16921576230.919981,"state_inec":3346507419.86,"economic_sector":282562175.58,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":225614774.69,"ministry_finance":113241495.97,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":88706599.17,"ministry_labour_productivity":45620682.11,"ministry_science_tech":58774580028.19,"ministry_transport":3665404500.37,"ministry_energy":16477696099.33,"ministry_works":5226810104.42,"ministry_culture_tourism":1405521333.03,"state_planning_commission":154500000,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":11009521189.900002,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":16466643085.699999,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":802165761.04,"judiciary":63733537.94,"ministry_justice":2444419954.91,"regional_sector":390887469.19,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":667276992.36,"state_capital_dev_agency":2328990211.4900117,"social_sector":1955393023.98,"ministry_youth_development":373597187.5100116,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":36379144716.68,"ministry_sports":414251566.88,"minsitry_lga":576407692.98},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","admin_sector":20500269873.65,"governors_office":12495824118.59,"secretary_to_state_gov":1774187002.3899999,"state_assembly":324935364.64,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":293269097.55,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.3381661392131075,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.08093900318618194,"civil_service_commission":0.09198719432679868,"lga_service_commission":0.0181547954814559,"state_inec":0.004349255325531489,"economic_sector":0.1148846965591119,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.022720252783598426,"ministry_finance":0.0019183833324743368,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0015317535775509648,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0007688240578109573,"ministry_science_tech":0.0006022506762587896,"ministry_transport":0.0003097299063340336,"ministry_energy":0.3990349184841123,"ministry_works":0.02488532262272098,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.11187108638885171,"state_planning_commission":0.03548608502091919,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.00954242616934576,"ministry_water_resources":0.0010489380762265896,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0747463170039455,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.11179604479109405,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.005446098447897319,"regional_sector":0.00043270248982458224,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.01659576158571639,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.002653830096784718,"social_sector":0.004530305790785522,"ministry_youth_development":0.015812080983759812,"ministry_women_affairs":0.013275638814501455,"ministry_education":0.0025364421692583563,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.2469868613196312},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.00281245463842691,"governors_office":0.0039133720168067826,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.13918131808020934,"state_assembly":0.08483718907326611,"ministry_of_info":0.01204538706248017,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.002206065218663217,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0019910752297786737,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.3241244209027147,"lga_service_commission":0.07757816201589512,"state_inec":0.08816759762233299,"economic_sector":0.01740095145459209,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.004168660608735781,"ministry_finance":0.11011432377426783,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.021776836656038835,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0018387260420411815,"ministry_science_tech":0.0014681503666944434,"ministry_transport":0.0007369000725321373,"ministry_energy":0.0005772433400188349,"ministry_works":0.0002968689495653665,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.3824657376240693,"state_planning_commission":0.023852006007566658,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.10722584814647423,"ministry_water_resources":0.03401259151573893,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.009146194717611812,"ministry_land_survey":0.0010053828786964869,"law_justuce_sector":0.07164261557910444,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.10715392251112406,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.005219959365865071,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.00041473532584873114,"social_sector":0.01590665353404888,"ministry_youth_development":0.0025436347509425663,"ministry_women_affairs":0.004342193291047447,"ministry_education":0.015155513807661928,"ministry_health":0.012724392669463049,"ministry_environment":0.002431121138198878,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.23673119249043256,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0026956727042999652,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0037508765415600856,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.13340207339563173},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.08131448300344987,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.011545224827241093,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0021144624743822385,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0019083995438675717},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":49809106650.38999,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":58774580028.19,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":2328990211.4900117,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":36379144716.68,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.3381661392131075,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.3990349184841123,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.015812080983759812,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.2469868613196312,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.3241244209027147},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.3824657376240693,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.015155513807661928,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.23673119249043256,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"yobe","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.6317529128571429,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.7325956,"recurrent_revenue_performance":0.9994157603918559,"federation_revenue_performance":1.0101794987893462,"igr_performance":0.9065116959262806,"aids_grant_performance":0.20687006245998926,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.07765117334751517,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.5051335223960703,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.517723221618595,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.7458866945706872,"total_expenditure_performance":0.6317529128571429},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.9525706228234199,"satutory_allocation":0.8628600475384022,"derivation":0.43439122277672493,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.07790717627222242,"igr":0.35056164848945476,"tax_revenue":0.08971057528501772,"personal_taxes":0.0718427345347436,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.04167009987253789,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.04167009987253789,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.030172634662205718,"lottery_tax":0.030172634662205718,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.017867840750274113,"fees_general":0.0004055340002621149,"fines_general":0.009676205336949135,"sales_general":0.000020921873851375475,"earnings_general":0.0005053348131029734,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.002188970699565085,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0022694773090489364,"repayments":0.0025821679088501876,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.00021922880864430608,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.02472832504209979,"foreign_aids":0.004136392615930303,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.019073051125796187,"capital_development_fund":0.0015188813003732995,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.022701052134480346,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.022701052134480346,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":1.0415020574985692,"derivation":0.9434161555191563,"vat":0.47494573256973555,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.08518054455733992,"tax_revenue":0.38328987839208084,"personal_taxes":0.09808590197941289,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.07854993009597498,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.04556039595760675,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.04556039595760675,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.032989534138368234,"property_tax":0.032989534138368234,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.01953597188343791,"fines_general":0.0004433944166855885,"sales_general":0.010579570192224271,"earnings_general":0.000022875127723703027,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0005525125748812479,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.002393331720270501,"repayments":0.0024813543795995704,"investment_income":0.0028232375904088487,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.00023969588164417962,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.027036946965153796,"domestic_grants":0.004522563804607162,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.020853699992776788,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.0016606831677698477,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.024820409047851096,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.024820409047851096,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.11653806580659813,"ovetimes_payments":0.07046004189305351,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.07046004189305351,"allowances":0.06495830466606431,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.005501737226989194,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.04607802391354463,"gratuity_arrears":0.004560399745615163,"pension_arrears":0.041517624167929465,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.24890135343924583,"materials_supplies_general":0.17646707546469434,"maintainance_services_general":0.0020196752611678003,"training_general":0.0017185981018757453,"other_servies_general":0.003834038223748494,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.007311482938979262,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.009503919160313326,"financial_general":0.08476003882221593,"miscellaneous_general":0.0007816486337004461,"loans_advances":0.02155771045076379,"staff_loans_advances":0.0000016468591626167123,"grants_contribution_general":0.04497831701276693,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.04384960857399403,"grants_to_private_companies":0.04384960857399403,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.028584669400557455,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.028584669400557455,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.027216023948191052,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.001368645452366403,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.5491729100963172,"preservation_of_environment":0.17382115605755183,"other_capital_projects":0.10429269363453109},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.06952846242302073,"personal_cost":0.12091835878872817,"salaries_wages":0.08061223919248545,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.12741799128207537,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.07703815008018992,"allowances":0.07703815008018992,"social_contribution":0.07102277389239423,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.006015376187795699,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.05037984120188544,"pension_arrears":0.004986155991244127,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.04539368521064131,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.27213863781857084,"maintainance_services_general":0.1929419381341809,"training_general":0.0022082309590342616,"other_servies_general":0.0018790454127289693,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.00419198178369861,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.007994078698062245,"financial_general":0.01039119947918159,"miscellaneous_general":0.09267318633587626,"loans_advances":0.0008546228917148429,"staff_loans_advances":0.02357032565509943,"grants_contribution_general":0.0000018006089681747707,"grants_to_other_states":0.04917746630981651,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.04794338231317421,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.04794338231317421,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.03125331737121574,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.03125331737121574,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.029756895982111127,"domestic_debt_principal":0.0014964213891046133,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.6004433708993538,"other_capital_projects":0.19004899724298865},"expenditure":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.11402939834579319,"recurrent_expenditure":0.07601959889719546,"capital_expenditure":0.1322072258480259,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.08813815056535061,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":442227039000,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":176694745000,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":265532294000},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.3995566291006462,"governors_office":0.6004433708993538,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.36543941924584394,"state_assembly":0.5491729100963172,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":118553569925.47568,"office_head_of_service":56628486845.584625,"office_auditor_general_state":49374074337.2561,"office_auditor_general_lga":3883562126.809106,"civil_service_commission":4515565566.235139,"lga_service_commission":1194524042.082538,"state_inec":333182019.6145833,"economic_sector":458787984.5736335,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":377614538.5557298,"ministry_finance":293767889.1407015,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":9017164.289747763,"ministry_labour_productivity":1484987411.3337512,"ministry_science_tech":275642469229.4898,"ministry_transport":11336578677.451256,"ministry_energy":138243017449.66882,"ministry_works":8302320639.597266,"ministry_culture_tourism":490225394.7882448,"state_planning_commission":304234819.214856,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":98839392.07099766,"ministry_water_resources":36395529.364494406,"ministry_housing_urban_development":89334678565.79297,"ministry_land_survey":1001356142.2115737,"law_justuce_sector":14652580405.79041,"judiciary":43582960.73378085,"ministry_justice":452120871.7996844,"regional_sector":8391883845.7374525,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":2954654535.267991,"state_capital_dev_agency":5097326846.623591,"social_sector":3271878144.884572,"ministry_youth_development":1825448701.7390196,"ministry_women_affairs":462916058.97593045,"ministry_education":317184765.33473736,"ministry_health":145731293.6411931,"ministry_environment":42470756939.43506,"ministry_sports":834080875.8016086,"minsitry_lga":1670021434.562971},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","admin_sector":23752555755.141193,"governors_office":12614620436.569242,"secretary_to_state_gov":2259427435.4703293,"state_assembly":593315133.0886106,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":746735868.801105,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.2680830421259603,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.12805297245875694,"civil_service_commission":0.11164870074182891,"lga_service_commission":0.008781828753825037,"state_inec":0.010210966693592742,"economic_sector":0.0027011555982277644,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.000753418471127414,"ministry_finance":0.001037448966510692,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0008538929220827898,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.000664292011191793,"ministry_science_tech":0.000020390350418504743,"ministry_transport":0.0033579751583976557,"ministry_energy":0.623305327174917,"ministry_works":0.025635200197361194,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.3126064334787743,"state_planning_commission":0.01877388740944279,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.0011085378132842862,"ministry_water_resources":0.0006879606907411557,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.00022350372852483508,"ministry_land_survey":0.00008230055187668975,"law_justuce_sector":0.20201089188893528,"judiciary":0.002264348522143563,"ministry_justice":0.033133614893661914,"regional_sector":0.00009855336035610625,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0010223727450543439,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.01897641506659988,"social_sector":0.006681306828160706,"ministry_youth_development":0.01152649294839611,"ministry_women_affairs":0.007398638835570097,"ministry_education":0.004127854112826013,"ministry_health":0.0010467837064479688,"ministry_environment":0.0007172441695378499,"ministry_sports":0.0003295395369101189,"minsitry_lga":0.09603835404427873},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0018860919895076985,"governors_office":0.003776389246436311,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.05371122446255756,"state_assembly":0.02852521289764293,"ministry_of_info":0.005109202369397248,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.001341652772816116,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0016885803059208803,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.24519205561595725,"lga_service_commission":0.11711882741969129,"state_inec":0.10211527825351002,"economic_sector":0.008031968852419885,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.009339076032462085,"ministry_finance":0.0024705102136107146,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.000689085822847254,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0009488636158339618,"ministry_science_tech":0.0007809809944749248,"ministry_transport":0.0006075696637195148,"ministry_energy":0.000018649265892371533,"ministry_works":0.0030712454814951925,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.5700827371788287,"state_planning_commission":0.02344627016566115,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.2859136982913671,"ministry_water_resources":0.017170828894357944,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0010138823515718068,"ministry_land_survey":0.0006292173298546107,"law_justuce_sector":0.00020441926576275746,"judiciary":0.0000752730994580846,"ministry_justice":0.1847616523830266,"regional_sector":0.002071001076280204,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.03030441269741825,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.00009013811847979574,"social_sector":0.000935074717810093,"ministry_youth_development":0.017356063186626598,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0061108056011537504,"ministry_education":0.010542272564678561,"ministry_health":0.006766886299362142,"ministry_environment":0.00377538626531642,"ministry_sports":0.0009574012840717979,"minsitry_lga":0.0006560003606080969},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.00030140092346370097,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.08783786269862494,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.001725042987877227,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0034539321651858032,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.04912494811751943},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.02608951141329426,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.004672939480154906,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0012270921677137172,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.0015443963668795955},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":118553569925.47568,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":275642469229.4898,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":5097326846.623591,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":462916058.97593045},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":42470756939.43506,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.2680830421259603,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.623305327174917,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.01152649294839611,"health_total_expenditure":0.0010467837064479688,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.09603835404427873,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.24519205561595725},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.5700827371788287,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.010542272564678561,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.0009574012840717979,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.08783786269862494,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"akwa_ibom","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.264461482597783,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.2388947409760058,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.3000047296812158,"federation_revenue_performance":1.2958657735085033,"igr_performance":1.3598747307195,"aids_grant_performance":0.27964533951556886,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":1.18256451184348,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.1483767583068147,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.749512661814677,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.9583165948866591,"total_expenditure_performance":1.264461482597783},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.8605276240764468,"satutory_allocation":0.8023214755222996,"derivation":0.7319093996909066,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.07041207583139295,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.058206148554147186,"personal_taxes":0.038977991206464876,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.030238955064301437,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.030238955064301437,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.008739036142163443,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0.00009249637792663514,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.000019472683283168573,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.00862706708095364,"licances_general":0.019228157347682306,"fees_general":0.00007322107215497349,"fines_general":0.014283825017009836,"sales_general":0.00001861398650288528,"earnings_general":0,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.00006886549874369443,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0036877707756936095,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.000221208401309166,"reimbursement":0.0008746525962681407,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.009994567858735447,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.004280258117845217,"capital_development_fund":0.00571430974089023,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.12947780806481782,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.12947780806481782,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.8166857914980229,"derivation":0.7614451075594765,"vat":0.6946203592626439,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.06682474829683262,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.05524068393854631,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.036992155404213745,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.028698352336180517,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.028698352336180517,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.008293803068033229,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0.00008778390780747729,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.00001848059645589258,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.00818753856376986,"fees_general":0.018248528534332564,"fines_general":0.00006949063294905457,"sales_general":0.013556098157982687,"earnings_general":0.000017665648231057713,"rent_on_government_building_general":0,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00006535696562764131,"repayments":0.003499887639334002,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.00020993836020438944,"miscellaneous_income":0.0008300911300037351,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.009485368434455896,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.004062189162770813,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.005423179271685083,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.12288122217381711,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.12288122217381711,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.20098591490778073,"ovetimes_payments":0.114395889376752,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.114395889376752,"allowances":0.114395889376752,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.08659002553102871,"gratuity_arrears":0.016912071451055083,"pension_arrears":0.01327504003306025,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0.056402914046913374,"utilities_general":0.49055668222682,"materials_supplies_general":0.1714502995546131,"maintainance_services_general":0.021778053910464286,"training_general":0.02722256738808036,"other_servies_general":0.04174126999507082,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.018148378258727376,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.013559408703704208,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0,"loans_advances":0.049000621298566055,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.07832848186896788,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.04787577712054498,"subsidies_general":0.0304527047484229,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.240777900803239,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.04787577712054498,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.04787577712054498,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.19290212368269402,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.19290212368269402,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.3621400223438234,"preservation_of_environment":0.041189416478440516,"other_capital_projects":0.22306298614908135},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.023327955569425428,"personal_cost":0.01980437226229644,"salaries_wages":0.05475529188457968,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.19074616131304256,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.10856769131617479,"allowances":0.10856769131617479,"social_contribution":0.10856769131617479,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.08217846999686777,"pension_arrears":0.016050441696975705,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.01259870836593227,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.05352931993395979,"materials_supplies_general":0.46556398782552466,"maintainance_services_general":0.16271531520514357,"training_general":0.02066851394136546,"other_servies_general":0.02583564242670683,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.03961465172096402,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.017223761617811324,"financial_general":0.012868589130203318,"miscellaneous_general":0,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0.04650415636809261,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.07433783230451377,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.045436620321443306,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.02890121198307046,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.22851084031586735,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.045436620321443306,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.045436620321443306,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.18307421999442405,"capital_expenditure":0.18307421999442405,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.34368985086143283,"other_capital_projects":0.03909091382643229},"expenditure":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.2116984583645293,"recurrent_expenditure":0.02213945180283303,"capital_expenditure":0.018795386671652283,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.051965640195985874,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":492345363512.27,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":323131258954.42004,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":169214104557.85},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6563101491385672,"governors_office":0.34368985086143283,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.6915425971346008,"state_assembly":0.3621400223438234,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":102872436711.12123,"office_head_of_service":49557226049.355896,"office_auditor_general_state":15831566085.121864,"office_auditor_general_lga":24692824893.317474,"civil_service_commission":5927296815.880476,"lga_service_commission":2891549982.476429,"state_inec":917879916.8000065,"economic_sector":661823695.1763818,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":235150469.65921146,"ministry_finance":482037579.3019482,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":16908560.85477191,"ministry_labour_productivity":1658172663.176794,"ministry_science_tech":286921667145.81586,"ministry_transport":17138793829.9715,"ministry_energy":150070775901.57184,"ministry_works":2316966727.149563,"ministry_culture_tourism":597389473.4356203,"state_planning_commission":1215045452.018231,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":2287965450.8245964,"ministry_water_resources":3141870580.992481,"ministry_housing_urban_development":86447099906.88869,"ministry_land_survey":2236013444.7570915,"law_justuce_sector":16129953433.083359,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":1250583446.980493,"regional_sector":596971567.1882346,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":3492237930.9541564,"state_capital_dev_agency":13074231342.13757,"social_sector":9542740629.702541,"ministry_youth_development":3531490712.4350276,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":89477028313.19537,"ministry_sports":2851263602.460572,"minsitry_lga":2240225121.425854},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","admin_sector":43699626521.9057,"governors_office":19697658625.177143,"secretary_to_state_gov":12943061146.193682,"state_assembly":2114904237.9886189,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":5930289058.043813,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.20894364877787153,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.10065541329733849,"civil_service_commission":0.032155408090336,"lga_service_commission":0.050153462839915806,"state_inec":0.01203890044499781,"economic_sector":0.005873011501212943,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0018643009253749812,"ministry_finance":0.0013442265211052163,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00047761284473505787,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0009790639153443254,"ministry_science_tech":0.00003434288633115263,"ministry_transport":0.0033679055111797956,"ministry_energy":0.5827650434219339,"ministry_works":0.03481051127953676,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.30480793975798626,"state_planning_commission":0.004705978564763757,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.0012133545224717699,"ministry_water_resources":0.002467872233731211,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.004647074229566857,"ministry_land_survey":0.006381436312468049,"law_justuce_sector":0.17558223619736452,"judiciary":0.004541554791551046,"ministry_justice":0.03276146101593455,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0025400532627323637,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0012125057153571776,"social_sector":0.007093065538469571,"ministry_youth_development":0.026555000434794872,"ministry_women_affairs":0.019382208784555197,"ministry_education":0.007172791650239674,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.18173630736539975},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.005791186053059102,"governors_office":0.0045501091052115175,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.08875807463720868,"state_assembly":0.04000780769957682,"ministry_of_info":0.02628858136057398,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0042955705379277166,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.012044977971841956,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.2201602911676475,"lga_service_commission":0.10605885954782301,"state_inec":0.03388159462702294,"economic_sector":0.05284583210107629,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.012685180156525257,"ministry_finance":0.006188290142824965,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0019643814825451604,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0014163881219305134,"ministry_science_tech":0.0005032523533369777,"ministry_transport":0.0010316226309568107,"ministry_energy":0.000036186502429858665,"ministry_works":0.003548703501175748,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.6140493974932808,"state_planning_commission":0.03667923071040552,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.3211708284020166,"ministry_water_resources":0.004958607821329591,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0012784905715940468,"ministry_land_survey":0.002600354079775972,"law_justuce_sector":0.004896541347120685,"judiciary":0.006724008529756068,"ministry_justice":0.1850079505703184,"regional_sector":0.004785357349266294,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.034520182061210186,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.0026764099754905545,"ministry_youth_development":0.0012775961982901113,"ministry_women_affairs":0.007473839876706756,"ministry_education":0.02798054241838535,"ministry_health":0.02042269652338784,"ministry_environment":0.007557845894997508,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.19149238839911042,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.00610207209027423,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0047943708808919,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.09352284058359552},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.04215553161647916,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.027699821270381262,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.004526168016558019,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.012691583940930349},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":102872436711.12123,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":286921667145.81586,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":13074231342.13757,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":89477028313.19537,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.20894364877787153,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5827650434219339,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.026555000434794872,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.18173630736539975,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.2201602911676475},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.6140493974932808,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.02798054241838535,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.19149238839911042,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"bayelsa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.2319133438334016,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.2676653774733324,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.0840471125372033,"federation_revenue_performance":1.1117672832004912,"igr_performance":0.9892315262715266,"aids_grant_performance":1.1209142034516615,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":9.881691831833333,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.3094867599524067,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":2.1543750415850367,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.5635310617913132,"total_expenditure_performance":1.2319133438334016},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.6615658981956068,"satutory_allocation":0.5249956923366433,"derivation":0.1758672988856377,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.1805850307350617,"igr":0.16854336271594392,"tax_revenue":0.13657020585896357,"personal_taxes":0.08455021475364745,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.08455021475364745,"personal_income_tax_dat":0,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.08455021475364745,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.05201999110531611,"fees_general":0.0020083474834539056,"fines_general":0.03842892163665814,"sales_general":0.0024960351825959073,"earnings_general":0.00207642030430668,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0027001245831664343,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0005739361178061704,"repayments":0.0015925794559231159,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.0015363219649663095,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.0006073043764394354,"domestic_aids":0.18247971470624905,"foreign_aids":0.023321429303862336,"domestic_grants":0.015040437258212065,"foreign_grants":0.14411784814417467,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.1559543870981441,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.1559543870981441,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.6807655654171019,"derivation":0.5402318806182249,"vat":0.18097124034174503,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.18582588807784978,"tax_revenue":0.1734347521986301,"personal_taxes":0.14053368479887693,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.0870039929656193,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.0870039929656193,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.0870039929656193,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.05352969183325764,"fines_general":0.002066632838628064,"sales_general":0.03954418847419787,"earnings_general":0.002568473990293966,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.002136681238196075,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0027784863814313827,"repayments":0.0005905926330502754,"investment_income":0.0016387985788569172,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0015809084083620133,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.0006249292902410641,"foreign_aids":0.187775558713005,"domestic_grants":0.023998253310337028,"foreign_grants":0.01547693404713522,"capital_development_fund":0.14830037135553276,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.16048042500636056,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.16048042500636056,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.27435448783398164,"ovetimes_payments":0.23000743495033793,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.23000743495033793,"allowances":0.18446243097527526,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.045545003975062684,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.04034751017855478,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0.04034751017855478,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.003999542705088934,"gratuity_arrears":0.003999542705088934,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.5023762628460403,"materials_supplies_general":0.2708862183752044,"maintainance_services_general":0.015726598039623674,"training_general":0.0058751383828981795,"other_servies_general":0.004837562867002315,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.006096627709903326,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0034414488685182605,"financial_general":0.06024315851505819,"miscellaneous_general":0.004415369960152124,"loans_advances":0.0023300032922155735,"staff_loans_advances":0.016455156735828227,"grants_contribution_general":0.15146515400400454,"grants_to_other_states":0.000024052003440535982,"grants_to_lga":0.000024052003440535982,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.23146599246739538,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.23146599246739538,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.23146599246739538,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.19506619646766238,"preservation_of_environment":0.10649859420338925,"other_capital_projects":0.03935154535432711},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.008508398584465384,"personal_cost":0.005984477165818659,"salaries_wages":0.03472318115966198,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.2823166800834659,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.23668260702550198,"allowances":0.23668260702550198,"social_contribution":0.18981581647965642,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.04686679054584556,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.04151845742773582,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0.04151845742773582,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.004115615630228072,"pension_arrears":0.004115615630228072,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.5169560002432215,"maintainance_services_general":0.2787477560721722,"training_general":0.016183008277380083,"other_servies_general":0.006045644000161004,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.004977956435447772,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0062735612905530334,"financial_general":0.0035413250459566032,"miscellaneous_general":0.06199150830003894,"loans_advances":0.004543510836406361,"staff_loans_advances":0.0023976235972487385,"grants_contribution_general":0.01693271087558534,"grants_to_other_states":0.15586090741339434,"grants_to_lga":0.00002475002984021598,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.00002475002984021598,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.23818349414120907,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.23818349414120907,"capital_expenditure":0.23818349414120907,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.20072731967331245,"other_capital_projects":0.10958934838802761},"expenditure":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.040493588161423635,"recurrent_expenditure":0.008755325492057096,"capital_expenditure":0.006158155963942532,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.03573090166786157,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":184727050008.28003,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":147647284388.96002,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":37079765619.32},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.7992726803266875,"governors_office":0.20072731967331245,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.7767307506800221,"state_assembly":0.19506619646766238,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":79398306054.51071,"office_head_of_service":24300275602.6101,"office_auditor_general_state":36121266132.4931,"office_auditor_general_lga":8076673577.386482,"civil_service_commission":753786328.8644371,"lga_service_commission":1021119809.3800049,"state_inec":4508611507.636397,"economic_sector":905293635.7437347,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":996307679.1256374,"ministry_finance":71167992.96033622,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":2321910586.399898,"ministry_labour_productivity":321893201.91060024,"ministry_science_tech":55260814343.71683,"ministry_transport":2397653313.879767,"ministry_energy":607751580.8198819,"ministry_works":258217298.1877324,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":171359389.2375015,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":1131457926.3006628,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":6938384745.651065,"ministry_land_survey":243165556.14175957,"law_justuce_sector":40879810761.47134,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":1182586953.9929442,"regional_sector":582753790.7470965,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":867673027.2870865,"state_capital_dev_agency":5741666287.453957,"social_sector":5295157994.016939,"ministry_youth_development":446508293.43701714,"ministry_women_affairs":71762161.74,"ministry_education":71762161.74,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":44254501160.85852,"ministry_sports":184936355.25225478,"minsitry_lga":853241516.3096254},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","admin_sector":23631510634.088066,"governors_office":11793454561.830528,"secretary_to_state_gov":2776153364.6826353,"state_assembly":279369677.8495152,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":4735835050.845895,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.4298141828765838,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.13154692613518643,"civil_service_commission":0.19553858588048711,"lga_service_commission":0.04372220298556417,"state_inec":0.004080541148849885,"economic_sector":0.005527722168108218,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.024406883060354764,"ministry_finance":0.004900709645410116,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.005393404371915103,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.00038526026890564353,"ministry_science_tech":0.012569413013935007,"ministry_transport":0.0017425341978674592,"ministry_energy":0.29914846981662874,"ministry_works":0.012979438115707996,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.003289997760439744,"state_planning_commission":0.0013978315475516895,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.0009276356073992447,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.0061250256865464335,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.03756019892776973,"judiciary":0.0013163505622531197,"ministry_justice":0.22129845498880094,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0064018071740978766,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0031546749148052534,"social_sector":0.004697054531256763,"ministry_youth_development":0.031081892376869535,"ministry_women_affairs":0.028664767795401887,"ministry_education":0.002417124581467648,"ministry_health":0.0003884767376341656,"ministry_environment":0.0003884767376341656,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.2395669781922837},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.001001133051407281,"governors_office":0.00461893110008188,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.12792663896829853,"state_assembly":0.06384259674639914,"ministry_of_info":0.015028407396524763,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0015123376778711781,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.02563693325170093,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.4176921107602407,"lga_service_commission":0.1278369012248361,"state_inec":0.1900238008082327,"economic_sector":0.042489103383942635,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.003965457431162823,"ministry_finance":0.005371823527648146,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.023718534447443294,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.004762494672266762,"ministry_science_tech":0.005241293903360072,"ministry_transport":0.0003743947531798004,"ministry_energy":0.012214917194380417,"ministry_works":0.001693389413788036,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.29071156971170103,"state_planning_commission":0.012613378336537326,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.0031972097797180626,"ministry_water_resources":0.0013584084305374553,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.0009014734513360741,"law_justuce_sector":0.005952281263386975,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.036500886652266355,"regional_sector":0.0012792254577737197,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.215057162966616,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.006221256668016461,"ministry_youth_development":0.003065703451451127,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0045645832540615215,"ministry_education":0.030205288123414702,"ministry_health":0.027856333834268814,"ministry_environment":0.002348954289145885,"ministry_sports":0.00037752050767077413,"minsitry_lga":0.00037752050767077413},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.2328104580446572,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0009728980430462416,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.004488663142145067,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.12431871720825652},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.06204204061613137,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.014604560428434445,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.001469685138411629,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.024913893468231925},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":79398306054.51071,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":55260814343.71683,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":5741666287.453957,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":71762161.74},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":44254501160.85852,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.4298141828765838,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.29914846981662874,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.031081892376869535,"health_total_expenditure":0.0003884767376341656,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.2395669781922837,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.4176921107602407},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.29071156971170103,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.030205288123414702,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.00037752050767077413,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.2328104580446572,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"plateau","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.9617662671800155,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.210944606491437,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.4576213171685377,"federation_revenue_performance":1.6151286951732362,"igr_performance":1.181025803869048,"aids_grant_performance":1.0436239212613854,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.24743303947739623,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.0886545126877663,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.8215565286806075,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.9865515865648359,"total_expenditure_performance":0.9617662671800155},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.8571435711419897,"satutory_allocation":0.605157537241831,"derivation":0.4407420856780094,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.16441545156382162,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.2519860339001587,"personal_taxes":0.0793568719343513,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.07052631697636803,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.0519470438377772,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.008033724466795202,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.010545548671795631,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.00883055495798326,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.000045039082628106235,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.008785515875355152,"licances_general":0.17262916196580746,"fees_general":0.003018587040084871,"fines_general":0.11448474713223251,"sales_general":0.00013618593471279597,"earnings_general":0.009188121068204037,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.03913035990057858,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.005318637676182306,"repayments":0.0011358328102647913,"investment_income":7.798153554256015e-7,"interest_earned":4.873845971410009e-7,"reimbursement":0.00006971719994682488,"miscellaneous_income":0.0001457060036481609,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.11014018083100176,"foreign_aids":0.08672413519704827,"domestic_grants":0.0006025250777935632,"foreign_grants":0.022813520556159924,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.032716248027008586,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.032716248027008586,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.9077716787886169,"derivation":0.6409018185619693,"vat":0.4667749913770814,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.17412682718488787,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.26686986022664766,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.08404417099375985,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.0746920298020998,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.05501535189711325,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.008508245049812995,"other_taxes":0.011168432855173556,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.00935214119166006,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.00004769936452296205,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.009304441827137098,"fees_general":0.18282568923288783,"fines_general":0.0031968831327715587,"sales_general":0.12124691195134821,"earnings_general":0.00014422990353520673,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.009730827329060093,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.04144163672746804,"repayments":0.005632788735431817,"investment_income":0.0012029219977973322,"interest_earned":8.258759887759508e-7,"reimbursement":5.161724929849693e-7,"miscellaneous_income":0.00007383512140428463,"aids_grants":0.00015431228558950553,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.11664572916510602,"domestic_grants":0.09184658959108523,"foreign_grants":0.0006381138700628477,"capital_development_fund":0.02416102570395794,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.03464866843202701,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.03464866843202701,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.2294237416208494,"ovetimes_payments":0.17038205190255232,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.17038205190255232,"allowances":0.17038205190255232,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.059041689718297076,"gratuity_arrears":0.007405109562275283,"pension_arrears":0.051636580156021794,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.2283028902766951,"materials_supplies_general":0.17397607359629771,"maintainance_services_general":0.015005047602837825,"training_general":0.005615512359966827,"other_servies_general":0.012820912639587049,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.006294315784979651,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0030128605311108914,"financial_general":0.015620315918473255,"miscellaneous_general":0.03131435997579177,"loans_advances":0.005153929114433282,"staff_loans_advances":0.07183454917329737,"grants_contribution_general":0.007304270495819801,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.008777088723930926,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.008243737271423723,"subsidies_general":0.0005333514525072037,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.04554972795646643,"domestic_debt_interest":0.007042540885965427,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.007042540885965427,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.038507187070501006,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.038507187070501006,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.4865015161823909,"preservation_of_environment":0.022901855608678138,"other_capital_projects":0.10895764931318262},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.05830548412136276,"personal_cost":0.009930581378300218,"salaries_wages":0.2864059457608672,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.24297490186813103,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.18044585119498927,"allowances":0.18044585119498927,"social_contribution":0.18044585119498927,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.06252905067314175,"pension_arrears":0.00784250032932548,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.05468655034381627,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.24178784623286584,"maintainance_services_general":0.18425215764862948,"training_general":0.01589133689071886,"other_servies_general":0.0059471986419657496,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.013578193644891922,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0066660963219312905,"financial_general":0.003190818381381098,"miscellaneous_general":0.016542946691683342,"loans_advances":0.03316397635409275,"staff_loans_advances":0.0054583514851931384,"grants_contribution_general":0.07607753414190327,"grants_to_other_states":0.0077357050948680724,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.009295516916943134,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.00873066248680169,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.0005648544301414449,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.048240171667293205,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0074585161438856275,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.0074585161438856275,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.040781655523407574,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.040781655523407574,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.5152372518990032,"other_capital_projects":0.024254578361435734},"expenditure":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.11539335015032681,"recurrent_expenditure":0.0617493603001833,"capital_expenditure":0.010517141856545805,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.30332282123051146,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":181625331209.76,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":88045194681.76001,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":93580136528},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.48476274809969194,"governors_office":0.515237251900308,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.4577266318951531,"state_assembly":0.4865015161823909,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":43114641479.97,"office_head_of_service":4727574113,"office_auditor_general_state":21247169343.97,"office_auditor_general_lga":2566098786,"civil_service_commission":1167600837,"lga_service_commission":0,"state_inec":12991338212,"economic_sector":237219941,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":136235324,"ministry_finance":32052390,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0,"ministry_labour_productivity":9352533,"ministry_science_tech":75271190051.66,"ministry_transport":2526869492,"ministry_energy":27995036710.219997,"ministry_works":2825596772,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":6154297683,"ministry_housing_urban_development":22857228661.77,"ministry_land_survey":69732910,"law_justuce_sector":2072512752.67,"judiciary":8524481,"ministry_justice":6543252524,"regional_sector":438991798,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":3779146267,"state_capital_dev_agency":2909541148.75,"social_sector":2283515422.75,"ministry_youth_development":626025726,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":60329958529.38,"ministry_sports":127138528,"minsitry_lga":729733017},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","admin_sector":35168106753.31,"governors_office":20505147342.07,"secretary_to_state_gov":2481877251,"state_assembly":1053894360,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":264061278,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.23738231441993898,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.026029266300569755,"civil_service_commission":0.11698351327094196,"lga_service_commission":0.014128529147896779,"state_inec":0.006428623305020018,"economic_sector":0,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.07152822860905529,"ministry_finance":0.0013060950222049848,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0007500898860980801,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.000176475328559216,"ministry_science_tech":0,"ministry_transport":0.000051493549592898064,"ministry_energy":0.4144311234017148,"ministry_works":0.01391253893475523,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.1541361908258132,"state_planning_commission":0.015557283519717566,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.03388457789446112,"law_justuce_sector":0.12584824214478202,"judiciary":0.00038393823997649593,"ministry_justice":0.011410923459080692,"regional_sector":0.0000469344278311787,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.03602610098712824,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.002417018568251883,"social_sector":0.020807374399917124,"ministry_youth_development":0.01601946782072148,"ministry_women_affairs":0.012572670384325264,"ministry_education":0.003446797436396216,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.33216709435509206},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.000700004383490126,"governors_office":0.004017793179715551,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.19362996625512058,"state_assembly":0.11289805890752413,"ministry_of_info":0.013664818857934424,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.005802573644202652,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.0014538791271046082,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.22414306313166793,"lga_service_commission":0.024577565914866453,"state_inec":0.11045912609170608,"economic_sector":0.013340554912411965,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.006070087078002565,"ministry_finance":0,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.06753896683496652,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0012332516840330347,"ministry_science_tech":0.0007082559840438799,"ministry_transport":0.00016663297266726664,"ministry_energy":0,"ministry_works":0.00004862165897016445,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.39131753215628834,"state_planning_commission":0.013136610873453927,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.14553973001555312,"ministry_water_resources":0.014689625006977416,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0,"judiciary":0.03199477223375734,"ministry_justice":0.1188294526194828,"regional_sector":0.0003625252933100766,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.010774515125649652,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.00004431680787222525,"social_sector":0.03401685861761683,"ministry_youth_development":0.0022822169665752926,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0196469085960396,"ministry_education":0.015126032433585962,"ministry_health":0.011871469273410894,"ministry_environment":0.0032545631601750683,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.31364152035600174,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0006609638426707187,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.00379371341345101,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.1828308644498529},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.10660152508407097,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.0129027066040752,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0054789533661629124,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.001372793595718057},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":43114641479.97,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":75271190051.66,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":2909541148.75,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":60329958529.38,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.23738231441993898,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.4144311234017148,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.01601946782072148,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.33216709435509206,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.22414306313166793},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.39131753215628834,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.015126032433585962,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.31364152035600174,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kwara","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","budget_performance":0.6746545604353867,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.8232562099942212,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.367767290035646,"federation_revenue_performance":1.6552627218415692,"igr_performance":0.6610856095683577,"aids_grant_performance":0.4314457990761225,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.00009804545243591176,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.8299146938861178,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":0.924591437532346,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.3762770511605555,"total_expenditure_performance":0.6746545604353867},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.9282387152565186,"satutory_allocation":0.7984991746141075,"derivation":0.2426179287653784,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.2543077607268728,"igr":0.3015734851218563,"tax_revenue":0.12973954064241114,"personal_taxes":0.09182724152250582,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.07114467888269424,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.07114467888269424,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.020682562639811587,"lottery_tax":0.020682562639811587,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.03791229911990531,"fees_general":0.00211171654801665,"fines_general":0.02877218996037701,"sales_general":0.0017195576774460244,"earnings_general":0.0006219712757229739,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.004410989933947616,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.000009956671421574206,"repayments":0.0002621521619267532,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0000037648910467150886,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.07172502824735241,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.06166702176900488,"capital_development_fund":0.01005800647834753,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.00003625649612906885,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.00003625649612906885,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":1.1326956512392639,"derivation":0.9743792493653906,"vat":0.29605775788965805,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.3103224309838451,"tax_revenue":0.36799906049188735,"personal_taxes":0.15831640187387325,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.11205341409305053,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.08681524165577593,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.08681524165577593,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.025238172437274598,"property_tax":0.025238172437274598,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.04626298778082273,"fines_general":0.0025768502339696526,"sales_general":0.035109647883780376,"earnings_general":0.002098313150793268,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0007589687303792969,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.005382569196612213,"repayments":0.000012149760869345686,"investment_income":0.0003198946659915448,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0.000004594158427043559,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.08752342069500736,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.0752500043734179,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.012273416321589462,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.000044242472135220596,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.000044242472135220596,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.2720805416939321,"ovetimes_payments":0.20083131677766736,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.20083131677766736,"allowances":0.20083131677766736,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.007751414841003318,"group_life_insurance":0.009307497065240087,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0.009195814690658121,"social_benefit":0.00011168237458196638,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.054190313010021286,"gratuity_arrears":0.0038536602084969815,"pension_arrears":0.05023836417932746,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.00009828862219684436,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.3603746403173295,"materials_supplies_general":0.233528978123049,"maintainance_services_general":0.04294770794816631,"training_general":0.004266619687093039,"other_servies_general":0.01290285512061839,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.008235845732851693,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.009011381783480594,"financial_general":0.04345310614253382,"miscellaneous_general":0.017626549084292606,"loans_advances":0.00907667668960161,"staff_loans_advances":0.001007278283372586,"grants_contribution_general":0.08500095765103835,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.030241902762209096,"grants_to_private_companies":0.013091583643481189,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.017150319118727907,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.09660375943207145,"domestic_debt_interest":0.005124778457734432,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.005124778457734432,"foreign_debt_principal":0.091478980974337,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.091478980974337,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.18704007626129182,"preservation_of_environment":0.003458617191690631,"other_capital_projects":0.16618495920713647},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.017392715576954786,"personal_cost":0.000003784285509953601,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.332009903592928,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.24506708824771928,"allowances":0.24506708824771928,"social_contribution":0.24506708824771928,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0.009458767165221716,"employee_comepensation_fund":0.011357597217657769,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0.0112213153130896,"gratuity":0.00013628190456816807,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.06612645096232918,"pension_arrears":0.0047024801786166096,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.06130403278382221,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.00011993799989036038,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.43975195302164105,"maintainance_services_general":0.28496684485437296,"training_general":0.05240751244698778,"other_servies_general":0.005206399480683776,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.015744880754791468,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.010049900410909465,"financial_general":0.010996258602491541,"miscellaneous_general":0.05302423132274169,"loans_advances":0.0215090312071461,"staff_loans_advances":0.01107593558104863,"grants_contribution_general":0.0012291447365978272,"grants_to_other_states":0.10372355031097465,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.03690308449856952,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.015975179247623053,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0.020927905250946472,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.11788202366869864,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.006253579146433569,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.006253579146433569,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.11162844452226506,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.11162844452226506,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.22823814338543097,"other_capital_projects":0.004220423677595386},"expenditure":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.20278940912659377,"recurrent_expenditure":0.021223692756462777,"capital_expenditure":0.000004617824779036119,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":121269218040.12,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":93590956864.84,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":27678261175.28},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.7717618566145691,"governors_office":0.22823814338543097,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.6324551820112616,"state_assembly":0.18704007626129182,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":24142079917.08173,"office_head_of_service":5337343820.945328,"office_auditor_general_state":1884129405.1221924,"office_auditor_general_lga":1743887962.1818023,"civil_service_commission":1032132175.7749836,"lga_service_commission":12895299462.81906,"state_inec":487996951.7171813,"economic_sector":121561976.39673536,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":62868133.288402334,"ministry_finance":26771554.357192237,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":207061766.14619368,"ministry_labour_productivity":343026708.33266014,"ministry_science_tech":68256514063.474655,"ministry_transport":7617479481.8110285,"ministry_energy":38684043035.89183,"ministry_works":145907921.26858044,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":43186958.68269929,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":18113548223.14664,"ministry_land_survey":82115182.22025125,"law_justuce_sector":139226497.764948,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":1379696145.312696,"regional_sector":936592745.0919794,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":1114717872.2839866,"state_capital_dev_agency":2262142095.6067843,"social_sector":1319867453.412621,"ministry_youth_development":942274642.1941633,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":26608481963.956825,"ministry_sports":49445906.04759187,"minsitry_lga":26001697.01137438},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","admin_sector":13886244298.737104,"governors_office":4315456778.113743,"secretary_to_state_gov":0,"state_assembly":19987686.250242252,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":8311345597.796768,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.19907838367601832,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.044012354554636875,"civil_service_commission":0.015536749024792575,"lga_service_commission":0.01438030186361773,"state_inec":0.00851108131523961,"economic_sector":0.10633613105803036,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.004024079313810165,"ministry_finance":0.0010024141192740148,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0005184178994838032,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0002207613340784905,"ministry_science_tech":0.0017074552758944202,"ministry_transport":0.002828637917160274,"ministry_energy":0.5628511106659653,"ministry_works":0.06281461697304674,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.3189930937222159,"state_planning_commission":0.0012031735969494676,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.000356124657028889,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.14936641396627182,"judiciary":0.0006771312914138256,"ministry_justice":0.0011480778058524889,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.01137713401315283,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.007723252118127145,"social_sector":0.009192092521906094,"ministry_youth_development":0.018653885397845894,"ministry_women_affairs":0.01088377969895018,"ministry_education":0.007770105698895714,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.21941662026017048},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.00040773666101511,"governors_office":0.00021441300135020358,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.11450757680438792,"state_assembly":0.03558575579077324,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.00016482077293208605,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.06853631722971193,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.16314379144706112,"lga_service_commission":0.03606791586293534,"state_inec":0.012732292154788234,"economic_sector":0.011784589189762691,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.006974790780610989,"ministry_finance":0.08714195518510467,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0032977139165801007,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0008214736175705129,"ministry_science_tech":0.0004248410104305939,"ministry_transport":0.00018091286648724603,"ministry_energy":0.0013992515023079318,"ministry_works":0.0023180553604827962,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.46125381630419876,"state_planning_commission":0.051476280759618465,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.2614133277270481,"ministry_water_resources":0.000985995057578821,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.0002918424677891139,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0.12240506799053505,"regional_sector":0.0005549058825416006,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0009408443180240717,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.00932350737651013,"ministry_youth_development":0.006329168489248651,"ministry_women_affairs":0.007532876235304641,"ministry_education":0.015286770631894335,"ministry_health":0.008919205855372751,"ministry_environment":0.006367564776521582,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.1798108798893992,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.00033413826032576614,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.00017571043791847843,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.09383841622747612},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.02916235813258373,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.00013506984188266176,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.056165186989212426},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":24142079917.08173,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":68256514063.474655,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":2262142095.6067843,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":26608481963.956825,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.19907838367601832,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.5628511106659653,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.018653885397845894,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.21941662026017048,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.16314379144706112},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.46125381630419876,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.015286770631894335,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.1798108798893992,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"benue","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.0378855473926765,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.1816449009443852,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.6183928300090307,"federation_revenue_performance":2.180659128334706,"igr_performance":0.7459578551094758,"aids_grant_performance":0.8533893271185612,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0,"personnel_expenditure_performance":1.0825268611973606,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.0708486825405297,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.9763222267023292,"total_expenditure_performance":1.0378855473926765},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.9098715559201136,"satutory_allocation":0.745513496949106,"derivation":0.17290412116588724,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.17121600481029067,"igr":0.40139337097292804,"tax_revenue":0.16435805897100764,"personal_taxes":0.08779709604177538,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.04799161545453116,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.04757714328595561,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.0004144721685755482,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.03980548058724422,"lottery_tax":0.03764730612240516,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.0021581744648390645,"non_tax_revenue":0,"licances_general":0.07656096292923226,"fees_general":0.0015720872058046663,"fines_general":0.061809674324357945,"sales_general":0.000027747435811019658,"earnings_general":0.004044129943301548,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.00484313217492754,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.00019083421352329418,"repayments":0.0038782246665984977,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.00019513296490774958,"domestic_aids":0.09012844407988642,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.04984552453964646,"capital_development_fund":0.04028291954023996,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":1.0024902112662426,"derivation":0.821401634324706,"vat":0.19050456938519025,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.18864461441577413,"tax_revenue":0.4422524505237417,"personal_taxes":0.1810885769415365,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.09673423549379506,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.052876831243909496,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.052420168664300555,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.00045666257960894004,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.043857404249885566,"property_tax":0.041479542494422705,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0,"non_tax_revenue":0.0023778617554628587,"licances_general":0,"fees_general":0.08435434144774141,"fines_general":0.0017321148516202755,"sales_general":0.06810147329978038,"earnings_general":0.00003057193359578754,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.004455794507334246,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.005336129660986711,"repayments":0.00021025982160562378,"investment_income":0.004273001216555929,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.00021499615626247078,"foreign_aids":0.09930289869911706,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.05491945550039173,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.044383443198725336,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.3038472968847755,"ovetimes_payments":0.3038472968847755,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.3038472968847755,"allowances":0.28402159578953445,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0.01982570109524109,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.2721810353296319,"materials_supplies_general":0.26298790971485086,"maintainance_services_general":0.09757062118378823,"training_general":0,"other_servies_general":0.0814783226185628,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.007370919965439597,"fuel_lubricant_general":0,"financial_general":0.07656804594706024,"miscellaneous_general":0,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":-0.005316287740229999,"public_debt_charges":-0.01982570109524109,"foreign_debt_interest":0.014509413355011092,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.014509413355011092,"domestic_debt_interest":0,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0.007117078764045437,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.007117078764045437,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.007392334590965655,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.007392334590965655,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.3315830795427781,"preservation_of_environment":0.03214646590836223,"other_capital_projects":0.15047581063793913},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.0025571314679905866,"personal_cost":0.1464036715284861,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.33477685818924474,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.33477685818924474,"allowances":0.33477685818924474,"social_contribution":0.3129330373222754,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0.02184382086696932,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0,"pension_arrears":0,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.29988718938942655,"maintainance_services_general":0.2897582669280147,"training_general":0.10750263815533803,"other_servies_general":0,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0897722544726672,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.008121228832027455,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0.08436214546798204,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":-0.005857449202778724,"foreign_debt_interest":-0.02184382086696932,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.015986371664190594,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.015986371664190594,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.00784154834530604,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.00784154834530604,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.008144823318884553,"capital_expenditure":0.008144823318884553,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.36533595242132866,"other_capital_projects":0.03541875464756983},"expenditure":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.1657932113773335,"recurrent_expenditure":0.002817429832707634,"capital_expenditure":0.16130655656371767,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":154972860487.75,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":98355702901.77,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":56617157585.98},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.6346640475771862,"governors_office":0.36533595242281386,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.5760283322107178,"state_assembly":0.3315830795427781,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":32746754114.35,"office_head_of_service":14957420970.719997,"office_auditor_general_state":11922704438.949999,"office_auditor_general_lga":3094276067.95,"civil_service_commission":1126345786.01,"lga_service_commission":0,"state_inec":843941412.7,"economic_sector":176833604.31,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":138421165.88,"ministry_finance":126337591.37,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":71898427.31,"ministry_labour_productivity":288574649.15,"ministry_science_tech":49139356478.90999,"ministry_transport":5689422019.350004,"ministry_energy":18046789616.55999,"ministry_works":1485014827.68,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":420422075.85,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":1964305407.82,"ministry_housing_urban_development":13755799250.249998,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":1589269384.89,"regional_sector":4884874696.07,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":1303459200.44,"state_capital_dev_agency":4678063038.28,"social_sector":3758021069.67,"ministry_youth_development":920041968.61,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":68408686856.21001,"ministry_sports":2749535322.8599997,"minsitry_lga":1407494042.8100002},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","admin_sector":34709754325.240005,"governors_office":16737198443.840002,"secretary_to_state_gov":4310367239.86,"state_assembly":1691307494.77,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":6803029986.830001,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.21130637978257732,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.09651638953803474,"civil_service_commission":0.07693414447779373,"lga_service_commission":0.01996656742476539,"state_inec":0.007268019590400826,"economic_sector":0,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.0054457368215338545,"ministry_finance":0.0011410617559276396,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0008931961728252343,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0008152239751648186,"ministry_science_tech":0.0004639420546502141,"ministry_transport":0.001862097971480868,"ministry_energy":0.31708362563646747,"ministry_works":0.036712376614978996,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.11645129063042076,"state_planning_commission":0.009582418644142842,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.0027128754965552414,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.012675157454212993,"law_justuce_sector":0.08876263370825126,"judiciary":0,"ministry_justice":0,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.01025514648101346,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.031520839717843835,"social_sector":0.008410886889048128,"ministry_youth_development":0.030186337295043764,"ministry_women_affairs":0.024249543164054713,"ministry_education":0.005936794130989055,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.4414236572818461},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.01774204408562338,"governors_office":0.009082196962580653,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.22397311513677953,"state_assembly":0.10800083570177742,"ministry_of_info":0.027813690902241523,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.010913572153472741,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.04389820233937088,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.19178408166776503,"lga_service_commission":0.08759937656632216,"state_inec":0.06982630748182164,"economic_sector":0.01812188444833635,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.006596537521122575,"ministry_finance":0,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.00494261288465043,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.001035640671199618,"ministry_science_tech":0.000810675039394026,"ministry_transport":0.0007399065829976458,"ministry_energy":0.0004210791031946102,"ministry_works":0.001690061368725942,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.28778871710900117,"state_planning_commission":0.03332057196848257,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.1056925202900225,"ministry_water_resources":0.00869711251365886,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.0024622367593499783,"law_justuce_sector":0,"judiciary":0.011504117551262868,"ministry_justice":0.08056197929123186,"regional_sector":0,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0,"state_capital_dev_agency":0,"social_sector":0.00930768797540936,"ministry_youth_development":0.028608673836084206,"ministry_women_affairs":0.007633816923498974,"ministry_education":0.027397464208133254,"ministry_health":0.022009162105594508,"ministry_environment":0.005388302102538749,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.4006411487685964,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.01610288168001086,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.008243105607064649,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.20328055522494712},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.09802279096224605,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.025244023265961417,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.009905282629527301,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.039842509398838995},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":32746754114.35,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":49139356478.90999,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":4678063038.28,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":68408686856.21001,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.21130637978257732,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.31708362563646747,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.030186337295043764,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.4414236572818461,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.19178408166776503},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.28778871710900117,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.027397464208133254,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.4006411487685964,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"nasarawa","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.0178020112095936,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":0.9396850834701443,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.3994556594916163,"federation_revenue_performance":1.5004719927774832,"igr_performance":0.962992467578139,"aids_grant_performance":0.22538172970911075,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.5693611159111592,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.7358319882047637,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.7865863519898841,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.9689617106724848,"total_expenditure_performance":1.0178020112095936},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.7600052133584134,"satutory_allocation":0.661715064174095,"derivation":0.2533465377264253,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.16280670427955135,"igr":0.2455618221681183,"tax_revenue":0.0982901491843185,"personal_taxes":0.06625376885470106,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.04321724572875096,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.042540170040648605,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.0006770756881023566,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.0230365231259501,"lottery_tax":0,"property_tax":0.00012640325313846852,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.00004124888736468723,"other_taxes_nec":0.0003135636744473755,"non_tax_revenue":0.02255530731099957,"licances_general":0.032036380329617434,"fees_general":0.0018589659636503754,"fines_general":0.023339800625105957,"sales_general":0.00008230886744799775,"earnings_general":0.0007981780254547208,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.0011336384150678668,"rent_on_land_others_general":0,"repayments":0.001205567850452182,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.0027576007348584196,"reimbursement":0.0008603198475799146,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.03715576618850332,"foreign_aids":0.03715576618850332,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.2028390204530833,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.1485029828885394,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0.04035928623385784,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0.013976751330686061,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.7016743477483453,"derivation":0.6109280277142621,"vat":0.23390203578729585,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.15031119001092744,"tax_revenue":0.22671480191603888,"personal_taxes":0.09074632003408314,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.0611687515162719,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.039900295649551665,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.039275185935203655,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.0006251097143480191,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.021268455866720232,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0.00011670172604115601,"withholding_tax":0,"other_taxes_nec":0.00003808300999550172,"non_tax_revenue":0.0002894974703833734,"licances_general":0.0208241736603002,"fees_general":0.02957756851781125,"fines_general":0.0017162891873685215,"sales_general":0.02154845663206574,"earnings_general":0.00007599161145917353,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.000736917373136337,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.0010466309723852997,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0.0011130397795488295,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.0025459531894942876,"miscellaneous_income":0.0007942897723530592,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.03430403837652764,"domestic_grants":0.03430403837652764,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.18727100139931546,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.13710528799735902,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0.037261686296322656,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0.01290402710563379,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.19213294504079126,"ovetimes_payments":0.15584532682212052,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.15584532682212052,"allowances":0.15584532682212052,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.036287618218670735,"gratuity_arrears":0.002183867395419697,"pension_arrears":0.029659944629050153,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0.0038115158580859575,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0.0006322903361149275,"utilities_general":0.2465826421686413,"materials_supplies_general":0.1760742920768626,"maintainance_services_general":0.02457709730521675,"training_general":0.014595455955359294,"other_servies_general":0.003819303020202212,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.01071651348560669,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.015381730327979681,"financial_general":0.0017325852885560064,"miscellaneous_general":0.009924031214402334,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0.09532757547953964,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0.01644533698290538,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0.01644533698290538,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.0540630131088733,"domestic_debt_interest":0.005698259868865937,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.005698259868865937,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.04836475324000736,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.04836475324000736,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.6444153777421157,"preservation_of_environment":0.028371326089744457,"other_capital_projects":0.5512700492808011},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.014237012491466257,"personal_cost":0.03909558349484014,"salaries_wages":0.011441406385263671,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.17738662383212905,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.14388410253702974,"allowances":0.14388410253702974,"social_contribution":0.14388410253702974,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.033502521295099334,"pension_arrears":0.0020162542352552795,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.027383525712771892,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0.003518979681516591,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.00058376166555557,"materials_supplies_general":0.22765727335629415,"maintainance_services_general":0.16256048231871845,"training_general":0.022690790034163744,"other_servies_general":0.013475245771421734,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.0035261691741709745,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.009894014511981082,"financial_general":0.014201173104369474,"miscellaneous_general":0.001599608306492752,"loans_advances":0.009162355740467882,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0.08801112567565081,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0.015183147297096276,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0.015183147297096276,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.049913643740479435,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.005260914933884139,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.005260914933884139,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.04465272880659529,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.04465272880659529,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0,"capital_expenditure":0,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.5949561028115767,"other_capital_projects":0.026193809435605595},"expenditure":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.5089597353589288,"recurrent_expenditure":0.013144313062920441,"capital_expenditure":0.036094973516511926,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0.010563271437610022,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":247984599986.07,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":100444648821.07,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":147539951165},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.40504389718842326,"governors_office":0.5949561028115767,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.4387155872094326,"state_assembly":0.6444153777421157,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":68932347387.7151,"office_head_of_service":27114814976.31146,"office_auditor_general_state":16032501462.869907,"office_auditor_general_lga":4798867644.43335,"civil_service_commission":1973803408.9893978,"lga_service_commission":7246601324.60118,"state_inec":11021781768.132912,"economic_sector":257010966.5659755,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":105241604.09,"ministry_finance":169831835.8727563,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":151437373.2944228,"ministry_labour_productivity":60455022.55373727,"ministry_science_tech":106602394705.11002,"ministry_transport":10228348197.596157,"ministry_energy":20331878907.982964,"ministry_works":3672445133.8860736,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":631956693.963665,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":304647441.36,"ministry_water_resources":4587920021.74751,"ministry_housing_urban_development":42938536601.56001,"ministry_land_survey":229054578.64,"law_justuce_sector":4731283174.670001,"judiciary":42806578.910000004,"ministry_justice":1232482502.3819978,"regional_sector":15129768182.995651,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":2541266689.415977,"state_capital_dev_agency":6263356265.769097,"social_sector":5263837214.008383,"ministry_youth_development":999519051.760714,"ministry_women_affairs":1388559.99,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":1388559.99,"ministry_environment":66156121093.485794,"ministry_sports":7074823007.046967,"minsitry_lga":6276424015.93738},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","admin_sector":23166389053.72377,"governors_office":18010297599.64784,"secretary_to_state_gov":10063897306.696499,"state_assembly":224036709.5033464,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":1340253400.93,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.27797027473313757,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.10934072106830252,"civil_service_commission":0.06465119795249584,"lga_service_commission":0.019351474425036538,"state_inec":0.007959378965872364,"economic_sector":0.029221981223867297,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.04444542834011481,"ministry_finance":0.0010363988996914023,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.0004243876599430437,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0006848483167192489,"ministry_science_tech":0.0006106724905616296,"ministry_transport":0.00024378539053285242,"ministry_energy":0.4298750596250661,"ministry_works":0.04124590074613792,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.08198847391783629,"state_planning_commission":0.014809166109880876,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0.0025483707214043285,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.001228493387803569,"ministry_land_survey":0.018500826349721822,"law_justuce_sector":0.17315001255711843,"judiciary":0.000923664528575027,"ministry_justice":0.01907893947824087,"regional_sector":0.00017261789204815368,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0049699961306114565,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.06101091835479112,"social_sector":0.010247679450896253,"ministry_youth_development":0.02525703719553927,"ministry_women_affairs":0.021226468152877508,"ministry_education":0.004030569042661762,"ministry_health":0.000005599379921487057,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0.000005599379921487057,"minsitry_lga":0.2667751186856037},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.028529283703279878,"governors_office":0.025309733008783385,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.0934186600902842,"state_assembly":0.0726266776269959,"ministry_of_info":0.04058275113560204,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0009034299287775579,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.00540458319188081,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.30107821189955025,"lga_service_commission":0.11843032071920859,"state_inec":0.07002571442356037,"economic_sector":0.02096018116722503,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.00862104981972039,"ministry_finance":0.03165123272080341,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.04814021968571345,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0011225557402974715,"ministry_science_tech":0.00045966741562763845,"ministry_transport":0.0007417804181335635,"ministry_energy":0.000661438283971383,"ministry_works":0.00026405150528893847,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.4656109881403022,"state_planning_commission":0.04467471227546014,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.08880425486953085,"ministry_water_resources":0.01604026637872304,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0.002760219238528943,"law_justuce_sector":0.0013306192285682762,"judiciary":0.020038817896575228,"ministry_justice":0.18754414018236437,"regional_sector":0.001000449652126986,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.02066499012731922,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.00018696778398201889,"social_sector":0.005383156704754648,"ministry_youth_development":0.06608281487020502,"ministry_women_affairs":0.011099578932163411,"ministry_education":0.027356679069421595,"ministry_health":0.022991044932939523,"ministry_environment":0.0043656341364820715,"ministry_sports":0.0000060648617774906005,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.0000060648617774906005,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.28895239172700177,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.030900950586910014,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.0274137555364696,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.10118464344807021},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.07866420341935308,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.04395643439789317,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0009785329305229448,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.00585387140778278},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":68932347387.7151,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":106602394705.11002,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":6263356265.769097,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":1388559.99},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":66156121093.485794,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.27797027473313757,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.4298750596250661,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.02525703719553927,"health_total_expenditure":0.000005599379921487057,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.2667751186856037,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.30107821189955025},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.4656109881403022,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.027356679069421595,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.0000060648617774906005,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.28895239172700177,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"niger","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}},{"indicators":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","budget_performance":1.023037618400649,"total_revenue_performance_excluding_opening_balance":1.0564244559378393,"recurrent_revenue_performance":1.0813217859505688,"federation_revenue_performance":1.1151888153945178,"igr_performance":0.9675235384477477,"aids_grant_performance":1.5146466843140307,"capital_reciepts_cdf_performance":0.7339788821497555,"personnel_expenditure_performance":0.9474603256912573,"other_recurrent_expenditure_performance":1.5679920610291054,"capital_expenditure_performance":0.7120097445749233,"total_expenditure_performance":1.023037618400649},"revenues_percantage_total_revenue":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0.6438428576304371,"satutory_allocation":0.5117177999528888,"derivation":0.3201575710265396,"vat":0,"other_federation_transfers":0.19156022892634914,"igr":0,"tax_revenue":0.13212505767754842,"personal_taxes":0.0997045600551483,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.06538850979404782,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.06461378270934479,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.000774727084703034,"other_personal_tax_nec":0,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0.03431605026110048,"lottery_tax":0.00002937826490436097,"property_tax":0,"capital_gain_tax":0.0000014834908175064591,"withholding_tax":0.0013948905100682194,"other_taxes_nec":0.010943504424881506,"non_tax_revenue":0.021946793570428887,"licances_general":0.03242049762240013,"fees_general":0.0018804108037417946,"fines_general":0.004832729868709904,"sales_general":0,"earnings_general":0.00007622027555858968,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.015077459140529987,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.007975134183501322,"repayments":0,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0.00000485791121296406,"reimbursement":0,"miscellaneous_income":0.002573685439145569,"aids_grants":0,"domestic_aids":0.19093032556771145,"foreign_aids":0,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0.18466874160986885,"capital_development_fund":0.006261583957842591,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.16522681680185144,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0.0002111468895397199,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.16501566991231173,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"revenues_percantage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","recurrent_revenue":0,"federation_revenue":0,"satutory_allocation":0.6648546723482507,"derivation":0.5284177127856392,"vat":0.3306059148781323,"other_federation_transfers":0,"igr":0.19781179790750686,"tax_revenue":0,"personal_taxes":0.13643695956261148,"personal_income_tax_paye":0.10295841884626715,"personal_income_tax_dat":0.0675224641218523,"penalty_for_offenses_interest":0.06672245381505906,"other_personal_tax_nec":0.0008000103067932224,"other_taxes":0,"sales_taxes":0,"lottery_tax":0.035435954724414874,"property_tax":0.000030337024719097623,"capital_gain_tax":0,"withholding_tax":0.0000015319045473841855,"other_taxes_nec":0.0014404127684917386,"non_tax_revenue":0.011300645743782598,"licances_general":0.022663027282874056,"fees_general":0.03347854071634433,"fines_general":0.0019417780192561686,"sales_general":0.004990446030936653,"earnings_general":0,"rent_on_government_building_general":0.00007870772461358417,"rent_on_land_others_general":0.015569512091217628,"repayments":0.008235402725471568,"investment_income":0,"interest_earned":0,"reimbursement":0.000005016449168480186,"miscellaneous_income":0,"aids_grants":0.0026576776756802507,"domestic_aids":0,"foreign_aids":0.1971613376497672,"domestic_grants":0,"foreign_grants":0,"capital_development_fund":0.1906954068697102,"other_capital_reciepts_cdf":0.006465930780056996,"sales_of_fixed_assets":0.17061899475321016,"domestic_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"domestic_loans_from_other_government_entities":0.00021803766928305565,"domestic_loans_from_other_entities":0.17040095708392708,"international_loans_from_financial_instituitions":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_government_entities":0,"internaitional_loans_from_other_entities":0,"foreign_debt_forgiveness":0,"domestic_debt_foregiveness":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_ppe":0,"gain_on_disposal_asset_investment_property":0,"minority_interest_share_of_surplus":0,"extraordinary_items":0,"unspecified_revenue":0},"expenditures_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0,"personal_cost":0,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0.2790355743576831,"ovetimes_payments":0.20057923986847315,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.20057923986847315,"allowances":0.20057923986847315,"social_contribution":0,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0.07845633448920998,"gratuity_arrears":0.008800835728656626,"pension_arrears":0.06951952781883271,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.0001359709417206461,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0.4122902709095461,"materials_supplies_general":0.2862102423762576,"maintainance_services_general":0.1414704480880805,"training_general":0.05789149454834624,"other_servies_general":0.02287199459047398,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.06397630514935683,"fuel_lubricant_general":0,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.12608002853328854,"domestic_debt_interest":0.0011085828862770276,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0011085828862770276,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_debt_principal":0.04685456166049122,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.0304430612477456,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.016411500412745614,"domestic_debt_principal":0,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0.07811688398652027,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.030627474487106877,"capital_expenditure":0.047489409499413396,"fixed_assets_purchased":0,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0.2770705342850115,"preservation_of_environment":0.013145620352439224,"other_capital_projects":0.15937279124524767},"expenditures_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","personal_expenditure":0.04429826766305975,"personal_cost":0.06025385502426486,"salaries_wages":0,"salaries":0,"ovetimes_payments":0.2881419016526077,"consolidated_revenue_charges":0.20712514431457846,"allowances":0.20712514431457846,"social_contribution":0.20712514431457846,"nhis_contribution":0,"contributory_pension":0,"group_life_insurance":0,"employee_comepensation_fund":0,"housing_fund_contribution":0,"social_benefit":0,"gratuity":0,"pension":0,"death_benefit":0,"gratuity_arrears":0.08101675733802928,"pension_arrears":0.009088051044476112,"severance_gratuity_for_all_political_office_holders":0.07178829793950345,"contribution_to_lg_pension":0.00014040835404972835,"payment_benefit_to_past_governors_deputies":0,"other_recurrent_expenditure":0,"overhead_costs":0,"transport_travelling_general":0,"utilities_general":0,"materials_supplies_general":0.4257453658595642,"maintainance_services_general":0.29555071499605684,"training_general":0.14608733683359337,"other_servies_general":0.059780783747987204,"consulting_professional_services_general":0.023618422242604156,"fuel_lubricant_general":0.0660641721718721,"financial_general":0,"miscellaneous_general":0,"loans_advances":0,"staff_loans_advances":0,"grants_contribution_general":0,"grants_to_other_states":0,"grants_to_lga":0,"grants_to_government_owned_companies":0,"grants_to_private_companies":0,"grants_to_communities_ngos_fbos_cbos":0,"subsidies_general":0,"subsidy_to_government_owned_companies":0,"meal_subsidy_to_government_owned_schools":0,"subsidy_to_private_companies":0,"public_debt_charges":0,"foreign_debt_interest":0,"foreign_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0,"foreign_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_debt_interest":0.13019465086350737,"domestic_interest__discount_treasury_bill__long_term_borrowing":0.0011447614940378085,"domestic_interest__discount_short_term_borrowing":0.0011447614940378085,"foreign_debt_principal":0,"foreign_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0.04838366050289805,"foreign_principal___short_term_borrowing":0.0314365706962077,"domestic_debt_principal":0.01694708980669035,"domestic_principal__treasury_bill_long_term_borrowing":0,"domestic_principal___short_term_borrowing":0,"transfers_payment":0,"transfer_to_fund_recurrent_expenditure_payment":0.08066622886657149,"capital_expenditure":0.03162700226251172,"fixed_assets_purchased":0.049039226604059766,"construction_provision":0,"rehabilitation_repairs":0,"preservation_of_environment":0.2861127324878281,"other_capital_projects":0.013574627735098918},"expenditure":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","total_expenditure":0.1645739230447528,"recurrent_expenditure":0.04574394183871487,"capital_expenditure":0.06222023986926155,"recurrent_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"capital_expenditure_total_expenditure":0,"recurrent_expenditure_total_revenue":176055349179.74918,"capital_expenditure_total_revenue":125683672156.78918,"recurrent_revenue_total_expenditure":50371677022.96},"expenditure_mda":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.7138872675119262,"governors_office":0.2861127324880738,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.6913258452663976,"state_assembly":0.2770705342850115,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":43421404977.35,"office_head_of_service":29639775683.449997,"office_auditor_general_state":5171621091.49,"office_auditor_general_lga":2593465706.83,"civil_service_commission":1868569706.35,"lga_service_commission":149648000,"state_inec":2737446453.87,"economic_sector":239410685.45,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":914536430.77,"ministry_finance":43372622.14,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0,"ministry_labour_productivity":63558597,"ministry_science_tech":82755464948.73842,"ministry_transport":3252269536.8906817,"ministry_energy":42426652976.15,"ministry_works":183674018.19,"ministry_culture_tourism":0,"state_planning_commission":0,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":8842699247.5,"ministry_water_resources":4947601825.906016,"ministry_housing_urban_development":19515766972.579998,"ministry_land_survey":258987546.36,"law_justuce_sector":2744198913.71,"judiciary":1488000,"ministry_justice":112899312.24999996,"regional_sector":211774845.1650442,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":257451754.03666654,"state_capital_dev_agency":8650313377.98,"social_sector":4829565841.23,"ministry_youth_development":3820747536.7499995,"ministry_women_affairs":0,"ministry_education":0,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":41228165875.680786,"ministry_sports":586040285.4633334,"minsitry_lga":3365059953.43},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","admin_sector":22312320530.88534,"governors_office":10699712420.404648,"secretary_to_state_gov":2277610498.197459,"state_assembly":78038770.43333334,"ministry_of_info":0,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":1909383416.8666666,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.24663496553564118,"office_auditor_general_lga":0.16835487147375963,"civil_service_commission":0.02937497278884399,"lga_service_commission":0.014730967953605848,"state_inec":0.010613535544669086,"economic_sector":0.0008500054141898507,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.015548783190181674,"ministry_finance":0.0013598603312266339,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.005194596103044221,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0002463578774631842,"ministry_science_tech":0,"ministry_transport":0.00036101485865705393,"ministry_energy":0.47005368103968026,"ministry_works":0.01847299472603575,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.24098474243345347,"state_planning_commission":0.0010432742830342211,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0,"ministry_water_resources":0,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0.05022681383264406,"ministry_land_survey":0.02810253621348568,"law_justuce_sector":0.11085017901181753,"judiciary":0.0014710575257520647,"ministry_justice":0.015587137377495236,"regional_sector":0.000008451887471362784,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.0006412716953839042,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.0012028878767474667,"social_sector":0.001462334176359459,"ministry_youth_development":0.04913405595612301,"ministry_women_affairs":0.02743208805484778,"ministry_education":0.021701967901275227,"ministry_health":0,"ministry_environment":0,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0.23417729746769697},"expenditure_mda_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","admin_sector":0.0033287275177563283,"governors_office":0.019113647890308904,"secretary_to_state_gov":0.12673469244087396,"state_assembly":0.060774707898657805,"ministry_of_info":0.012936900291908235,"ministry_of_internal_security_home_affairs":0.0004432627057164291,"office_head_of_service":0,"office_auditor_general_state":0.010845358722475298,"office_auditor_general_lga":0,"civil_service_commission":0.23884040769570655,"lga_service_commission":0.1630342480151716,"state_inec":0.028446617298162103,"economic_sector":0.014265416033571983,"ministry_of_agric_natural_resources":0.010278109395706562,"ministry_finance":0.0008231421657012542,"ministry_commerce_trade_business_industry_investment":0.015057385347814672,"ministry_labour_productivity":0.0013168838214565831,"ministry_science_tech":0.005030428059424202,"ministry_transport":0.00023857207660952213,"ministry_energy":0,"ministry_works":0.00034960548208805487,"ministry_culture_tourism":0.4551982829140301,"state_planning_commission":0.017889181212180656,"fiscal_responsibility_commission":0.23336875209988556,"ministry_water_resources":0.0010103030385702992,"ministry_housing_urban_development":0,"ministry_land_survey":0,"law_justuce_sector":0.04863946467197691,"judiciary":0.027214394325375268,"ministry_justice":0.10734691202776188,"regional_sector":0.0014245667820513765,"oil_producing_communities_dev_agency":0.015094527403949794,"state_capital_dev_agency":0.000008184777227650662,"social_sector":0.0006210051881191002,"ministry_youth_development":0.0011648722648495285,"ministry_women_affairs":0.0014161191220820079,"ministry_education":0.04758124190062673,"ministry_health":0.026565134755872858,"ministry_environment":0.021016107144753868,"ministry_sports":0,"minsitry_lga":0},"expenditure_by_sector":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.22677644704104583,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0032235276767111454,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0.018509587417011465,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.12272941732340906},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0.05885400709740518,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":0.01252804740531226,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":0.0004292539994063202,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":0,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0.010502606121790391},"expenditure_by_sector_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","admin_sector_total_expenditure":0,"economic_sector_total_expenditure":43421404977.35,"law_justice_sector_total_expenditure":82755464948.73842,"regional_sector_total_expenditure":8650313377.98,"social_sector_sector_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":41228165875.680786,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0.24663496553564118,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.47005368103968026,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0.04913405595612301,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0.23417729746769697,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0.23884040769570655},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_expenditure":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0.4551982829140301,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0.04758124190062673,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0.22677644704104583,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0},"expenditure_by_function_percentage_total_revenue":{"state":"kogi","year":"2023","general_public_service_total_expenditure":0,"public_order_safety_total_expenditure":0,"economic_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"environment_protection_total_expenditure":0,"housing_community_affairs_total_expenditure":0,"health_total_expenditure":0,"recreation_total_expenditure":0,"education_total_expenditure":0,"social_protection_total_expenditure":0}}]}}